Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Volledig verhaal
I have been writing on r/detrans about transition, medicine, and gender for a couple of years now, and my thinking has sharpened considerably over that time. I was born female, and while I have not laid out a full personal timeline of dysphoria, coming out, hormones, or surgery in these posts, my views are rooted in a strong conviction that the medical system has failed women like me and like others who trusted it.
Back in December 2023 I was arguing about medical accountability. I compared the situation to women who received mesh implants for incontinence after pregnancy, implants that fused with their flesh. My point was that blaming individuals for the failure of systems is cruel and misguided. I wrote that the medical community has been spreading propaganda for a long time, claiming that "transitioning" is not just safe, it is life-saving and reversible at the drop of a hat. I believe practitioners have only begun to admit the dangers and inefficacy of the treatment under relentless activism, and even then only in a very small part. I noted that information on mesh implants only became readily available because hundreds of women suffered first, and I see an parallel with what is happening around transition medicine now.
By December 2025 I was engaging more directly with people who were questioning their gender. One of my most strongly received comments was about attraction and self-perception: I argued that so much of the trans problem is the issue that "sometimes you just aren't your own type." We do not find ourselves attractive because we are not our own type, but that does not mean other people do not find us attractive. We are not meant to be attracted to ourselves; we are not autosexual. I extended this to body dysmorphia and dysphoria, saying it accounts for so much of plastic surgery, and I observed that in couples where one partner is trans, the trans partner sometimes slowly morphs into the other partner.
On December 13, 2025 I made a biological argument: the female body does not ever transition into male, calling the word itself a misnomer. I said the body simply reacts as a female body would to high levels of testosterone, with increased muscle mass and body hair, but also male pattern baldness, vaginal prolapse, and early menopause from lack of estrogen. In the same thread I told a person that what they were describing was an unsettled feeling about their body as female, that the paradigm of choosing a gender role is itself false, and that there is no choice to make. I was blunt that what they were doing was "plain doping," and I listed the risks: raised cholesterol and blood pressure, damage to muscles and tendons, increased risk of liver cancer and heart damage. I insisted hormones are not cosmetics; they control everything in the body, including how energy is stored in cells, and that taking them is an extreme health risk rather than a cosmetic or social consideration. I also pushed back on the weight given to others' opinions, telling them that the need for approval is a prison and that their essence, person, and health should not hinge on what other people perceive them as.
On December 15, 2025 I argued that ruminating on what gender you are is inconsequential and has no productive value, materially or existentially, comparing it to wondering whether other people are real or whether you are "actually a goth or a jock." I said the problem is not what gender you might be, the problem is that you think about it at all.
On December 17, 2025 I laid out what I see as two factors behind a large portion of the issue. The first is rumination and obsession about "what gender am I?", mixing up attributes with ontology. I said this constant self-awareness is neither healthy nor normal, does not disappear with changing the body, and needs to be treated as a problem in itself rather than through hormones or surgery. I suggested rumination can be caused by anxiety, trauma, low social skills often associated with autism, ADHD, or simply being young, and noted that many stop obsessing as they mature. My second factor was the belief that one has to find oneself attractive. I argued that difficulty reconciling not being one's own type can make people think they should look different, either by looking different in their own gender or by becoming the gender they are attracted to, and that this is more an expression of heterosexuality and lack of autosexuality than any true notion of being the opposite gender.
Most recently, on December 28, 2025, I advised someone dealing with doctors to ask specifically for what they want, for example a referral, rather than leaving them to figure it out, warning that at best it takes years and at worst they will give a nonsense diagnosis and send you to endless treatments for stress and anxiety, adding that if they could, they would just call most women hysteric.
Throughout these posts I have not described my own medical interventions, surgeries, mental health diagnoses, family situation, sexuality, or personal experience of regret in detail. What comes through is a firm critical stance toward transition medicine, a belief that the system rather than the individual bears responsibility, and a conviction that gender rumination is a psychological problem to be addressed rather than a identity to be affirmed.