Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Volledig verhaal
I have never medically transitioned, and I don't claim to be 'detrans' in the strict sense, but I have questioned my gender several times and felt dysphoric at various points in life. I am a bisexual woman, currently almost 40 (I have said I have '40 years of experience' as a desisted 'tomboy'), and I go by she/her. I am very curvy and feminine-presenting but often wear men's clothes and keep my hair short; I don't wear dresses, heels, makeup, false nails, lashes or false hair, I can't cook, and I don't want children or marriage. I have described myself as a really short, overweight, really big-boobed, big-hipped, feminine-looking-by-nature woman.
What I eventually realised is that I wasn't questioning my gender so much as my gender roles. I said: 'it's cos I am not the stereotypical female society expects... I am everything that typical society claims a woman should not be. No wonder I feel dysphoric.' I envied how men are portrayed - tall, calm, powerful, deep authoritative voices - but in clear moments I see that 'I am not hateful of being born a woman, I just don't like my body.' My below-average height is, I've said, 'literally the only reason I have never gone through with it in moments of self-hatred.'
There are some family and personal factors I have shared. I have dissociative amnesia due to trauma. My mother repeatedly told me she wanted a boy, and my dad always told me I looked better with short hair, so I was never conditioned to be the girly girl like my sister, who is 'your everyday cishet picket fence soccer mom.' I was an early bloomer with big breasts, and even in my teens I would get asked 'are you a boy or a girl' - even on Xbox Live, because my voice isn't as squeaky as some women's. I have said I am not autistic, though I have speculated that autism and mental illness on both sides of the debate promote black-and-white thinking, and I've said my own 'weird brain thing is seeing TOO much grey in things.'
I have also dealt with vocal cord damage from a cough that lasted six months, which dropped my voice a tiny bit and made it permanently a little huskier due to thickening of the cords - changing both my speaking and singing voice. I had to rewire how I approached singing using YouTube videos and practice, and stop clearing my throat constantly because of cracking.
I work a 40-hour week, do a part-time university degree, have two side hustles (editing and art commissions), have multiple disabilities, and am working on a hobby comic project and writing a novel.
A lot of my activity has been around a FtM friend of mine. This friend is 31, spent 29 years of life extremely feminine, straight and cis, was lesbian for two weeks, then came out as trans and now identifies as a trans het male. They underwent testosterone and top surgery within 18 months of coming out, going overseas for the top surgery even though trans healthcare is free in their country. They have become severely depressed - not showering or changing clothes; I spent four days with them and they wore one outfit without showering the entire time. They started promoting 'self HRT' and overseas surgical clinics on social media, and the bottle of T gel they use looks suspiciously like bottles from those websites. They claim to have had cervical cancer and heart problems (I have doubted this), they are petrified of needles so they wouldn't inject, they have a mild CSA history (a horrible man touched them clothed as a pre-teen), no parental abuse, and untreated mental health issues they've claimed 'my doctor told me my mental health issues went away' about. Their period stopped for a couple of months, then returned and is apparently granular like 'wet sand' - nobody warned them. Their feet have gone up two sizes, their jaw is wider and brow more prominent on T. They adopted cliche man-traits (manspreading, body language, suddenly talking about boobs and sex non-stop) from the day they came out, but go 'awwww' around baby clothes. I have said they have 'become an utterly horrible person since transitioning, routinely calls people pedo/child beater now if you don't affirm/agree at every step.'
I have been active in the r/detrans community, largely offering advice and opinions to others rather than describing my own transition, since I never transitioned. I have been critical of transition language and gatekeeping, arguing that buzzwords like 'top surgery', 'T', 'E', 'bottom surgery' and 'puberty blockers' dumb down and 'other' what are actually radical, permanent medical procedures. I have advocated strongly for mandatory pre-transition therapy, saying 'it's amazing what therapy brings out of you' and that even 8-10 sessions could prevent regrettable transitions. I have said therapy in the UK is nearly impossible without paying privately, with 18-month waiting lists even for deeply suicidal people. I have been sceptical of trans activism, describing a 'growing stain' in the community that is 'radical and dangerous', and I have said trans people are 'brainwashed' into thinking detransitioners are grifters. I have also criticised both political sides for using detransitioners. I have been critical of children being given hormones and puberty blockers, and I have argued that biological sex is immutable and that trans people are 'trans' men or women, not the sex they identify as, while still supporting rights, respect and pronoun use for trans people. I have engaged heavily with debates about intersex conditions, autism and social contagion, and I have advised many people questioning their gender to seek therapy, step away from trans media, and consider that their real issue may be internalised homophobia, gender roles, or body dysmorphia rather than being trans.