Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw — een kale, gebaarde, masculiene butch lesbienne die stopte met als trans identificeren en stopte met testosteron nadat ik het had genomen en top surgery had gehad, zonder verdere terugdraaiing na te streven. Ik heb geen spijt van transitie en beschouw het nog steeds als een noodzakelijk deel van mijn leven, waardoor ik me soms minder geldig voel in de detransitiegemeenschap en me ben gaan afvragen of ik misschien toch nog trans ben. De opmerking van een transman dat ik detransitioneerde omdat ik 'een lelijke man' was, deed mijn zelfbeeld pijn, hoewel ik over het algemeen tevreden ben met hoe ik eruitzie en het goed doe met daten. Ik blijf kritisch over transgenderisme als ideologie terwijl ik denk dat medische transitie gepast is bij echte vastgestelde genderdysforie, en ik verdedig openlijk masculiene gedetransitioneerde vrouwen tegen vijandigheid in detrans-ruimtes.
Volledig verhaal
I am a detransitioned woman who identified as trans and lived as a man for a period, took testosterone, and had top surgery, but I have stopped identifying as trans and stopped testosterone without pursuing any further reversal. I am a gender-nonconforming, masculine-presenting butch lesbian — I am completely bald by choice, I keep and like my facial hair, and I enjoy the other changes testosterone gave me, including a deep voice. I do not have breasts anymore, and I note it can be hard to wear feminine clothing without them, but I don't particularly care.
I first detransitioned around some point before February 2024 — I had another Reddit account and remember getting a lot of support from this community back then, whereas more recently I've seen hostility toward masculine detransitioned women. I have been opening up about my detransition in trans spaces on Facebook because I'm still gender-nonconforming and still move in those spaces.
I don't regret transition at all. I wrote that I keep waiting to hate my masculine features, deep voice, and top surgery, but no matter how much I try, I still think transitioning was a necessary part of my life. I don't care that people read me as a man or misgender me as a man when I'm actually a woman. The biggest part of detransition for me was 'just to stop the delusion that I was a man or that I could ever be a man' — once I did that, everything else stopped mattering. Because I don't regret it, I sometimes feel less valid within the detransition community, and I've wondered whether I'm actually still trans since all I've done is stop identifying as trans and stop testosterone.
I don't see the point in spending all my time trying to look like a stereotypical woman after testosterone, because I believe women come in all forms, including bearded and hairy ones. I like the way I look, but I've started feeling ugly after seeing cruel comments directed at other masculine detransitioned women here — for instance, I saw a woman called a 'bearded woman freakshow with a pcos beard' for saying she keeps her facial hair trimmed. I said I would start commenting in defense of these women.
A trans man recently told me he looked through my profile and saw I was an 'ugly man' and that this was obviously why I detransitioned. That got me feeling really bad about myself, because up until then I had considered myself quite attractive — I do well dating and had never been told I'm ugly. I also said I used to think I was lucky not to get a 'pcos beard,' but now I'd take looking like a woman with pcos over 'a weird gay man' any day, because I'm tired of being called a man even in my detransition.
I hold mixed but generally critical views on gender ideology: I believe some people are genuinely mentally ill and diagnosed with gender dysphoria, and that medical transition is the appropriate treatment for that, but I don't believe in 'transgenderism as a whole' and don't believe you can just be whatever gender you want to be. I'm quite critical of men in these spaces — I said men can be gross, make me uncomfortable, and that some men here seem jealous that women can look better than them in both masculine and feminine forms. I pushed back firmly when a male commenter engaged me, telling him 'you're a man so you have no idea what it's like to be a woman' and 'stay in your lane.' I also reacted strongly to a man who criticized women for not wanting to experience their period, saying it was 10x worse coming from someone who will never have one.
Overall my quality of life seems good: I date successfully, I like my appearance, I'm active in community discussion, and I don't experience the profound regret many detransitioners describe — though I do feel some alienation for not fitting the expected regret narrative.