Alle verhalen

Mastectomie op haar 27e, spijt op haar 29e — en een lange weg terug

Vrouw · Gedetransitioneerd2,5K
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw van begin dertig die me ongeveer 7 jaar als trans/non-binair identificeerde, rond mijn 27e een mastectomie had en ongeveer twee jaar later spijt begon te krijgen. Mijn transitie werd gedreven door emotionele verwaarlozing in mijn kindertijd en CPTSS, geïnternaliseerde vrouwenhaat en angst voor seksualisering, de behoefte om aan mijn moeder te ontsnappen en bij een sektarische queer vriendengroep te passen, en het geloof dat ik te lelijk was om een vrouw te zijn. Ik detransitioneerde nadat ik het translabel losliet, kritische perspectieven las, met traumatherapie begon en een relatie kreeg met een hetero vriend die me hielp te accepteren dat ik vrouw ben. Ik heb één vettransplantatie voor reconstructie gehad en ben van plan mijn tepels te laten verplaatsen; ik heb spijt van de mastectomie en de blijvende littekens, al is mijn mentale gezondheid sterk verbeterd na ongeveer drie jaar therapie. Ik geloof niet dat genderidentiteit iets echts is dat los staat van het lichaam, en ik raad anderen nu aan onnodige transitiegerelateerde operaties uit te stellen of af te blazen.

