Alle verhalen

Genderatheïst zonder geduld voor beide kanten

Vrouw · Gedetransitioneerd147
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde/gedesisteerde vrouw die zich identificeert als ‘genderatheïst’: ik geloof niet dat gender bestaat en ik vind dat sekse onveranderlijk is en dat ik een vrouw ben. In 2023 was ik actief in detrans-gemeenschappen, ontmoedigde ik anderen om testosteron te nemen en betoogde ik dat trauma de meeste transities aandrijft. Ik ben kritisch op zelfidentificatie van gender in vrouwenruimtes en op zowel linkse als rechtse kaders rond transkwesties, en vooral sceptisch over medische transitie. In deze reacties geef ik geen gedetailleerde medische of identiteitstijdlijn, maar mijn algemene standpunt is stevig kritisch op transitie zoals die momenteel wordt toegepast.

Volledig verhaal

I've been active in detrans spaces since at least April 2023, and my comments show a consistent set of views I've settled into rather than a step-by-step retelling of my own transition and detransition. I'll lay out what I've actually said. I describe myself as a "gender atheist" — I don't believe in gender at all, though I try to be aware of how language is used around me. My core position, stated early on, is that "Sex is immutable. Gender is a social construct when ppl think sex entails something it doesn't." I draw an analogy to race: biological inheritance is immutable, race is a modern concept invented a few hundred years ago, and yet it can still be a useful shorthand despite its obvious shortcomings. I've used blunt language in discussions about who counts as what sex, telling one person "You are clearly female" and arguing that being female "isn't a gender." I've also said "Gender is fake and g4y and as usual you are clearly female but thats not a gender," which drew heavy downvotes. On medical transition, I'm clearly skeptical and discouraging. When someone floated surrogacy as a way to earn money, I called it sexist exploitation — citing that women's teeth fall out and preeclampsia — and suggested donating blood instead. On the same thread I added "don't ruin your body with t," which tells me I view testosterone as damaging rather than therapeutic. I don't describe my own hormone use in these comments, but my framing suggests I see transition medicine as something to avoid. I've engaged with the question of who is "truly" trans and whether gender is even changeable: "what makes someone true trans vs fake trans. And if trans is a gender, is gender a thing you can change." I've expressed a kind of bleak hope about the current moment: "I am hopeful for the future, I think back in the day more folks were hurting themselves before they got to this point." I've also referenced trauma as a driver — describing someone's situation as "Caught between a rock and two bad ideas. The rock is trauma" — which suggests I see trauma as central to why people end up transitioning. On spaces and politics, I'm critical of gender-self-identification policies. I've argued that offering a "third space" doesn't solve the problem and suggested one possible explanation is that some get "gender euphoria from invading women's spaces." I've noted that men's-only spaces go back to prehistory (fraternal societies) and that early women's spaces were probably a byproduct. I've pushed back on the assumption that trans people are all left-wing: "Trans=!=leftism. There are PLENTY of conservative/racist/misogynist trans ppl" and "As if there ain't hella trans Republicans." I've been sharply critical of Matt Walsh, calling him a "radical xian zealot" who is "Homophobic, misogynist" and whose narrative on trans issues mirrors his employer and the right-wing community — while also saying the film (What Is a Woman, by context) should be judged on its own merits and that I can "poke my own holes in matt Walsh's narrative." I've been supportive of other detransitioners or skeptics: "Good to see posts like this. Why I joined this group" and I recommended reposting to another ("other") sub. In one thread about someone's partner or family member, I advised: "Him. Curb him. Tell him why. Write it down if you prefer. When he backlashes document everything" — a practical, documentation-oriented approach to conflict. I've also told someone being excluded, "They're excluding you by being inclusive of delusion," which captures my view of so-called inclusive spaces. I don't give a detailed timeline of my own dysphoria, coming out, hormones, surgeries, or the moment of detransition in these comments — that information isn't in what I've posted here. What is clear is that by 2023 I was firmly in a detrans/desisted identity, viewing gender as a false construct, viewing my own sex as immutable and female, discouraging others from taking testosterone, and engaging critically and often combatively in debates about trans ideology, women's spaces, and the politics around the gender debate. I use humor and internet shorthand, and I'm willing to take unpopular positions in the community (some of my comments were heavily downvoted). I don't describe my current mental health, relationships, or physical aftereffects of transition in these particular comments.