Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die van mijn 15e tot 19e als transman/non-binair leefde, vanaf mijn 17e ongeveer 2,5 jaar testosteron nam en als tiener een dubbele mastectomie had, waar ik diep spijt van heb. Ik ben ongeveer 3 jaar van T af, ga weer voor vrouw door, en heb laserontharing en stemtraining gedaan om mijn lichamelijke terugkeer te helpen. Ik voel me seksueel geschonden door mijn mastectomie en vergelijk het met verkrachting, en ik koester intense woede jegens mijn chirurg, therapeut, endocrinoloog en in mindere mate mijn ouders. Op 31 juli 2024 postte ik dat ik suïcidaal was; ik zei dat ik elke dag aan zelfdoding denk maar niet denk dat ik het zal doen. Ik geloof nu dat transitie voor niemand een goed idee is, ben tegen medische transitie voor minderjarigen en onder-21-jarigen, en vermijd de trans-gemeenschap volledig.
Volledig verhaal
I was a dysphoric teen and thought I was a lesbian for a long time before realizing I was bi. I was a transmed type but unusual in that I was 'non-binary transmasc/transman' — essentially a masculine girl with issues. My therapist diagnosed me as a transsexual at 15 and literally wrote it down; I first said I was a trans man, then non-binary, then whatever. I started identifying as trans at 15, began testosterone at 17, and was on T for about 2.5 to nearly 3 years. I got a double mastectomy as a teenager — at 17, after two years on T — with only one referral needed, despite having extreme mental health issues at the time. My transition was motivated by social isolation and feeling sexually vulnerable, and I now believe a huge part of my dysphoria was discomfort and trauma around being sexualized from a young age and internalizing that my body was a sex object for being female. I was very suicidal at the time I started T, and my therapist used the 'would you rather have a living son or dead daughter' line on my dad. I passed as male — I was read as bio male about a year into HRT — and people were shocked when I told them I was trans.
I detransitioned and have now been off T for about 3 years. It took until year 2 off T to be consistently gendered female, and by year 3 I am gendered female always, even with a buzzcut. I did 6 laser sessions on my upper lip and chin (pale skin with dark hair, so it worked well — 12 sessions for about $120 on a Groupon) and my facial hair is almost completely gone. My voice lightened somewhat though it's still deep for a woman; I voice train, focusing on voice lightening rather than sounding hyper-feminine, and posted a recording of my progress. I still pass as androgynous at times and got asked by a frat boy if I was a transwoman, but most people assume I'm female. I peaked about 6 months ago (around January 2024) — I had been a transmed for two and a half years and made constant excuses for everyone involved, but now I realize what happened to me was deeply wrong.
I got a double mastectomy as a teenager and I regret it. I have healed a lot and my confidence has improved, but I still feel violated — sexually violated in a way that is hard to explain. My surgeon is a man who only does trans surgeries, and the more I think about how he encouraged me to get it, the more I feel he gets some kind of perverse kick out of these surgeries. I compare my mastectomy to rape — 'a middle aged man literally butchered me as a teenager and had his hands inside my body.' I have been sexually harassed many times and dealt with predatory sexual behavior, and when I focus on my feelings about my surgery and those incidents, there's something connecting them. I was never raped but had plenty of sexual harassment and men touching me when I didn't want to be touched or ogling me, and I now know those feelings spurred transition in the first place. I also feel betrayed by my dad, who was initially resistant but was gaslit by my therapist and media into validating my identity and approving the mastectomy; he told me before surgery that 'if you regret it, it's a reversible surgery,' which enrages me because I will literally never have breasts. I hold immense resentment at the medical professionals and, to a much lesser degree, at my parents. I don't trust my dad's judgment anymore.
On July 31, 2024 I posted that transition fucked me up and that I was feeling suicidal. I said I think about killing myself every day and it's basically a constant loop, that I was suicidal back then and am now exponentially more suicidal, that I'm basically nonfunctional, and that I would rather die than live like this for 50+ years. I also said I think about killing myself every day but I don't think I'll do it. My only concern is my parents. I feel like a shell of a person and that my life is completely wrecked; I said I do think I am ruined, that just existing in my body is intensely triggering, and that I don't know how to cope. I also said it's amazing people recover from this stuff.
I now believe transitioning is a bad idea for anyone, though some trans people seem to have benefited in some way. I don't believe in gender identity and don't see trans people as the gender they ID as, though passing trans people take on a unique social role. I think medical transition should be banned for under 21s, and I think transitioning adults (21+, not 18-19) is malpractice while there is zero excuse for teenagers. I recommend detransition for pretty much everybody. I have no interest in building bridges with the trans community and avoid them. I compare detransition to recovery from addiction — staying in contact with trans friends held me back from processing my trauma. I have no patience for trans medical professionals anymore. I would rather be flat forever than ever let a trans surgeon touch me again, and I'm considering reconstruction with a breast cancer specialist instead. I have moderately strong facial features, am tall, and felt incredibly masculine as a child. I have male-typical behaviors. I'm in my early 20s. I'm bi and have been with men and women; sex with women is more uncomfortable for me because they have breasts and I don't, but men haven't cared. I agree with a lot of radfem principles (anti-porn, critical of the beauty industry/sex work, pro women's rights) but am sick of mindless hate from either side. I've made a detrans Spotify playlist as a coping outlet.