Volledig verhaal

I was born female and grew up in a homophobic home town. I was a very gender-nonconforming kid, and I remember that childhood was the last time I felt treated as 'just a person' — before puberty hit and male relatives and boys at school started acting weird or uncomfortable around me. That was devastating; I learned I wasn't a person, I was 'something worse than boys'. My mother expressed fear and shame when I started my puberty, so I never had a future I could imagine where I was a full grown woman. She was also very fearful of me becoming my own person and wanted me to stay as her child forever. She believed every interest or want I'd ever had, I'd copied off of someone else. I grew up with emotional neglect and childhood PTSD; I'd been dissociating from my own wants, needs and boundaries since childhood, so adapting to any environment came naturally to me. While living at home I wasn't allowed to express anger or any other feelings different from my parents, so I only started separating from them as an adult after moving out. I also experienced sexual harassment and homophobia as a teen — I'm bisexual and had only ever been with other women before deciding to transition. Around 2013 (when I was about 23), a friend introduced me to the concept of nonbinary and told me I seemed like one. That began my spiral toward transition. I identified as trans for about 7 years total. I was in a very online, cult-like queer peer group — my polycules and friend groups were all trans or nonbinary identifying, and they lovebombed you until you felt you could never leave. I was also in polyamory first, then trans; every polycule I was in had someone who didn't really want to be there. I had a partner who introduced me to nonbinary, and I later learned she had already stopped T and regretted her mastectomy but never told me — to me she was just another success story. I wanted to fit in and feel safe, and I had such low self-esteem that I wanted to completely destroy the person I was as a child and pre-teen. I thought 'that girl' must have been horrible and disgusting, and that I'd never get friends or love if I continued being her. Subconsciously, transitioning was an attempt to create a new, better me — one without flaws, one everyone would like. I also thought I was too ugly to be a woman, that my breasts and hourglass figure didn't 'fit me' because my face was ugly, and I wanted to destroy my body with a mastectomy because of that. I also had a blinding rage at my mother — I needed her to believe I could have my own wants and feelings, if just once in my life, and getting the mastectomy was partly about individualizing away from her and making her finally see me. Other reasons included wanting to escape sexual harassment and the misogyny I associated with being a woman. I also wanted to be a genderless being (agender) because I wished to return to the state of being viewed as kinda sexless but still important, like when I was a child. Around 2015 (about 23-25), I started identifying as trans. Around age 27 (roughly 2016-2017), I had a mastectomy. Before the surgery, a small voice in my head asked twice 'what if I'm gonna regret this?' and I shrugged it off. I was completely dissociated during the whole surgery process — I remember seeing my chest after surgery and thinking nothing about it, which I took as evidence that this was how it was always meant to be, when in reality it was extreme dissociation. For two years after the mastectomy my self-esteem was through the roof — a placebo effect where I'd placed all my bad feelings and trauma associations in my breasts, and when they were cut off I felt the bad feelings were cut off too. About two years after the mastectomy (around 2019), regret started and I began to awaken from the nightmare when I realized none of it was real and I was now missing body parts. I had never even heard the word 'detransition' when I got my mastectomy — it was before the first detransitioners were speaking up. Everything I read about transition was super positive and presented as medically necessary; the whole team — nurses, doctors, surgeons, psychiatrist and therapist — gave me the green light. Two years after my surgery the hospital had to put a disclaimer on their website that these surgeries are experimental because there's not enough research backing them up, and only after that did they move to informed consent. What moved me toward detransition was gradual. It started when I realized that since identifying as trans I had become more and more miserable as years went on — I'd backed myself into a corner where everything made me feel dysphoric and unsafe, and everything I thought about was gender. I couldn't talk with family or friends for fear they'd use a wrong word; they were no longer interacting with ME but a new persona. I was depressed and alone. So I made the conscious choice of letting go of the identity label. Once I no longer identified as trans, I started reading things outside my bubble — including gender-critical opinions — and was shocked to find that the trans side had no actual arguments or studies to back up claims about suicide rates or puberty blockers being safe and reversible; it was all virtue signaling and emotional blackmailing. That was the beginning of realizing I'd had the mastectomy for ideological reasons. A crucial factor was my relationship with my current boyfriend, a straight man with no mental health issues who wasn't marinated in always-online trans culture. Actually interacting with a real male person solidified in my mind that even though I didn't have boobs, I was still very much a female — an undeniable fact about my body, not about my mind or character. It was freeing to accept my body. I'm still very gender-nonconforming. I also stopped using the word 'dysphoria' — instead of saying 'I'm dysphoric about my breasts', I asked myself what I really felt and why, which uncovered anxieties around sexual harassment, childhood trauma, and homophobia I'd experienced as a teen. Going through those issues made me stop associating the traumas with my breasts. The whole trans thing for me had been trying to control how other people perceived me 24/7 so I would be safe, because I was scared of other people and especially men. I've been in therapy for about 3 years (as of early 2023) and it's been '10/10'. I was evaluated and they ruled out BPD, but I have CPTSD from childhood neglect, which causes some BPD-like traits. I also have dissociation/derealization, health anxiety, and OCD-like spirals. During the years I was trans I lost two family members and was so dissociated I wasn't even sad — I didn't process those losses at all, and now that I've thawed out emotionally I sometimes want to talk to them before remembering they've been dead for like 8 years. I hate that a mass delusion took my last years with them. On reconstruction: I had one fat transfer (fat grafting) to my breasts, with modest results, and am looking to get the nipples replaced lower. The nipple placement looks off — they're 'cut-and-pasted on' and no longer connected to any glands. The scar tissue limits how much the skin can stretch and makes my chest look uneven. The most painful part of fat grafting was the liposuction areas, which had enormous bruising and hard lumps. I debated for 3 years whether to get the fat grafting or just accept my body, because I was done with having unnecessary surgeries, but I'm glad I did it. I didn't consider implants because of implant sickness. I consulted several surgeons; the first cosmetic surgeon said the nipples couldn't be moved down, only up, and didn't know how to create the breast shape on the lower parts — the last two said it's no problem. I also experienced some milder phantom-type sensations in my chest after surgery and found that gently touching my chest and looking at it helped remind my brain pathways that I'm healed. I changed my name before I even knew what transgender was — it's a unisex name I picked as a teenager and I've been using it for 15 years. I'll keep it; I don't feel the need to revert to my birth name. Current status: I'm a detransitioned woman in my early thirties (33 as of late 2022/early 2023). I no longer believe in gender identity as a concept separate from the body. I'm in a long-term relationship with a straight boyfriend who has never cared about my flat chest. I'm still gender-nonconforming. I've been through about 2-3 years of detransition at the time of writing in late 2022. I regret the mastectomy — I wish I could have avoided the unnecessary surgery. The regret is intense in specific ways: I'll live the rest of my life with an irregular chest, visible scarring, nipples in the wrong place, lumps, and a 'semi weird look' until I hopefully die of old age. The scars make me opt out of some fun things because I'd rather not show or discuss them. I also regret the wall I built between myself and my parents — I still haven't told them everything I've done and never will, to spare their feelings. I regret not listening to the small voice that asked twice if I'd regret the surgery. The regret is somewhat improving as my mental health gets better through therapy, but the physical damage is permanent. I've said 'mental health problems can be solved with time and therapy but they can't grow back missing body parts.' Attitudes toward transition for others: I don't oppose it outright — I think transitioning may be right for someone if they experience dysphoria so debilitating it's only relieved by trying to pass as the opposite sex, and if their mental health and relationships actually improve long-term. But I'm critical of how it's presented, especially to young people, and I frequently advise people to postpone or cancel surgeries, to question their reasons, and to wait until at least 25. I've done informal advocacy by sharing my story on r/detrans and responding to many people considering transition, recommending they listen to that small voice of doubt. I don't treat 'detransition' as an identity label, just an action/process.