Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Volledig verhaal
I was groomed as a young person, and that experience has shaped how I talk about transition and gender — when someone took offense at my bringing it up, I pushed back that my own experience of being groomed was mine to discuss. I ended up identifying as a desister rather than someone who went through medical detransition, and I've described myself as having a "desister experience."
For me, the turning point was medical rather than psychological: I explained to friends and family that I had taken a medication that removed most of my body dysmorphia and my dysphoria, and that I couldn't see any reason to transition anymore. My friends and family were chill with it. I've advised others to just be frank with the people in their lives, because if they care about you they won't mind.
I don't think transition resolves the underlying problem. I've told people considering transition that no matter how many surgeries and hormones you take, you won't have a cis man's body and you won't live as one, and that turning completely into the opposite sex is not something we can achieve. I've also said that most people can't pass as the opposite sex, and that a lot of the pictures of "passing" trans women on Reddit are heavily filtered and angled to hide masculine features — so passing wouldn't fulfil you either. My consistent advice has been to work with mental health issues to see if that can decrease dysphoria so you can live as your birth sex, because that usually has better results than "transing." I've said the majority of us who desist or detrans do so because of many other issues, not just whether we pass, and that treating underlying conditions can ease dysphoria. I've also encouraged people to explore their reasons for transitioning with a therapist, warning that detransitioning for money or because you don't pass won't resolve much.
On dating, I've said I wouldn't mind dating a detrans man, but I couldn't bring myself to date a trans woman, and I've wondered whether my desister experience has something to do with that. I've also observed that a lot of women with trans partners dated them before they came out and now feel stuck in the relationship.
I've acknowledged how hard letting go is — "Same, but I think we can live normal lives and let this whole gender identity behind us if we want. Its just difficult to let go" — and I've been blunt that there's no easy way to deal with these feelings, while wishing people the best.
I'm critical of how the subreddit is used. I told someone that "guess my gender" posts don't belong here, and that the whole thing is often used by trans people to validate themselves using us, telling people to specify their intent before posting. I've also been sharp with someone I read as not genuinely questioning their transition but just uncomfortable that people recognize them as trans, telling them to make peace with the fact that they will never be like a cis man, since the objective is to live as our birth sex.
I don't describe ongoing medical needs, surgeries, or fertility concerns in this material, and I don't describe my current mental health beyond having had dysmorphia and dysphoria that a medication addressed.