Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Volledig verhaal
I have been open in these communities about my own views and experiences, and I want to lay out where I've landed on all of this.
First, on how people respond to us: when I shared my own experience, I got almost entirely positive responses. I think the truth is that very few people actually want someone to go through what I'd call the brutal medical marathon that is transitioning. There is also something that concerns people about treating mental distress with physical, sexual and surgical interventions, and I share that concern.
On what I think drives discomfort with sex characteristics: in my experience, there are usually psychological reasons people develop that discomfort. I've listed C-PTSD, RTS (religious trauma syndrome), depression, and ASD among them. I've suggested to others that treating any of those conditions may improve discomfort regarding the body, even if they don't seem related at first glance. I also try to make a distinction that expression — clothes, mannerisms — should be viewed separately from stuff like genitals or sex characteristics, even though society lumps them together.
I should be honest about my own transition-related experience here. I did have a powerful psychedelic experience that changed things for me. It just completely changed my priorities. It was like being reborn — a scary, scary trip, but it woke me up. That experience is part of what moved me toward where I am now.
I've also been on testosterone myself at one point. In an exchange with someone else who was on T, I recognized the pattern: it honestly sounded to me like they'd gotten what they wanted out on T but didn't want to go further, and that that was okay. I noted from my own knowledge that the voice is a permanent change but the other things are not, and that there are meds that can stop periods, certain forms of contraceptives.
On my own identity and how I present: I am not male. I present as a typical tomboy, but I do not have short hair. Anytime I've had short hair, I've been met with random homophobic insults from total strangers — which I find always amusing and frustrating, because it's rude, and also because I am heterosexual. I make concessions with things that I know would result in public insults. I've advised others to think about styles of expression that are somewhat gender-nonconforming but not beyond the point where you'd be 'clocked', noting this applies mostly to those who are impacted by such things, since some people don't care what others think. I've cited examples like Mr. Rogers, new wave and gothic musicians such as The Cure, and David Bowie.
On being female: I know how someone feeling bad about being female feels, and all I can say is there are some pros to being female — higher average intelligence, better social skills, etc. I've joked about watching Mulan. Being physically weaker is a disadvantage, sure, but there are ways around that.
On my broader views: personally, I never had transphobic thoughts. I just get annoyed at certain ideological tactics targeting people with any type of gender dysphoria or confusion. Something that serious isn't a race, and it's also a fact that being trans is extremely difficult socially — and on that basis alone, it isn't the right choice for all people with gender dysphoria. I know FTMs who don't regret a thing but are still never treated properly, even from a health care perspective.
I've also stated my view plainly: most dysphoria resolves itself into early adulthood. I think transmeds are right on the medical side, wrong on the presentation of it and outcomes.
I've engaged with others about dissociative identity disorder, asking what DID is like for them and how it impacts their sense of self, since I'd heard of people having alters but know there are many who don't. I've also told someone directly, 'I don't see anything, you look female to me,' and 'You have dysmorphia,' when they were distressed about their appearance.
As for my own current identity, I haven't laid out a full detransition timeline in these comments — what I've shared is that I'm female, heterosexual, not male-identifying now, that I've used testosterone at some point, and that a psychedelic experience shifted my priorities.