Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde (of, onder gedesisteerde mensen, geheridentificeerde) vrouw die het grootste deel van mijn studie rond 2013 transmasc/genderqueer en non-binair was, slechts ongeveer een maand online bestelde testosteron gebruikte en rond 2018 detransitioneerde zonder ooit een operatie te hebben gehad. Mijn transitie werd gedreven door seksueel misbruik door mijn moeder in mijn kindertijd, waardoor ik mijn borsten en heupen haatte en vrouw zijn met pijn associeerde, versterkt door Tumblr en trans-identificerende leeftijdsgenoten op de universiteit. Een zuurtrip, een steunende vriend, traumagerichte therapie en zorgen over het gebrek aan langetermijnonderzoek naar HRT brachten me richting detransitie. Ik leef nog met zware depressie en PTSS, maar ben veel gelukkiger en zelfverzekerder als vrouw, al verloor ik de meeste vrienden van mijn studie tijdens het proces. Ik ben kritisch op hoe gemakkelijk transitie wordt gepusht en pleit voor traumatherapie en wachten in plaats van haastig medische veranderingen door te voeren.
Volledig verhaal
I first started questioning my body and my place as a girl when I was around 9 years old — that was the first time I noticed an older man looking at me in a sexual way. Growing up, my mother sexually abused me; she molested me throughout my teenage years, and she would grope and fondle my breasts and hips. My mother also cut my hair but forced me to keep it long because her father preferred it that way. Because the abuse coincided with my developing breasts and hips, I came to associate being female — and being seen as female — with pain. When I looked in the mirror, I would see her face staring back at me. I hated my body not because I thought I was ugly, but because it felt violated and alien, like it didn't belong to me.
I first went to college around 2013, and it was the first time I was free of my mother. That's when I started using Tumblr heavily (the attitude then being very 'if you hate your breasts, you're trans') and got involved with the group of trans-identifying people on campus after I'd accepted being bi and started hanging out at the LGBT center. I finally felt like I had a safe place to talk about my feelings as I began processing the trauma, and everyone around me pushed the idea of transitioning — the prevailing attitude was that there's only one reason you'd hate your body, and it's because you're trans. I spent most of university identifying as transmasc/genderqueer and was fully out socially. I also used to identify as nonbinary at one point.
I eventually went on testosterone — but only illegally, ordering it online (I now tell people never to order testosterone online). I was on T for about a month before I realized that what I was really doing was running from my adolescent trauma. I quit after a month partly because it felt too good to be true: T made me feel amazing, and after feeling the starting effects I really began to question whether it was right for me. I didn't have any noticeable lasting effects from that month of T, and I never changed my name legally. I never went through with top surgery or any other surgery, despite having multiple friends who offered to help me set up appointments and drive me there.
Several things moved me toward detransitioning. An earth-shattering acid trip made me start wondering what the hell I was doing to myself with trying to transition. Then I started dating my partner, who encouraged those thoughts and helped me stop binding — it was a relief to no longer feel like I was being suffocated constantly, though there are still some lasting effects from binding. I got with a great therapist — a trauma-based, non-gender therapist rather than a gender therapist — and working through what ended up being a boatload of childhood trauma helped get to the root of my issues and alleviated the distress. I also came to realize that no matter how much I transitioned, I would still be female, and that my body was worthy of love and respect without having to alter it. Another factor that cemented my decision was the lack of studies on long-term cross-sex HRT and the experimental nature of the surgeries — I didn't want to be a human guinea pig. I also questioned the culture around transition itself: the cutesy nicknames for taking testosterone, euphemistic mastectomy fundraisers like 'Get this off my chest!', and the absence of honest talk about complications like atrophy and pain on social media.
I detransitioned around 2018 — as of October 2020 I said it had been almost 4 years since detrans, and in December 2021 I said I was 5 years out from making the decision to detrans. I became a radfem after detransitioning. I started seeing my boyfriend just before detransitioning, and we are still together; he had a lot of questions about why I detransitioned and why I'd started transitioning in the first place, and I can't imagine not being able to talk about that time with him. His love for the parts of me I hated most gave me permission to love them myself, and he really helped me come to terms with my chest.
Mental health-wise, I'm still dealing with major depression and PTSD, and I'm still affected by PTSD, though I no longer feel too overwhelmed to cope with triggers as they come. I use grounding techniques like the 5-4-3-2-1 countdown when I start feeling overwhelmed. Life is much less stressful without the additional layer of anxiety over 'am I doing enough to not be perceived as a woman?'
Family and social fallout: the only person in my family I speak to is my older sister, whose response to my detransition was relief rather than 'I told you so' — as it was for a lot of people who weren't in the trans community I was active in during college. I did end up losing most of my college friends over this process — partly because I became a radfem after detransing, and they sent me anons on my Tumblr telling me to kill myself, which did a number on my mental health. But I feel so much happier and more self-confident now with them out of my life. If that's all it took, it really wasn't friendship.
On sexuality and womanhood: I'd accepted being bi in college. I now accept being a woman in my own way — I don't shave, wear makeup, uncomfortable or revealing clothes or heels, and my hair will never go past my shoulders again. I see being GNC as one of the most freeing things a woman can do. If I could choose between a button to make myself male and a button to get rid of all society's sex stereotypes, I'd pick the second one. To me, being female means being of the sex that can get pregnant — it has no bearing on my personality or interests. I take comfort in my inalienable womanhood now; it's a security I never had in being trans.
On labels, I distinguish between 'detrans' and 'reidentified': I technically started medically transitioning but only for a month, so I walk the tightrope between the two. In general conversations with outsiders I call myself detransitioned because it's more self-explanatory, but within the desisted community I tend to say I'm a desister or reidentified, because I didn't have to cope with the physical differences someone on HRT for years would have.
As for my views on transition for others: I'm critical of how readily transition is pushed, especially on people whose discomfort stems from trauma. I advise people questioning to take care of physical health first, spend time recovering, and then come back to identity questions; to dig at the root of discomfort about being seen as a woman; to spend time in nature and get involved in hobby groups centered around something other than being trans; and that there is no harm in waiting and lots of possible harm from rushing. I've told people it's not worth becoming a lifelong patient just to escape how society treats women. I also believe detrans spaces should be closed spaces for detrans, desisted, and questioning people only, and I've pushed back against trans people posting in them. I haven't done formal advocacy or activism, but I'm active in the detrans community online, offering support, resources for PTSD recovery, and grounding techniques to others in crisis.