Alle verhalen

Een jaar of twaalf verder, en het probleem was nooit haar lichaam

Vrouw · Gedetransitioneerd300
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die al jaren heen en weer gaat: ik bleef testosteron gebruiken omdat stoppen ernstige nood veroorzaakte, terwijl ik mentaal detransitioneerde en mezelf accepteerde als een vrouw met een transmasculiene ervaring. Ik begon met T in mijn vroege twintiger jaren, nadat ik jaren had gewacht omdat mijn ouders fundamentalistische christenen waren, en ik ben nu een jaar of twaalf uit de kast als trans. Ik begon te detransitioneren nadat ik was uitgekafferd omdat ik me tot hetzelfde geslacht aangetrokken voelde, en op een gegeven moment ben ik medisch geretransitioneerd, terwijl ik sociaal nooit meer wilde retransitioneren. Ik vind nu dat medische transitie het niet waard is: ik wil mijn vruchtbaarheid behouden om te kunnen bevallen en ik heb geconcludeerd dat mijn probleem in mijn hoofd zit en niet in mijn lichaam. Mijn dysforie komt nog in heftige periodes, maar ik werk aan een eenvoudiger leven waarin gender minder centraal staat.

Volledig verhaal

I was born female and I've been dysphoric for as long as I can remember — since my first memories, though I'm still not entirely sure why. My parents were and are fundamentalist Christians, so I couldn't transition as a young teen; I waited years and started testosterone in my very early twenties, and I'm now in my late twenties. I'm glad in hindsight that I went through my first puberty and fully developed before starting T. I spent about a dozen years out as trans. I like the changes testosterone gave me — I like looking superficially male, and I'm read as a man in day-to-day life by most people, based on my face and voice, with or without binding. When I first tried feminizing early on, people assumed I was a Black trans woman, which was uncomfortable. I've had bacterial vaginosis on and off for several months early in taking testosterone, which resolved eventually; I suspect it may have been linked to T but I'm unsure. My nose also got slightly bigger on T, and it looked smaller when I was off it. I've had bottom growth, and my partners have liked it. I tried going off hormones at one point and it didn't go well — I had never been more sad about being female, it felt like I was grieving my life, and it caused dysphoria. Because of that I prefer to stay on hormones. Sexually, T made my sexuality confusing rather than changing it: on T I had a high sex drive with no clear direction and identified as an aromantic, sex-favorable asexual, but off T I was blatantly and clearly attracted to women. Going back on T made me feel directionless again, so I think it's the T. I've gone back and forth about detransitioning for a long time. I identify strongly with my femaleness and have sentimental feelings about being a woman, a lesbian, and about motherhood — I feel a strong desire to give birth and breastfeed, and things about motherhood make me feel most sentimental about my body. I'm changing careers to a female-dominated field. I feel deeply connected to women. At the same time, I don't like that I want to be a man; I feel imposter syndrome when people address me as a man and I look in the mirror and see a female. I feel caught between a rock and a hard place — both transition and detransition give me distress for different reasons. I've largely let go of trying to be a cis man and have started accepting myself as a woman of transmasculine experience, or adjacent to men rather than a man. I like being a brother, a boyfriend, and the future concept of being a dad on a social level, and I wouldn't want to change my pronouns — I know lesbians who use he/him as an expression of masculinity, including me. I also value femininity and feminine traits over masculinity even though I present masculinely. I eventually started detransitioning because I was berated for being same-sex attracted. I decided everything transition-related is entirely cosmetic and doesn't make me a man to any degree, no matter how many people read me as one. I want to preserve my fertility — I want to be a parent in the future and give birth — and I don't want to remove organs off feelings. I decided my problem is in my brain, not my body, so I should have mental-health-related treatments. It was also the little things: it's annoying to inject myself every week, and I looked older on testosterone. I've had really bad bouts of "dysphoria" since detransitioning, and I did retransition at one point and have considered retransitioning — but only medically, not socially; I don't think I ever want to socially retransition. For me it goes up and down and feels normal. Lately I've concluded medical transition just isn't worth it — I don't want to be a patient forever, and the less I do to my body, the less I think about gender and the simpler my life is. I've struggled with dissociation, which I've called torture, and with feeling my body is "incomplete." I also felt that accepting I'm a woman was protective: if anyone called me a woman it couldn't hurt me because I'd already accepted the thing I was trying to obscure. I've been self-conscious in public — when someone calls me sir I feel I need to hunch over and hide my chest so they aren't uncomfortable if they see I have breasts, and I've felt weird dabbling in wearing bras while being read as a man. I've also dealt with feeling male-averse generally, which makes my own desire to be male confusing and aversive to myself. On politics and community: I'm a leftist, but I feel disconnected from the trans community and trans liberation spaces, and I don't like a lot of the popular rhetoric in activist spaces. I think the sexes of male and female are real and that acknowledging them is a good thing, and I'm dissatisfied with the circular logic of "a woman/man/nonbinary person is someone who identifies as one." I watched the Daily Wire/Matt Walsh documentary and wrote detailed notes — I found Walsh's buzzwords and the deceptive interview setup frustrating, I thought Scott Newgent's segment on the pharmaceutical industry profiting off transition was important, and I related strongly to the therapist Sara Stockton's concerned-but-supportive stance. I was upset by Dr. Marci Bowers dismissing BIID as a fetish, and disappointed by Dr. Michelle Forcier prescribing blockers and hormones to young children. I don't want this issue framed as conservative vs. progressive. I've advocated for better informed consent — I think people should be assessed for the full range of consequences including detransition — and I believe responsibility for treating gender dysphoria as a medical condition lies substantially with doctors. I also think detransition is a real possibility people should factor into their decisions, regardless of how long or intensely they've had dysphoria. I've given a lot of advice to others in the community — about waiting, about the lighter regret of waiting versus the heavier regret of transition, about bodies and self-acceptance — and I like seeing detrans and questioning stories because it makes me feel less alone. I do these conversations one-to-one with my inner circle, but I'm not vocal publicly; I just can't or don't know how to.