Alle verhalen

Aan beide kanten verbannen, de gekozen naam behouden

Vrouw · Gedetransitioneerd24
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde persoon die actief is in r/detrans-discussies, verbannen van de meeste reguliere transsubs, en die een genuanceerd perspectief inbrengt dat kritisch is op zowel kritiekloze affirmatie als algemene antitrans-verhalen. Ik ben sceptisch over veelvuldig aangehaalde zelfmoordstatistieken onder transmensen, verwerp de framing „genderideologie” en verdedig de lange geschiedenis en legitimiteit van medische transitie, terwijl ik voorzichtigheid en detransitie-stemmen toch waardeer. Ik ben nooit teruggegaan naar mijn geboortenaam, waar ik een hekel aan had, en ik was dit jaar bij Pride, waar ik troost vond in de nabijheid van mensen die op mij leken. Ik houd ruimte voor zowel mensen die spijt hebben van transitie als mensen die een lang leven leefden en wensten dat ze eerder waren getransitioneerd.

Volledig verhaal

I am a detransitioned person who left school in 2014 and found no LGBT content in the curriculum at that time, no mention of Pride month either. I believe any discussion of trans people in schools is incredibly recent, in the last 2-3 years, and not in depth enough to 'capture' anyone; I think young people get most of their information from social media platforms rather than school indoctrination. I have been banned from most of the main trans subs, though I still engage in discussions on r/detrans and think people with my perspective should bring it into discussions there, since aside from help/vent posts that is what the sub is for. I am skeptical of statistics in this field, noting that the commonly cited '51% suicide rate in trans' is actually suicidal ideation from a very small group, and that no matter how presented, statistics are only an approximation of the truth. I bristle at the term 'gender ideology' and have asked others to explain what it means, arguing that criticism of it can slide into being entirely dismissive of gender/sex dysphoria and the truly positive treatments some trans people find. I push back on the idea that trans is a recent invention, pointing to over 100 years of medical transition history: the first SRS (orchiectomy) on Dora Richter in 1921, her later penectomy and vaginoplasty up to 1931, hormone therapy beginning with testosterone in the early 1930s and estrogen in the late 1940s, Michael Dillon as the first UK trans man to have top surgery in the 1940s and later phalloplasty, and historical trans people like Lucy Hicks Anderson (born 1886) and the medieval figure Eleanor Rykener. I argue gender variance has been noted since the beginning of recorded history, from the Priestesses of Inanna to the Kama Sutra, and that most trans people historically had to pursue and persuade doctors to prescribe anything, with commercialisation being intensely recent and mostly confined to the US. I have noted there is a lot of homophobia in the UK and that all homophobes are also transphobes (if A then B, though not if B then A); I went to Pride this year and found it nice to see other people who looked like me as the majority, nice to be normal. I am critical of the framing that 'cis women' erases women, pointing out the double standard that men are equally 'erased' by 'cis men' but this is never raised, and I question whether hyper-femininity in women is damaging to other women by reinforcing stereotypes. I have never gone back to my birth name, which I also hated, and advise others who find their current name too male to pick a more gender-neutral one rather than returning to their birth name. I recall a r/asktrans post asking what one thing people would change about their transition, where around a thousand answers were all the same: 'I wish I could have started sooner.' I hold a nuanced view of generational attitudes, recalling my grandmother telling me before she died at 76, 'I wish I had never been born a woman,' a 70-year-old lady who said if she had known about transgender years ago she would have done it but it was too late and she hadn't had a terrible life, and a detransitioner who said 'I wish I gave myself time to come to terms with my body' - leaving open the possibility that some people lived long miserable lives never knowing there was a balm as well.