Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben als man geboren en ben gedetransitioneerd (mtftm) na een transitie vanwege steeds overweldigender dysforie die HRT nooit wezenlijk verlichtte, omdat mijn dysforie erin bestond fysiek vrouw te zijn in plaats van een transvrouw te zijn. Gezondheidsredenen, vruchtbaarheid en onbekende langetermijneffecten van oestrogeen, waren een belangrijke reden om te stoppen, en ik heb specifiek spijt van HRT vanwege de langetermijneffecten, terwijl ik de hele reis zie als een leerervaring. De werkelijkheid accepteren in plaats van transitioneren is wat mijn dysforie echt verminderde, al ervaar ik die nog steeds op een geherformuleerde manier. Ik identificeer me nu niet actief als iets, maar antwoord ‘ja’ als iemand vraagt of ik een man ben, en ik gebruik nog steeds mijn unisekse gekozen naam Sasha. Ik ben een gedesillusioneerde linkse persoon die nu publiekelijk betoogt dat transitioneren een stressberekening is die voor mij mislukte, en ik wil dat anderen dezelfde fouten vermijden.
Volledig verhaal
I was born male and grew up with what I now describe as increasingly overwhelming gender dysphoria. Looking back, my childhood was admittedly bad, though I'm not sure it counts as trauma; I definitely had what I call 'mental oddities,' nothing particularly bad or diagnosed. As my dysphoria got worse and worse when I was younger, I idealized transitioning as the solution. Years ago my dysphoria was so bad I thought I had to transition.
The decision to transition and start HRT happened the day I started considering it — a click moment. I went to an LGBT therapist to get a letter to start HRT. I showed up and got a letter after 20 minutes and that was that. That therapist told me I was their only client who had ever asked solely for a letter and didn't want therapy. I was in a Republican/conservative state and it took me all of one 20-minute counselor appointment (who had agreed beforehand to write the letter) and then two months of waiting for a doctor's appointment to get HRT. I could have done it faster even. HRT is not hard to get in the US.
I transitioned (male to female, i.e., lived as a trans woman), but I still had a lot of dysphoria after beginning because transitioning is a flawed process and transition in general just wasn't a good decision for my life. Transitioning didn't relieve my dysphoria meaningfully. My dysphoria is to be physically female, not to be a person who transitioned — being a cis woman is cool, being a trans woman is of no appeal to me. I knew and knew before I started transitioning that I'd never be a cis woman. While I had intense dysphoria when I was transitioning, it also felt fake, like I was pretending to be something I wasn't, and I felt like I was faking it too.
I detransitioned (mtftm) after lots of thinking on my own. My decision to detransition was a bit gradual, with lots of introspection over lots of time. Health reasons were a major reason I stopped: fertility, but also the relatively unknown long-term effects of HRT. Both the stress of being trans and the fact that transitioning didn't relieve my dysphoria played roles, but even if transitioning hadn't been so stressful I would still have detransitioned. I probably would have continued for a bit if my HRT results were better, but I would have detransitioned eventually. I'm thankful I didn't pass, as otherwise I might have continued ruining my body and mind for longer.
Doing HRT made me confront my issues with gender dysphoria, which is good, but I regret it because of estrogen's long-term effects. That said, I don't know how long it would have taken me to address dysphoria without transitioning. I don't particularly regret transitioning and detransitioning overall — I consider my journey a learning experience — but I wish someone had told me I had no chance of passing, that transitioning would increase stress rather than reduce it, and that there are other ways to handle gender dysphoria.
After detransitioning, the dysphoria started lessening after acceptance of reality. Accepting my situation and reality made dysphoria less impactful. I still have dysphoria but no desire to transition, and my life is much easier detransitioned. Around six months after stopping HRT, I completely stopped caring about — and even desiring — she/her pronouns; before that I cared a lot about she/her even after stopping HRT. I still use my chosen name, 'Sasha,' which is unisex and originated as a male name. Because of using Sasha online, I occasionally get mistaken for a woman or a trans woman and get referred to as she/her; when I was transitioning I would have loved that, but now it makes me feel uncomfortable. I don't actively identify as anything anymore, but if people ask me if I'm a man I say yeah — easy and straightforward, no need to attach weight to such labels.
I still consider being a woman a theoretical if impossible ideal form for me and I'm still unhappy with my current form and life, but it doesn't feel like it used to. I lost all the conviction I used to have regarding my dysphoria. Recently I realized I'm not even sure what dysphoria is supposed to feel like anymore; I still have it in a sense but it feels reframed and nothing like it used to. I also experience what I'd call both sides of gender dysphoria — the desire to be a woman is not mirrored by a same desire to be man, but both are dysphoria related to gender.
I now think transitioning is all about stress: does the stress of gender dysphoria outweigh the stress of transitioning? For me it didn't. I think idealized self is a better term than true self when it comes to transitioning — think about how close transitioning will get you to that idea and judge from there whether it's worth it. For me, transitioning was getting me nowhere close. I think most detransitioners detransition because it's easier to live as cis. I believe having gender dysphoria doesn't make you trans, and even identifying that way doesn't mean medical transition is a good idea. I think social media pushes people into transitioning and makes people think they have gender dysphoria, or exacerbates it, though saying it outright causes dysphoria is misleading and oversimplified. I think the idea of gender euphoria always seemed odd to me; any positive emotions I had were from psychological mechanisms like feeling good for doing the 'right' thing.
I'm still a leftist, just disillusioned and doubtful of the current transgender situation. I browse r/detrans daily but haven't clicked the join button. I initially came to the detrans subreddit to see if I related and if I had warning signs of detransitioning; I didn't find any, and then I still ended up detransitioning. If you don't want to honestly consider detransitioning, you're not going to find any warning signs of it. I believe the rates of detransition are going to go up dramatically. My motivation in speaking up isn't hatred — it's about making sure other people don't make the same mistakes and damage their lives. I have a couple of deep friendships I've had for a long time, though I've gone a month plus without messaging these people sometimes.