Alle verhalen

Zonder hormonen gedetransitioneerd, luid in de reacties

Vrouw · Gedesisteerd195
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerd persoon die nooit testosteron heeft genomen en er fysiek vrouwelijk uitziet. Ik heb de details van mijn eigen transitietijdlijn of redenen niet gedeeld, maar ik post actief in detrans-ruimtes met kritiek op medische transitie bij jongeren, pubertijdremmers en wat ik zie als toxische ideologie en deugsignalering rond trans-onderwerpen. Ik onderschrijf AGP als echt en betuig medeleven met het misbruik dat detransitioners meemaken als ze uit de kast komen. In deze berichten heb ik geen suïcidale gedachten, zelfbeschadiging of problemen met mijn geestelijke gezondheid beschreven. Mijn huidige identiteit is gedetransitioneerd, al heb ik in deze reacties niet aangegeven of ik me als vrouw of man identificeer.

Volledig verhaal

I have been posting in the detrans community since April 2023, and my comments make clear that I never took testosterone — in one exchange I wrote directly, "i was never on T and u look just about as feminine as i do tbh," which tells you both that I did not medically transition with hormones and that I read myself as physically feminine-presenting now. Because I never went on hormones, I have not described any medical complications, irreversible changes, or fertility concerns from transition-related medicine. My engagement with the community has been largely ideological and argumentative rather than a detailed recounting of my own transition story. I have focused on criticizing the medical and cultural framework around youth transition. I argued that "there are children put on puberty blockers (chemical castration) and hormones every single day in the USA alone," and said it is "not much more of a leap" for "gender reassignment" surgeries to be planned for those children as well. I pushed back hard on the idea that a 16-year-old could consent to genital surgery: "are you seriously advocating that a 16 year old can be informed enough to be able to have the choice to chop off their own genitals? do you know how a 16 year old brain works? your bias is showing." I also commented on the David Reimer case, saying it "all the David Reimer case proves is that John Money was a twisted, horrible human being, and anyone who looks up to his work should be ashamed of themselves," and I emphasized that Reimer "was absolutely given female hormones as a small child, as well as had his genitals mutilated to make them 'female'. AS A SMALL CHILD." I noted that holding such views "is a very radical position to take in 2023," suggesting I feel culturally alienated from mainstream discourse on gender. On the question of who is genuinely trans, I said "it's oftentimes pretty easy to tell who's trans and who's not - solely because many will try to take every opportunity to tell you that they are," and I accused others of "twisting things to perfectly fit their narrative." I endorsed autogynephilia as a real phenomenon: "AGP is very real and anyone who says it isn't is fucking lying to themselves." I also expressed sympathy for the hostility detransitioners face, writing that "the abuse detrans people get when they come out about their detransition is indicative of how toxic the ideology is," and I compared it to what I see as performative allyship more broadly: "virtue signaling is a disease." In one thread I quoted Lucille Bluth — "Hurt people, hurt people" — to explain hostile behavior. At one point I questioned whether someone else was "still 100% supportive of the trans community," which suggests I see shifting away from unconditional support as a meaningful marker. Overall I come across as critical of current transition culture, particularly around minors, while framing my own position as a moderate or common-sense one that has been made "radical" by the current moment. I have not described my own age, my reasons for originally transitioning, my mental health history, my family or relationship situation, my sexuality, or the specific process that led me to detransition, so those parts of my story remain unclear from what I have posted.