Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw, als vrouw geboren, die een gewelddadige autogynefiele ex-partner verliet en daardoor vrienden verloor. Ik overleefde seksuele mensenhandel waarbij geen van mijn kinderen lang leefde, en ik ben een overlevende van vrouwelijke genitale verminking (VGV). Ik heb nu sterk kritische opvattingen over transitie van kinderen en wat ik trans-ideologie noem, geef de voorkeur aan therapie boven medisch ingrijpen en steun ruimtes en opvang alleen voor vrouwen. Ik heb mijn eigen medische transitietijdlijn, huidige geestelijke gezondheid of specifiek activisme dat ik zelf heb ondernomen niet beschreven.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female and grew up in Ireland. My first real brush with gender distress came in my teens, when I needed someone to tell me I could be a "stud without being trans" and to be shown the risks of transitioning — nobody did, and I ended up going down that path anyway. I desisted at some point, and the fallout was severe: a lot of transmasculine and female nonbinary friends, people I had been close to, dropped me or sided with my ex after I left.
My ex-partner was, by my own account, autogynephilic and abusive. He "went the whole nine yards with abuse," including claiming to be the mother of my late daughter — a daughter he sired, who did not survive. He also raped me. I describe the relationship as one that "was forced by my social circle in the first place," and I refer to leaving as "I escaped, depending on how you want to put it." Months after we broke up I sent him a nasty message, which is what I think triggered friends abandoning me for him.
I have also disclosed that I survived being a "broodmare in a trafficking context" and that "none of my kids survived very long." I spoke about this in the context of artificial wombs and trafficking, explaining from direct experience that traffickers prefer live women, that escaping is extremely rare, and that the most common ways out of trafficking are death or being discarded. Separately, I identify as an FGM survivor.
On transition medicine I hold firm views. I think the minimum age for hormones should be 18 and for surgery 21, and I have called it "evil that we allow teens to get parts chopped off anywhere in the world." I believe a lot of gender dysphoria is caused by trauma and difficulty with patriarchal gendered expectations, and that the real response should be wraparound support including psychotherapy that is not pro-transition. I argue cross-sex hormones are "disabling," and the earlier they start the more disabling, pointing to endocrinology costs, cancer and osteoporosis risk, and infertility. I have said hormones can be titrated rather than stopped cold turkey, but that a 17-year-old being on them is "a disgrace." I am also critical of DIY hormone markets for lacking blood tests and regulation.
I am politically left-leaning but conflicted — I said of Trump's executive orders that "obviously I don't like the guy but this is a rare good thing he's put into effect," and I don't believe he actually cares about the kids. I think gender surgeries should be privately funded, and I noted that taxpayer money going to "mutilation" makes me grateful gender surgeries don't exist in Ireland. I have advocated for women's shelters, legal support for people who lost opportunities for having boundaries, and female-only works like period supply distribution.
I hold strongly critical views of what I call trans ideology: I compare it to a religion ("is being non Muslim Islamophobia? If not, why is not believing in trans ideology transphobia?"), describe it as a "psyop" designed to destroy leftism from the core, and call child transition "child abuse" and "just woke FGM." I believe gender itself is "a patriarchal construct meant to control us" and that there is no "mind sex." I acknowledge autoandrophilia as real but distinguish it from a forced masculinization fetish. I have not described any specific therapy, formal activism, or advocacy work I have personally done beyond these opinions.