Alle verhalen

Eén telegeneeskundeafspraak, een leven lang verbergen

Man · GedetransitioneerdTransitie 18 → Detransitie 19831
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw (als man geboren) die zich vanaf ongeveer mijn 12e of 13e als homo identificeerde, op mijn 18e transitioneerde en op mijn 19e gedetransitioneerd was. Ik kreeg oestrogeen en spiro voorgeschreven na één enkele telegeneeskundeafspraak bij een kliniek met geïnformeerde toestemming in Connecticut, begon en stopte herhaaldelijk met hormonen tijdens manische fasen en loog tegen mijn zorgverlener om herhaalrecepten te krijgen. HRT liet me gynaecomastie na die ik verberg met een compressieshirt, en ik worstel nog met schaamte, depressie en het gevoel emotioneel onderontwikkeld te zijn, al heb ik geen verlangen om vrouwelijk of een vrouw te zijn. Ik ben nu sterk tegen transitie als behandeling, bepleit therapie en DBT in plaats daarvan, en betoog dat mijn homo-identiteit zelf werd beïnvloed door vroege blootstelling aan porno en online cultuur en niet aangeboren was. Ik identificeer me momenteel als gedetransitioneerd persoon die kritisch is over zowel trans- als homo-'ideologie', waarschijnlijk biseksueel maar niet geïnteresseerd in relaties met mannen.

Volledig verhaal

I was born male and grew up as an effeminate boy. I had a strained relationship with my dad, and because my brother had developmental delays, I was closer with my sister. My parents didn't really enforce many gender roles. Around middle school I got into a rabbit hole of LGBT YouTube and Tumblr content, and from about 12-13 I identified as gay — it kind of became my entire personality. I look back now and think I self-sorted into being gay because I saw other feminine men being gay, and because everyone assumes an effeminate boy is gay. In elementary and early middle school I had many 'girlfriends' and girl crushes, so I clearly was interested in women before that. During my questioning phase I watched hundreds of hours of gay porn starting around age 11 to 'see if I was gay,' and I now feel that the porn may have made me gay rather than the other way around. Around the same time I began chatting with adult men on Kik in LGBT group chats where we exchanged nudes — I describe this as not age-appropriate men, and I now see it as part of how I was influenced. I started identifying as a gay man and that identity structured most of my friendships and personality. I began hormones (estrogen and testosterone blockers) in June 2021, about three months after turning 18, after just one telehealth appointment with an APRN at an informed consent clinic in Connecticut — to this day I have never met that provider in person, and we only ever had three telehealth appointments total. I went into the office once where a nurse showed me how to inject estrogen. I was able to get spiro and E less than a month after turning 18. During transition I remember feeling really manically excited, like a new beginning, and everyone — family, friends, doctors — was encouraging me and cheering me on, which made it feel more right at the time. I stopped taking the hormones regularly around two months in and was going on and off them for months in what I now recognize as manic phases. On 10/4/2021 I messaged my APRN saying I wished to stop hormones, partly to break the cycle of restarting. I was still able to keep filling the prescription without directly contacting her. In May 2022 I contacted her to switch from injections to pills; our last communication was me expressing that I wanted to stop HRT, and we never discussed it. I then stopped again for a while, removed the prescription from MyChart, and in January 2023 decided to restart — she prescribed medication again after a brief text exchange. Our last actual telehealth appointment was September 2021; all contact after that was over MyChart, plus one or two phone calls with the pharmacy and a medical assistant. Reading those messages back made me cringe because I had lied — I wrote that I was in therapy and that I'd stopped transitioning because of social pressure, when really I was in a manic phase and constructing a believable story to get the medication. I note that I probably didn't even need to lie, since the only question they ever asked was 'do you smoke cigarettes?' By 19 I was detransitioning. Since detransitioning I've been reevaluating not just my gender identity but my sexuality. Every sexual encounter I've had with a man has been bad and upsetting to recall, and I'm no longer sure I'm attracted to men at all, even though I genuinely believed I was — now the thought makes me feel a little ill. I would likely label myself bisexual if I had to, but I'm not really interested in men past a sexual relationship. I now say I feel just as much groomed into gay ideology as into trans ideology; the only difference is that thinking I was gay had no physical repercussions for my body. I've come to disagree with the concept of sexuality itself, believing anybody can be attracted to anyone if they feel they are supposed to be or really want to be, and I argue that homosexuality is not innate but shaped by socialization. Medically, HRT left me with small breasts (gynecomastia) that I have to hide with a compression shirt. When I take the shirt off, which is rarely, I hate my body. I say I can get surgery to remove them but my chest will probably never look the same. I've described being able to get spiro and E after one telehealth appointment and now having 'boobies until I can afford surgery to remove them.' I also dealt with sexual functioning problems after hormones — erections that felt diminished — and I was masturbating every day hoping to get functioning back, which I后来 came to think was part of the problem, both physically and because of anxiety about it. Mentally, I've described going through manic periods a few years ago where I was flip-flopping between taking HRT and not for months on end, finding it confusing because whenever I felt not trans it felt real, and whenever I felt trans it felt just as real. I've told someone else with similar feelings that they were describing autogynephilia (AGP) and OCD-fueled fetish, and that therapy and DBT (I corrected myself from CBT) help massively, recommending shrooms and therapy as what helped me. I've also advised others to give their body time to change back after testosterone and not to 'test' erections. Emotionally, detransition has been very hard. In January 2025 I wrote that I feel 'tainted and worthless' — that being transitioned for not even that long has totally emotionally stunted me. I have no desire to be a woman or to be feminine at all, I'm completely divorced from that concept, and yet I cannot get over the shame of having done this to myself. Every time I see my body I spiral into depression and mania. Even if I get gynecomastia surgery and get fitter, I don't see myself clearing this hurdle. I don't see myself ever dating or making more friends than the few I have. I said I just want a regular normal life but feel I've blown any chance of it and will be a recluse, too angry and cynical to move past it, joking darkly that 'when life gives you man boobs, become a raging incel and cry about it for all of your existence.' I later retracted the post, saying 'ugh forget I said ANYTHING.' I've also said detransitioning emotionally stunted me and that I've been detransitioned for a while now. On relationships, I've joked about wanting a 'detrans shawty' and made light of being single. On advice threads I've argued that partners have a reasonable right to ask the other to stop HRT, comparing HRT to medically assisted self-harm and saying it's much more reasonable to ask a partner to detransition than to transition. I now hold strongly critical views of transition. I say gender dysphoria is real but that the standard treatment should be therapy, not validating what I call a delusion. I compare gender dysphoria to other bodily dysphorias — saying the cure for weight dysphoria isn't liposuction, for racial dysphoria isn't skin bleaching, for height dysphoria isn't leg-lengthening surgery. I say research on transition outcomes is inconclusive at best and that there's no biological or chromosomal basis for transgenderism supported by meaningful data. I'm openly critical of informed consent clinics, calling the ease of getting HRT in some US states crazy and possibly malpractice, and I've posted my own MyChart messages to illustrate this. I've said I used to think transition could work for some people but now feel it isn't true. I acknowledge being transphobic in the sense of viewing trans people as mentally ill victims rather than wanting to hurt them. I've defended Chloe Cole as advocating on her own volition, and I've predicted that detransition rates will rise enough to cause mass concern and that the narrative will eventually shift to seeing those guided toward transition as victims of a for-profit medical industry. I also argue that the world wrongly assumes effeminate men are gay, and I feel disillusioned with sexuality as a concept, saying I feel tricked into a gay identity.