Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde man die zich als transvrouw identificeerde en detransitioneerde na ongeveer drie maanden oestrogeen. Ik groeide op in een streng religieus gezin met rigide gendernormen, en geïnternaliseerde homofobie deed voelen alsof de enige manier om met mannen te daten was om een vrouw te worden; ik stortte me halsoverkop in transitie op een dieptepunt na een break-up. Sinds mijn detransitie ervaar ik nog steeds genitale dysforie, ongemak met mijn borst en onbehagen bij gendergebonden taal zoals „meneer” of „bro”, al ben ik gelukkiger en emotioneel opener dan voorheen. Op dit moment identificeer ik me als bi, date ik liever mannen omdat dat makkelijker is, en worstelde ik onlangs met het vooruitzicht weer met een vrouw te daten omdat ik niet het gevoel heb de rol van een man te kunnen vervullen. Ik steun voorzichtige benaderingen van transitie en moedig anderen aan te vertragen en genderonconformiteit te verkennen vóór blijvende veranderingen.
Volledig verhaal
I grew up in a very strict, traditional, religious household with stringent gender norms, and I've had dysphoria since puberty. I was never comfortable with the men around me and felt restricted in what I could do because of my gender. Around grade 2 or 3, I was mocked at school for wearing a pink shirt — my teacher let me wear my jacket over it all day — and I remember another kid being called slurs for light-up shoes. That taught me to stay in my lane and present as a gender-conforming boy. I also struggled with internalized homophobia: because of my religious upbringing, I could only picture myself with a boyfriend if I was a girl in my imagination. I found it easier to come out as a straight trans woman than as a feminine gay/bi-ish man — I saw it as a choice between staying a man and dating women, or transitioning and dating men.
I decided to transition when I was at my lowest point after a really rough breakup, and I definitely rushed into it, though at the time I wouldn't have admitted that. I was on estrogen for about three months. I stopped cold turkey, which was rough at first, but my mental health improved over time. Being on E did improve my mental health while I was on it, along with softer skin and a drop in libido — my sex drive pretty much disappeared, which felt empowering because I don't like feeling controlled by it, and actual sex was still enjoyable even though I rarely initiated. I wish I could have had those effects without the other problems that come with HRT.
While transitioning I repressed masculine parts of myself and my 'boyish' interests because I wanted to be more girly. The constant pressure of trying to pass as a woman was exhausting — I'm an anxious person by nature, and always worrying about contour, my voice, and whether someone would say something drained me. I completely stopped improving myself because passing took all my energy. Dating was nearly impossible: the only guys who wanted me just wanted sex and didn't treat me like a person. I also found formal events like weddings deeply distressing — I can't stand wearing suits (I chose my career path specifically so I wouldn't need to wear them) and I felt envious watching women get ready with hair, makeup, and dress shopping.
After detransitioning I still struggle with genital dysphoria, shoulder width, and small hips. I used to like my chest, but I wanted breasts and got dysphoric about it; my chest didn't grow much on E, but I'm no longer comfortable with my shirt off, even when I'm alone. I also dealt with an eating disorder and body image issues. I still feel uncomfortable with gendered language like "bro," "sir," or "man" — I'm fine with male pronouns, but those terms throw me off because I associate them with a certain type of man rather than just physical sex. I feel sort of in between now.
I live in Toronto and found there was no detrans support group despite being in a big city. I've found that detrans people are few and often embarrassed or not open about their transition, so it's hard to find people in real life who relate. The best I've found is speaking with supportive friends who listen even if they can't relate. I also feel that detrans people are often used as pawns by both sides to push political views rather than treated as people with difficult issues.
On therapy: I was never pushed into transition — the therapists and psychiatrists I spoke to just tried to listen and help me figure it out on my own, though it didn't work out well for me. I'd recommend therapy to others and think it's always helpful if you have the means.
Currently I consider myself bi, though I generally prefer masculine traits and find it easier to date men. I've been exclusively male-attracted since a little before transitioning and have only been with men, only dominant men who led both socially and sexually. Recently I met a woman I really hit it off with, but I'm confused and lack the confidence to date a woman again — I don't really see myself as a man anymore even now and don't feel I could fill the role of a man after everything that's happened. I've been crushing hard and even thought about dressing more masculine, but I worry no one could be attracted to someone who has done what I've done and been intimate with men for most of my adult life. I consider myself gay in the sense that I prefer to be the more feminine partner, though I think I could be with a woman with the right personality — I just haven't met one and don't seek it out because straight women tend to have expectations about how a man should act that have caused me pain.
I still dress femininely as a man — women's crop tops and shorts, body hair shaving, occasional makeup — and I don't consider it cross-dressing, just dressing. I code-switch: with friends or somewhere safe my voice is higher and I might wear makeup or femme clothing, but at work or walking alone at night I present more masculine. I chose my career partly to avoid wearing suits. I still deal with the effects of childhood gender socialization as an adult.
I'm happy I attempted to transition because even after detransitioning I feel more open with my emotions and don't feel I need to conform to male stereotypes as much. I think if society were more accepting of men who don't conform to strict expectations, fewer people would question whether they're men at all. I believe people should slow down or stop transition if unsure, and that it's important to make sure it's really what you want before going through with it completely. I also think it's important to try dressing femininely without dressing female before considering permanent body changes, since transitioning can trap you in the opposite gender's roles. I don't think I was pushed into transition, but I also was never discouraged from it.