Alle verhalen

Een tomboy die nooit getransitioneerd is en van buitenaf argumenteert

Vrouw · Gedesisteerd659
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde... nee, ik ben een heteroseksuele vrouw die nooit is getransitioneerd maar actief post in detrans-gemeenschappen, waar ik kritisch, therapie-eerst advies geef over genderdysforie. Ik omschrijf mezelf als tomboy die nooit aan haar sekse twijfelde, getrouwd is en in 2019 30 jaar oud is. Ik ben zeer kritisch over transbelangenbehartiging, puberteitsremmers, hormonen en operaties, en dring er bij mensen op aan trauma, OCD en geestelijke gezondheid te onderzoeken vóór enige medische stap, terwijl ik ook vijandigheid tegenover trans mensen afwijs. Ik heb nooit medische ingrepen gehad, dus ik meld geen persoonlijke spijt over transitie; mijn zorgen gaan over onomkeerbare lichamelijke schade en verloren tijd bij anderen. Ik blijf actief in deze discussies en pleit voor kritische therapie, loskomen van het internet en zelfacceptatie.

Volledig verhaal

I was born female and have always identified as a woman. I never questioned my sex — I describe myself as a heterosexual female and a 'tomboy' who has always been comfortable in my own body. I have never transitioned, taken hormones, or had any surgeries; my involvement in this community has been as someone offering advice and perspective to others who are questioning, transitioning, or detransitioning. I came to these discussions with strong views shaped by my own experiences. Growing up, I was a tomboy who liked sports, wanted to be seen as a strong leader, and found makeup and hair styling a waste of time. I never questioned my sex because, as I put it, 'I am me.' I also described struggling with insecurities around boyfriends: 'I always felt weird around my boyfriends and could never be myself due to my own insecurities.' That changed when I decided, 'fuck it, if they don't like the real me they can go to hell,' after which I started finding people who were into me as a tomboy and met my husband shortly after. That experience informs my advice to others: the key is not to be embarrassed of who you are. I have been critical of what I see as the excesses of trans advocacy. I believe trans advocacy groups are too powerful and pressure doctors into prescribing hormones, and that they are 'infiltrating every strata of our society trying to convince younger and younger people that they are trans.' I argue that everyone is gender non-conforming to different degrees and that this does not make everyone trans, and I have described the idea that not matching gender stereotypes means you should transition as 'the cognitive dissonance of the trans ideology.' I have recommended the Quillette article 'No One Is Born in the Wrong Body' and pointed people to the Kelsey Coalition's resources on adverse health effects of transitioning. At the same time, I have pushed back against hostility toward trans people. When someone in the community spoke of 'getting rid' of a group, I responded that I'm not a radfem, that trans people should have their own space and bathrooms, and that wishing to eliminate a social group 'automatically invalidates anything you have to say because it makes you an immoral being.' I also told someone posting hostile content in a detrans forum, 'Why are you posting in a detrans sub? Why do you feel the emotional need to do this? What is triggering you?' My consistent advice to people questioning their gender is to seek therapy first. I recommend finding a licensed psychotherapist who is 'critical of your views but empathetic at the same time,' and I describe my own approach to finding therapists: I tell them straight up I don't want any 'hippy-dippity' material and only want science-based information; if they're comfortable with that I book a session, if not I move on. I ask people to explore why they feel uncomfortable in their body, whether they have co-morbid conditions, trauma, abuse, or problems with their parents, and I suggest that medical intervention should be the last line of action after years of therapy because it radically and irreversibly alters the body. I have suggested trauma therapy for complex PTSD, therapy for OCD, and non-affirming sexologists for people stuck in loops about their sexuality. I have repeatedly said that 'a physical change won't solve a psychiatric problem' and that transition is 'only a bandaid that will not cure the festering wound you have.' I have also dealt with online communities myself. I was banned from a subreddit for telling the original poster she had the same responsibility as her husband for their awful relationship, and I noted that 'everyone seems to be in a damn cult nowadays' when advising someone to look for conservative friends. I am 30 years old as of September 2019, and I have said I need to 'gtfo of the online world pretty often because it's damn toxic,' advocating that people unplug and live real-life activities rather than spending their lives online. I have recommended Thinkspot, a subscription-based free-speech platform, as an alternative to Reddit. I have been sexually involved with men throughout — I describe myself as heterosexual, having had boyfriends and later a husband. I have no reported regrets about my own body, since I never transitioned; my concerns are directed at what I see as irreversible damage done to others by hormones and surgery, including loss of the ability to breastfeed after breast tissue removal. I continue to hold these views and to advise others accordingly.