Alle verhalen

Online sinds 2019, schrijft over media in plaats van geneeskunde

Vrouw · Gedetransitioneerd148
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die sinds minstens 2019 actief is in online detrans- en gendercritische ruimtes, al gaan mijn berichten vooral over mediapolitiek en trans-gerelateerd discours en niet over mijn eigen medische geschiedenis. Ik ben kritisch over wat ik 'transprogrammering' noem, sceptisch over progressieve mediaframing en ben tegen schuld door associatie en gatekeeping in de gemeenschap. Ik heb in deze berichten geen operaties, diagnoses van mentale gezondheid of specifieke redenen voor transitie of detransitie beschreven. Mijn huidige identiteit is een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die kritisch is over hoe transitie wordt gepromoot, vooral voor jongeren en gezinnen.

Volledig verhaal

I've been active in detrans and gender-critical discussions online since at least late 2019, and most of what I've posted has been about the politics and media framing around these issues rather than a detailed account of my own transition. I'm female by birth. The first thing I ever posted, in November 2019, was just a factual correction — I pointed out that something people thought was a conspiracy turned out to be a pesticide that was actually causing the problem, linking to an article about scientific conspiracies that turned out to be true. Most of my activity has been arguing about how gender and trans issues are discussed in the media. In November 2019 I got into a back-and-forth about an article, where someone accused it of pushing 'transphobic right wing propaganda.' I responded that a reply like that 'is why we can't have nice things,' and I pushed back by asking what part of the article was actually stigmatising anyone. I also questioned a claim about people 'posting cruel things about themselves and people like them anonymously,' responding simply 'What?' I spent a lot of time in that same month arguing about the political leaning of UK newspapers. I said it was 'extra important' to see an alternative view given how extreme left Telegraph opinion pieces usually are, and I argued that the Telegraph, Guardian, and Independent — the big 'non tabloid' papers — are all very left-leaning and generally toe the line with progressive talking points, which is why it was great to see an alternative view in one of them. I got quite heated defending this, arguing with someone who apparently thought the Telegraph was a pro-Tory rag: 'How the fuck can it be a pro tory rag when it shits on Boris/Brexit/Trump on the daily? Do you know what it means when people say left/right?' I also joked, 'Next thing you'll be saying that Tommy Robinson is joining Labour.' I got frustrated with the person I was arguing with, eventually saying I wasn't going to go further because they appeared to be 'concern trolling' me, and asking 'Did you even read the articles?' I'm clearly sceptical of what I see as ideological gatekeeping and purity tests. In November 2019 I commented that 'Gatekeeping is what kills communities.' In December 2019 I made a comment that reveals something about how I view trans ideology and family dynamics: 'To be fair if you were deep in the whole trans programming you'd probably cut them off as transphobic.' I used the phrase 'trans programming' to describe being immersed in trans ideology, suggesting I see it as a kind of indoctrination. In the same period I commented on how parents today might be afraid to push back on a child's transition: 'But you can see in today's climate how parents would be apprehensive to try and talk you out of it?' I've also mocked what I see as the reflexive labelling of any critic as transphobic, writing: '"anyone not fully supporting every aspect is just a transphobe"®' — complete with a registered trademark symbol. I've also expressed views on biological sex. In June 2020, responding to someone who questioned whether biological sex was even a coherent concept because chromosomes and genitalia don't always agree, I responded dismissively: 'In such a small amount of people, let be honest' — implying that differences of sex development are rare exceptions that don't undermine the concept of biological sex. I've been critical of cancel culture and guilt by association. In January 2020 I responded to someone dismissing another commenter because they posted on T_D and MGTOW by asking, 'Guilt by association?' In March 2020 I offered simple encouragement to someone who seemed to be struggling: 'Chin up mate.' I was also active around the time of Reddit's June 2020 ban wave, when several communities were shut down. I suggested alternatives like detrans.win and Parler, saying Parler was 'a nice twitter alternative' and not to believe it's all 'alt-right hate-mongers.' I noted the irony that 'what a timeline we live in where a trans community would be accepted with open arms on .win and is being shut down on reddit for wrongthink.' I was aware of community migrations to other platforms after the ban wave. My final comment, in July 2020, was the meme 'THEY DO IT FOR FREE,' a joke about unpaid internet moderators. I don't have detailed information in these posts about my own medical transition, surgeries, mental health, or the specific reasons I transitioned or detransitioned. What comes through is that I'm politically engaged, sceptical of progressive media framing, critical of what I see as trans ideology's influence on families and public discourse, and opposed to gatekeeping and guilt by association.