Alle verhalen

Drie jaar HRT, en vooral verloren tijd

Man · Gedetransitioneerd160
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben als man geboren, ben getransitioneerd en gebruikte drie jaar HRT, en identificeer me nu als gedetransitioneerde man die geen genderdysforie meer ervaart. Ik vind dat mijn lichaam niet is verwoest, vooral tijd verloren, en ik hield mijn transitie privé genoeg dat detransitioneren terug in mijn oude vriendschappen gemakkelijk was. Ik ben kritisch over hoe transmedische zorg wordt bewaakt (of liever, alleen bevestigt), sceptisch over sommige detrans-/genderkritische beweringen en politiek rechtsgeoriënteerd in mijn kritiek op genderideologie en CRT. Ik ben niet autistisch, heb geen genoemde diagnoses en heb geen activisme bedreven.

Volledig verhaal

I was born male and I don't recall experiencing gender dysphoria as a child at all. As I put it, I didn't think about gender as a child — I thought about friends, video games, sports, that kind of thing. I also don't remember my parents enforcing any kind of gender roles on me; I think parental pushback only happens the more extremely a kid deviates, and I didn't deviate too much. I transitioned and was on hormone therapy (HRT) for three years. I don't recall ever losing length or girth in my penis while on HRT, and I couldn't grow a beard before transition, so nothing changed there either — I only grow significant facial hair on and below my chin. I've idly considered a minor beard transplant just to get some shadow or razor burn along my jawline, but I recognize that's pretty vain and I'm not seriously considering it. These days I don't really experience gender dysphoria anymore. I don't think about "being a girl." I worry more about my penis size (it's fine, I guess) and my value as a man than I think about girl versus guy. I don't get jealous of girls — I am not a girl or woman. I compare myself to other men now, which can also be a mental challenge. My sexuality and self-image are oriented around being male; I think about things like whether I'm infertile, though I don't feel like my body was destroyed. My overall framing is: "I lost time trying to be something I'm not. All I lost was time." Detransitioning was easy for me, but I had kept it fairly contained — I didn't tell anyone at work, or really anyone outside my immediate family. Several of my best friends from high school, whom I saw less of after college during my transition, I never told, and I'm grateful for that because I think it would have changed our relationship. I feel I can have a more normal relationship with them now — we can still be "bros," so to speak. On the medical and psychological side, I'm quite critical of how trans medical care is being handled. I believe the pressure on psychologists to be only positive and only validating toward transition doesn't come from the psychologists' own ideology — it comes from other trans people who have decided that access to trans medical care matters more than the risk of quickly pushing someone through irreversible surgeries and treatments, and from a broader cultural attitude that institutions must defer to minorities when making policies affecting them. I think trans people will remain the dominant determinant of how this care is dispensed, and that as long as trans people treat giving teenagers surgeries and hormones as the top priority, no psychologist will push back for fear of being labeled a bigot. I'm skeptical of some claims made in detrans and gender-critical spaces too. When someone suggested transsexualism is rising because of pregnancies conceived on estrogen-based birth control, I called that ridiculous and "anti-science." I also pushed back hard on a poster who seemed to think a 16-year-old's body hadn't gone through male puberty — I told them 16-year-olds are well into male puberty and that the first step to figuring out who you are is being honest with yourself. I don't think estrogen radically changes a male's hips regardless of age, and I don't think puberty is a switch. Politically and culturally I lean conservative-critical of the left. I've said I'm tired of the narrative that boys and girls are exactly the same and that observational stereotypes are somehow morally wrong to reference. I've said I'd wholeheartedly agree that "gender ideology is corroding society," and I've compared that to what I see as racially essentialist victim-stacking like CRT. I'm critical of both gender-critical feminists (I think their notions are deeply flawed and they mistake being ignored for being right) and of blanket leftist orthodoxy. I do think a large section of men who transition do so with accompanying sexual compulsion — I've referenced MtFs on Grindr who seem sexually mentally ill — but I've also said many detrans males or males who regret transitioning did not do so out of sexual compulsion, and that those who did should be pitied rather than feared. I don't think most people are predators and reject that label for trans people generally. On autism: I'm not autistic, and most of the MtF friends I made weren't either, though I met many autistic trans people and agree they're overrepresented. I think autistic trans people are particularly bad at judging whether they pass. I'm not aware of any formal diagnosis of my own. I don't have any advocacy or activism. I've said I'm happy I don't know any other trans people in real life because it would be painful watching them go through the same sad things trans people go through during their "transformations." Overall, I feel I came through it with my body intact and mostly lost time rather than health.