Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde/gedesisteerde vrouw die nooit medisch is getransitioneerd, sinds ongeveer 2017 actief in de detrans- en desisters-gemeenschap, en ik identificeer me als radfem terwijl ik op mijn hoede ben voor adviezen van buitenaf. Ik ben mijn dysforie gaan begrijpen als haat tegen de associaties en genderrollen die verbonden zijn aan als vrouw gezien worden, en niet als iets dat mij definieert. Ik pleit voor niet-chirurgische therapeutische benaderingen om de bron van dysforie te vinden, voor een poortwachtersmodel en voor erkenning dat detransitioners en desisters bestaan zonder één enkel ‘type’. Ik ben kritisch over organisaties en online spelers die beweren ons te steunen, en ik deelde Zweedse detrans-documentaireberichtgeving. Ik heb geen medische ingrepen, geestelijke gezondheidsaandoeningen of suïcidale gedachten beschreven.
Volledig verhaal
I have been active in the detransition and desistance community for close to three years as of late 2019, and I draw a careful line between detransition — which I understand as the medical definition, applying to people who medically transitioned — and desisting, which I think of as the social and psychological process of re-identifying. I was never medically transitioned myself, and I also say I am not male or mtf; I distinguish myself from those who medically detransitioned while still wanting to take part in the conversation.
I have thought a lot about why I came to hate being seen as a woman. What I realized was that I hated being seen as a woman because I hated the associations that came with it — the assumptions, which I now see as gender roles rather than anything that defines me. My advice to others in that position is to focus more on who you are and less on how people perceive you, because you are a unique individual before anything else.
I describe myself as a radfem, though I note I am 'a bit allergic' to advice from parents, gender critical people and even radfems when it comes to this topic, and I get discouraged posting because most of the time I just want replies from other detransitioners and desisters. I am skeptical of outside actors: I questioned a new forum being promoted in the community, noting that everyone linking to it seemed to be empty, 7-12 month-old accounts active in incel and mgtow subreddits, and I asked who was behind it and whether it was for detrans/desisters only or allies too. I am also wary of organizations claiming to support us — I criticized the Norwegian patient organization PKI (Pasientorganisasjonen for kjønnsinkongurens) for vouching for complete liberalization of medical transition and informed consent in the same breath as claiming to work for detransitioners, for an interview that fed the 'most detransition because of transphobia' myth, and for using the term 'converted,' which doesn't cling well with me.
On what I want from advocacy, I have suggested opening up for conversations about non-surgical options like therapy aimed at finding the source of the dysphoria and the gender identification, for views on gender and sex outside the typical queer theory view, for promoting the fact that detransitioners and desisters actually exist with no general 'type' — everyone can end up in that situation and there is no way to distinguish us from those who keep transitioning — and for continuing to work toward a gatekeeping model as well as a therapeutic option for those who don't 'pass the test' or fall off. On sexual matters I have advised someone considering sex with a partner purely to please them never to do it to please anyone else, and to base any decision on what they want for themselves rather than what they want for themselves in relationship to others.
I shared a Swedish detrans/desistance documentary, 'The trans train: part 2,' with English subtitles, saying I thought the episode was quite good and hoping it would reach more people. I joke that I'm bad at clickbait. I have not described any medical interventions, surgeries, hormone use, mental health diagnoses, therapy experiences, family situation, relationships, fertility concerns, regret about specific changes, or suicidal ideation in the material I've posted.