Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die als vrouw is geboren, me een tijd transmasculien identificeerde en op mijn 19e ongeveer een jaar testosteron nam voordat ik in 2018 stopte. Ik transitioneerde grotendeels vanwege een giftige, lesbofobe relatie en de Tumblr-retoriek dat je „geen dysforie nodig hebt”, en ik had geen echte genderdysforie totdat T me dysforie, paniekaanvallen en dissociatie gaf. Na de detransitie compenseerde ik door met hyperfeminiene gewoonten en kreeg ik mijn stem terug via training, en mijn vrienden en familie waren steunend. Ik heb spijt dat ik T nam en sommige dagen ben ik erg van streek door de lichamelijke veranderingen, maar ik ben nu veel gelukkiger en identificeer me als cis. Ik blijf een trans-bondgenoot, maar heb transmedicalistische opvattingen en pleit voor strengere psychische evaluatie vóór HRT.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female and grew up going by Sam, since my full name (Samantha) easily becomes Samuel/Sam. I never had gender dysphoria as a kid, but I had poor self-image issues and felt naturally masculine and like I couldn't fit in with 'normal' girls. During my 'most severe special snowflake phase' I identified as transmasculine/non-binary and socially presented as male.
The main push toward transition came from a toxic relationship lasting around five years with a lesbiphobic partner who guilted me into being her 'boyfriend,' telling me I'd both be safer if I were a man, that my body was naturally masculine and suited me, and that I didn't make an attractive girl. I also wanted to be like some male fictional characters I admired, and I genuinely thought I would be hotter as a man. I was heavily influenced by Tumblr rhetoric, particularly the idea that 'you don't need to be dysphoria to be trans,' which I now believe fucked me up badly.
I started testosterone at age 19, in 2017, through informed consent at a progressive medical facility — I paid about $15 a month after seeing a doctor for roughly two months and signing an informed consent paper, with no therapy and barely any follow-ups. I broke up with my partner only a month after starting T; in some ways I'm glad I took it because the aggression it gave me helped me leave her and begin my own life. I stayed on T for almost a year after she was out of my life because I couldn't admit I'd been mistaken and felt I was letting down my trans friends and my then-current partner, who is trans. I stopped T after pretty much exactly one year, in 2018.
I never had surgery — no top or bottom surgery, no hysterectomy. While on T I had terrible acne, felt massively insecure about looking so much younger than my age (I thought 'I can't wait until I look my age so I can be a hot party guy'), and I developed gender dysphoria that I had not previously had. My breaking point came around September 2018: I realized I had kidded and lied to myself for years due to negative influences, and I was so unhappy on testosterone that I wanted to kill myself. I also had panic attacks and was dissociating constantly during that period.
I began detransitioning around September–October 2018, a little over a month before my first comment here. Detransition involved a lot of overcompensating to feel 'worthy' of being female: I waxed all my body hair off, plucked out facial hair on my chin, started wearing heavy makeup daily, went on birth control, and bought a push-up bra and lots of panties. I did this because I didn't feel like a 'normal girl' or good enough to be one. Within about a month I was already much happier. With my doctors' help and a lot of effort I've been 'morphing myself into the girliest girl I can possibly be because I've missed being a girl for so many years.' I still have body image issues, mostly about blemished skin and my facial features, but I say I've never hated my body to the extent many trans or detrans people have.
My voice had dropped on T and I had a really low range. Through about 2–3 weeks of constant daily practice — singing along to female singers with mid-low alto ranges, watching many MTF voice training videos on YouTube, learning to talk from my throat rather than my chest, and re-learning nasality — I got my voice to pass as cis female. I also noted that some detrans women report a slight rise in voice over time even without training. My hair was cut short from before and I've been sad about it; I have old cosplaying experience with wigs and considered saving up for a human hair wig but worried about looking unnatural.
Everyone close to me was extremely supportive when I detransitioned, and I'm still close with all my trans/gnc friends. I identify as 'cis' deliberately, because that word was used as a dirty word in my life by people who said 'cis people are scum' on Tumblr. I remain a trans ally and supporter of transgender rights. I believe being trans is a real, rare, hardwired condition — I call myself 'truscum' or a transmedicalist — and I think non-binary people aren't trans unless medically transitioning. I think mental evaluation should be required before HRT and that informed consent access is too loose; I myself got T at 19 with no therapy. I think 'you don't need dysphoria to be trans' rhetoric is extremely harmful, and I openly say I was a 'transtrender' who medically transitioned without dysphoria and it gave me massive dysphoria. I don't think gender nonconforming people are automatically trans, and I think some confused, insecure teens use the idea of being trans as a coping mechanism. I'm critical of TERF/gender-critical anger but understand where it comes from, and I advise parents of trans-identified teens not to barrage their kids with gender-critical content because teenage rebellion against parental pressure was a gigantic contributor to my own decision to medically transition.
I regret taking testosterone because I never had gender dysphoria and never needed it beyond its initial mental effects. My body has been changed by it, which upsets me badly some days, but overall I'm working to reconcile with my body and am much happier. I don't regret my name — I kept Sam.