Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde hetero vrouw die als homoseksuele transman leefde en ongeveer een jaar testosteron gebruikte voordat ik rond 2023 stopte. Ik detransitioneerde omdat ik geen levenslange medische patiënt wilde zijn, omdat ik nooit een biologische man zou worden en vanwege gezondheidsproblemen — waaronder chronische blaasklachten die zelfs zonder HRT aanhouden. Inbinden vanaf mijn 16e heeft mijn borsten blijvend laten inzakken en hangen, en ik word nu vaak als androgyn of man gelezen, wat daten als mannelijke hetero vrouw erg moeilijk maakt. Ik voel me prettiger zonder T, maar worstel nog met er niet uitzien als een typische vrouw, en ik wou dat ik andere opties dan medische transitie had onderzocht. Ik ben nu kritisch op transitie voor anderen en pleit ervoor dat mannelijke vrouwen en vrouwelijke mannen worden geaccepteerd zonder te transitioneren.
Volledig verhaal
I am a detransitioned woman — I was born female, lived as a gay trans man for a while, and was on testosterone for about a year before I decided to stop. I first started binding when I was 16, believing it was completely reversible; it wasn't. Years of binding left my breasts deflated and saggy, and a laser technician doing hair removal on my body was visibly surprised at the state of my chest. I can't wear normal bras anymore, and I feel ashamed and stupid about it, blaming myself more than anyone. I've been getting laser hair removal to undo some of what testosterone did to me.
I came off testosterone around a year before early 2024. My reasons for detransitioning were practical: I didn't want to be a medical patient for life, dependent on hormones forever, and testosterone was already changing my body in ways I didn't like. I also realized I would never be a biological man — I'd always be somewhere in between and wouldn't share the same experiences as men. If there were a magical button, I would choose to be male 100%, but I accept that transitioning wasn't going to get me there. I also had chronic bladder problems that I was not adequately warned about; I was told side effects were relatively rare, and the bladder issues persist even after coming off HRT. My family was very supportive and actually pushed me to go on HRT at a young age without really considering other options for my gender dysphoria. I do think my diagnosis of gender dysphoria was accurate, but I wish I had explored other options before medically transitioning.
I think a lot pushed me toward transition. I've always had masculine features bodywise and facially, not just in personality, and I was bullied and ridiculed by both women and men for it. I found men attractive and wanted to be an attractive guy — I wanted to be 'one of the boys.' I wanted to be a father, to travel the world without fear for my safety, to have the freedom not to always look attractive in order to be desirable and to age freely. Sometimes I recognize internalized sexism in myself — a belief that women are lesser in many ways. I also think I never got the love and acceptance I needed as a masculine woman; instead I was accepted as a feminine gay man but not as a masculine straight woman. I believe a lot of gay trans men today are transitioning for the wrong reasons.
When I presented as a man, I fully passed and had a beard; most of the gay men I had sex with were attracted to my masculinity and didn't even know I was trans until I told them. Getting sex from men was easy. As a detrans woman, though, dating has been brutal. I'm a straight, masculine woman and I feel invisible to men — I get ghosted constantly and men seem severely uninterested, while women flirt with me. Straight men can't get past the fact that I used to identify as a man, which makes committed relationships difficult. I sometimes feel the urge to transition again, at least partly because as a 'twink gay man' I'd get attention, but I know transitioning didn't solve anything for me.
Coming off T has been hard on my body and mind. Most people see me as androgynous, and when I open my mouth I'm gendered as male — even my own family sometimes slips up. I'm tall and slim, and I don't feel I pass as a woman. I hate wearing makeup because it emphasizes my masculine features, and I hate feminine clothes for the same reason. I wish I could afford surgery to fix some things. Since coming off T I've been more emotional — insecurity, overthinking, and anxiety are high. I generally don't feel good when my estrogen and progesterone are high; it makes me feel 'crazy.' I was more depressed on HRT than coming off it, and even when I did pass, I was exhausted by constantly worrying about passing and fixing my female mannerisms. It felt like an everyday burden while everyone else was enjoying life.
I'm Jewish, and before starting T I had very thick eyebrows and could grow a mustache and thick chin hairs, with normal E and T levels. I try to make peace with looking like a trans woman until I can afford surgeries. I don't go into female-exclusive spaces. I'm more comfortable with my body now than I was, although I wish I hadn't 'poisoned' it with T.
I'm quite critical of transition for others, especially post-puberty. I think trans spaces are horrible echo chambers that reinforce shallow stereotypes, and that people hugbox each other with filtered, angled timeline photos that create false hope about what hormones can do. I think estrogen barely does anything for males post-puberty and that most trans women don't pass. I believe you can be a masculine woman or a feminine man without being trans, and that if you don't have genuine genital/body dysphoria you shouldn't transition — and even if you do, transitioning isn't an ultimate cure. I've been vocal about all this in detrans communities, including pushing back against desisted males who leave insensitive comments toward detrans women, and against the takeover of lesbian spaces online.