Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die als man leefde en iets meer dan zes jaar testosteron gebruikte voordat ik er ongeveer drie jaar geleden mee stopte. Ik detransitioneerde omdat ik besefte dat ik nooit echt man zou worden, dat de resultaten van operaties ontoereikend zouden zijn en levenslang hormonen en correcties zouden vereisen, en vanwege blijvende gezondheidseffecten van T, waaronder stemverdieping, zware lichaamsbeharing en ademhalingsproblemen door binden. Ik ben seksueel misbruikt en psychisch ziek, en depressie blijft een ernstige aanhoudende aandoening die ik met een psychiater en medicatie beheers. Ik ervaar nog steeds dysmorfie en zou technisch gezien nog steeds de diagnose trans krijgen, maar ik geloof niet meer dat transitie mogelijk of gezond is. Ik raad anderen nu aan de resultaten na een operatie zorgvuldig uit te zoeken en depressie psychiatrisch te behandelen in plaats van via lichamelijke veranderingen.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female and grew up with a masculine name I never liked, though over time I decided I'd rather keep it than change it to something feminine — it just felt weird, and I was used to it. Interestingly, nobody has ever asked me why I have a boy's name; people just assume it's a trendy choice.
I first wanted to transition when I was young — roughly 10 years before I was old enough to actually do it. Back then, around 15 years ago, trans communities still operated under the Real Life Experience standard: you had to find a therapist and spend a year living as your target sex before you could get hormones. I put off medical transition for years out of fear of surgery and medication. When a clinic near me started an informed-consent hormone model, the waitlist was so long it took me a little over six months to get an appointment — and they declined to treat me anyway, not because I wasn't a good fit (they actually praised my self-actualization), but because I'd lost my job in the meantime.
Eventually I moved to the Midwest and started seeing a new psychiatrist. It took only three sessions to be referred to an endocrinologist for hormones, despite intense mental health diagnoses in my medical history and the fact that I was in a clinical trial testing experimental medication at the time. I remember the doctor being flippant and dismissive when I described my dysphoria, but he wrote the letter anyway. The endocrinologist's office was equally blasé: they were supposed to have me take my first shot in the clinic under observation, but instead had me draw up saline and inject it into my thigh just to demonstrate intramuscular technique. Looking back, that seems irresponsible.
I was on testosterone for a little over six years. During that time I developed heavy body hair — on the underside of my arms, all over my face and down my neck — and a very deep voice. I shave my face every morning and have a five o'clock shadow by the time I leave work. Using public bathrooms became awkward: I know I no longer pass in the men's room, but I worry about making other women uncomfortable in the ladies' room. My orgasms on T were terrible, though thankfully they returned to normal after I stopped. I also had physical therapy to improve endurance and lung capacity even three years after I stopped binding; I still have trouble breathing sometimes and it doesn't just repair itself.
The biggest reason I detransitioned was the realization that I would never actually be male. I spent years working toward it, and when I was scheduling surgery, I saw that the possible results were not perfect — I would need revisions, I would carry scars, I would need hormones for the rest of my life to maintain a sort of maleness. I would never be a maintenance-free male. I also came to believe that nothing could change my sex, and that transition is not only impossible but deeply unhealthy, and for males, an appropriation of a lived experience that doesn't belong to them. I am still dysmorphic and would still technically be diagnosed as trans, but my understanding has evolved.
I was sexually abused and mentally ill, but I didn't rush into transition and none of my doctors ever considered the abuse part of the issue. I was diagnosed with dysphoria and still fit the definition. Depression has been a huge factor for me — without medication, some days I wake up wanting to just sit in bed and rot, and I could not function without seeing a psychiatrist.
It's been about three years since I stopped T. It took over a year for people to start regularly gendering me as female again. My voice will stay deep permanently, and body hair is here to stay — some follicles even kept activating after I stopped, so I have slightly more facial hair now than when I quit. My facial structure never fully redistributed, though I think age played a role. I've grown my hair out and that's the big decider: with my hair down I get gendered female nearly 100% of the time in person, but only about half the time on the phone or if I'm wearing a cap. It took more than a year for my period to come back. I still have an increased likelihood of organ damage and cancer down the line from long-term T use.
I'll probably never be comfortable wearing clothes from the women's section — I have no interest in figuring out women's clothing sizes and I'm more comfortable in men's clothes, even though I know that affects how people gender me. I was really androgynous and relatively tall when I started; I got called a dude plenty before hormones.
As for regret: I regret the permanent changes — the voice, the body hair, the lost time, the ongoing health concerns. But I've come to feel I can learn to tolerate myself as I am more easily than I could if I'd had surgery and hated the results. I advise others considering surgery to look hard at surgeon portfolios and remember those are their best work, and to ask whether they could live with the final results or worse. I also believe that at a certain age, nothing anyone could have said would have mattered — I would have needed to make my own mistakes. I try to help others in detransition communities by sharing the specifics of what happened to me physically and medically.