Alle verhalen

Drie jaar reageren, nooit een eigen tijdlijn

Vrouw · Gedetransitioneerd1K
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die sinds 2022 uitgebreid op r/detrans heeft gereageerd maar nooit een post heeft geschreven over mijn eigen medische tijdlijn. Ik ben kritisch over online genderideologie, echokamers en wat ik zie als medische overreach bij transitiebehandelingen, terwijl ik toch geloof dat een klein aantal mensen echt in het verkeerde lichaam is geboren. Ik heb gewaarschuwd voor complicaties van onderoperaties, gebrekkige spijtstudies bekritiseerd en weerstand geboden tegen druk van ouders of artsen om met hormonen door te gaan. Ik heb in dit transcript geen suïcidale gedachten of zelfbeschadiging gemeld. Ik identificeer me nu als gedetransitioneerde vrouw die actief blijft in de gemeenschap.

Volledig verhaal

I have been an active commenter in the r/detrans community since early 2022, and while I have not written a single post of my own, I have shared pieces of my thinking and experience across dozens of replies. I was born female, and I have commented in ways that suggest I have lived through a transition and come back from it — for instance telling someone "You look like a female" and, in a separate exchange, complimenting a poster by saying "When you were taking T pictures. You eyes haunt me," which implies I have seen pre-detransition photos of people on testosterone and relate to that look. I do not lay out a detailed personal timeline of dysphoria, coming out, hormones, or surgeries anywhere in this transcript, so I will not invent one. What I do talk about at length is the social and ideological pressure around gender, and how I see it. Early on, in January 2022, I told someone "I promise you can be who you are without gender" and "You are what you are not what people bully you into," and I compared the current wave of trans identification to subcultural fads, saying "It's a scene now... No different then the kids in the emo scene in the early 2000s." I have been blunt about friendships that only work when I conform: "If friends only like you when it's a the gender they prefer. They aren't your friends." I am highly critical of what I view as ideological conformity in online spaces. I recounted getting yelled at and kicked out of a Facebook group for defending r/detrans against the claim that it was "a bunch of conservative men trying to lie to the world" and "Republican propaganda," insisting "that Reddit has nothing to do with politics." I have described the dynamic as "Your only right when you agree with them on everything," and I warned about echo chambers generally: "just be very aware of echo Chambers socially. All of them." I also said "If you don't follow the pack they want you dead. I wish I was being dramatic," and elsewhere "Made the cult mad" after receiving heavy downvotes for defending detransitioners as "very real people making their own decisions." On the medical side, I have raised concerns about surgical outcomes and medical gatekeeping. I shared that a friend "has been suffering about 4 years with constant infections and blood infections" and "regrets the bottom" surgery, and I said both male and female bottom surgeries are "pretty much using you as the guinea pig." I have pushed back on doctors prescribing readily: "Maybe doctors shouldn't be throwing this around so easily." I also questioned the frequently cited detransition regret study, noting "about 250 of them were not followed up with and the study wasn't very long where most detransitions begin at the 5 to 10 year period... it really doesn't mean shit." I have asked others what they are doing to "clinically treat" OCD, suggesting mental health comorbidity is on my radar, and I have recounted being knocked out with fentanyl for wisdom teeth extraction without prior knowledge. I have been supportive of individuals while critical of the broader movement. I told someone considering stopping hormones against parental and doctor pressure: "You better stop taking this shit immediately and if your doctor and your parents are really forcing you you need to call... somebody." I have expressed that the "community" is self-serving: "It's never about you as a person it's always about them even when it's not about them" and "They say the word community a lot but, it's not about the community." I have also defended individuals' right to their own identity regardless of my views: "you are who you are...good ,bad or different or ugly." On sexuality and identity, I have commented on people's appearances in ways that read as gender-critical, saying things like "Looks like a butch female," "You look like a girl but non-binary that hates the patriarchy from her iPhone," and "Obviously women" when asked about a group. I have also said "you don't have to prove shit to shit... if you gotta prove what you are maybe you are not what you are." I have expressed that I do not personally experience hostility in the subreddit: "I have not experienced that personally. I find most of the people here are still very supportive." I have used cannabis and described its effects on me: "weed does a lot for me... One thing it does not do is make me relax. The very opposite," and I cope by telling myself "relax idiot your high af" and putting on something easy to watch. I have a sister who I described as "x Beyoncé was. Like real deal," which I believe refers to a past relationship. My most recent statement, in June 2025, captures where I have landed: "I believe some people truly are born with the wrong body. But there are very few truly. Most people are looking for something." I have not described any suicidal ideation, self-harm, or suicide attempts in this transcript. I continue to identify as someone who has detransitioned and remains active in the community, though I have not publicly detailed my full medical history here.