Alle verhalen

Op haar 4e twijfelen over gender, op haar 20e detransitioneren, terwijl ze nog testosteron nam

Vrouw · GedetransitioneerdEerste dysforie 4 → Transitie 15 → Detransitie 20114
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben vrouw geboren, begon rond mijn 4e te twijfelen over gender, transitioneerde rond mijn 15e sociaal en nam vanaf mijn 17e testosteron, en ging op mijn 20e volledig door voor man. In 2019 was ik mezelf gaan zien als 'een zelfhatende lesbienne' en een zeer GNC butch-lesbienne; ik geloofde dat trans zijn deels een afweermechanisme was tegen mannen die me hadden misbruikt, en ik was aan het detransitioneren terwijl ik nog hormonen nam en nog top surgery overwoog. Testosteron veranderde mijn seksualiteit, zodat ik alleen nog kon klaarkomen door mezelf als man voor te stellen, naast nieuwe fetisjen waarvan ik vermoed dat de hormonen ze veroorzaakt hebben. Mijn familie is accepterend, maar ik voel me een buitenstaander omdat ze me nu als hun zoon zien. Op het moment van dit account ben ik een gedetransitioneerde vrouw, en hoewel ik nog steeds wou dat ik als jongen was geboren, beschouw ik mezelf niet meer als trans.

Volledig verhaal

I was born female, and I started questioning gender very early — around age 4 I was, in my words, "outright fighting the fact that I was born a girl." I didn't have a name for those feelings until about age 12, when a friend taught me what being trans was. I got on Tumblr at around 11 or 12, and I often wonder how things might have been different had I not gone on hormones or gotten on Tumblr at such a young age. I started socially transitioning around 15 and got on testosterone at 17. By the time I was 20 (writing in 2019), I had been on hormones for about 3 years and completely passed as a man. I had no surgeries at that point; the only surgery I was still considering was top surgery, because my breasts had always bothered me a lot and that hadn't changed regardless of how I thought of myself — though I was starting to think of top surgery more like plastic surgery than as part of transitioning. My detransition was gradual and internal before it was anything else. Around 2019 I wrote that "detransitioning has meant a change in the way I think and perceive myself. I don't think of myself as a trans guy anymore. I think of myself as a very gnc butch lesbian." I hadn't fully decided whether to come off hormones or publicly come out about detransitioning. I liked how I looked after 3 years of testosterone and liked being referred to with he/him pronouns, but I didn't mind being called a woman — being called a man had always felt alienating and was feeling more so. I was treating the hormones as a health concern now, planning to get my levels checked; at my last check-up I'd been told I was healthy. As for causes, I came to believe I was "a self-hating lesbian," and I think being trans functioned as a defense mechanism against men. I had been abused by them and did not want to be the center of their attention, so becoming a man was "a pretty great way of alleviating that problem." I also had a lot of trauma and repression: I went through puberty at 8 but didn't really experience sexual attraction until maybe 16, which I attribute partly to repression and trauma. I'd spent almost a decade stressing about being a boy and not actually being a boy before concluding I wasn't a boy at all — and that plenty of girls can relate. Sexuality shifted noticeably. Before testosterone and identifying as a trans man I was a lesbian, though I "walked the line of being bisexual because I felt compelled to be attracted to men"; I was romantically attracted to women. I found women attractive but was sex-repulsed, so almost asexual at that time. Testosterone at 17 changed things: my sex drive steadily increased, but what got me off changed too. I couldn't watch lesbian porn because of body image issues and dysphoria, so I watched solo male porn and would imagine myself as the man. Eventually I didn't need visuals, but "the only thing that gets me off is thinking of myself as a man" — women had taken a backseat to that self-image, though I was still attracted to them and had a good relationship with one. I don't find sex fulfilling without fantasizing that way. This coincided with other fetishes, namely humiliation and exhibitionism, and I've wondered whether these manifested as a consequence of taking testosterone, citing a half-remembered Blanchard claim about AGP and hormone doses as loose support. I've speculated that getting on hormones may have made my penis envy worse. Family has been very accepting, but that has become its own problem: I've changed my relationship with my family to the point where I feel like an outsider. "They're their son now, not their daughter," and because everyone is so accepting I can't talk about the struggles I face now. On trans rights, I've pretty much always been in the camp of not wanting special treatment, especially for being trans, since that seemed to defeat the purpose of blending in; I think trans people deserve the same rights as any human being, nothing more and nothing less, and my transition/detransition hasn't changed that view. I've also commented on how I read sadness in the eyes of people in transition timeline photos, and I've tried to cut through the two entrenched narratives about SRS — the TRA narrative that surgeons never err and no one regrets, and the anti-TRA narrative that neovaginas are necrotic wounds and almost everyone regrets — arguing the truth is somewhere in the middle. I've advised someone with a no-depth result to get the neovagina closed and seek revisions. I've also argued that the David Reimer case has nothing to do with gender dysphoria generally, since David was literally the opposite sex due to a botched circumcision and it was Money's experiment gone wrong. As of my last writing in August 2019, I still wished I'd been born a guy, but I identified as a very GNC butch lesbian and was in the process of detransitioning.