Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female and grew up in Norway. Looking back, I can see that my discomfort with my body did not start as gender dysphoria in the way I understood it at the time. As a young child, before I learned about puberty, I was completely at ease being a girl. I liked drawing, art, watching TV and playing games, and I was just a normal child. What changed everything was learning that girls would eventually get periods, grow breasts that made running uncomfortable, and go through painful childbirths. I was about 12 or almost 14 when puberty hit, and I remember thinking even at 10 years old, "eeew, I don't want to bleed every 4th week, have painful births or breastfeed kids." Someone had told me that girls would get periods and that they couldn't stand up to pee like boys could, and 12-year-old me, having previously experienced a nosebleed from a falling accident, thought bleeding every month sounded gross and had to be bad.
I was diagnosed with autism spectrum disorder (ASD) at age 12. I also grew up as an international adoptee. I was the unpopular girl in elementary and middle school because I wasn't as pretty as the other girls. I noticed that boys in my culture had less pressure to look pretty, and that not looking perfect was common and still considered good enough for a boy, whereas for a girl it made you uninteresting to hang out with. I didn't fit into society's beauty standards, and having other interests didn't help.
I started thinking I might be transgender when I was about 13. I thought being trans was the right thing because it was trendy, many people in my circle said they were trans, and there were TV shows about it aired at the time. There were three different pro-trans TV shows running during the period I was 13 to 16, and I basically grew up with them. TV advertisements indirectly suggested that if you were unhappy with your body, it might mean you were trans. I also watched YouTube and followed many trans YouTubers. From ages 13 to 16, I shaved my head and wore different, more masculine clothes because I thought you had to act and look masculine to change your sex, even though I liked having long hair.
I socially transitioned at age 16, using a male name and male pronouns because, in my country, that was a requirement to be taken seriously and allowed hormones from gender therapists. I never signed up on the doctor's waiting list for medical transition. About 5 to 6 months later, at around 16.5 years old, I started to realize it wasn't for me. The first thing that made me want to go back was learning that testosterone could cause male pattern baldness. I met a trans guy and watched YouTube videos of trans men who had started balding, and I loved my hair too much and was fairly vain at that time. I also didn't want a beard, more body hair, acne, a change in body smell, or bigger hands, feet, ears and nose. I feared not being able to recognize myself. I realized I didn't actually want to become a man and didn't relate to other men. I had no bottom dysphoria other than hatred for my bleeding uterus; I never missed having a penis and didn't even know what male genitalia looked like until I was 18 or 19.
I came out as a desister to my friends, family, classmates and even an ex. I was nervous, but everyone accepted it. I said things like, "I think I've made a mistake. I don't think I'm trans," and "I want to change back and stay the sex I was born as." My family and friends had told me beforehand that I would regret it, and in my case they were right. The online trans community did not take it well, so I deleted my accounts on trans forums and never returned. After coming out as a desister, I had a short phase of secretly wondering if I was non-binary for about half a year, but I never told anyone or used they/them pronouns. Eventually I realized I could be a cis woman and still be unhappy about parts of my body.
I never went on hormones or had any surgeries, so I have no permanent physical changes from transition. My hair went from a pixie cut to bob length in about 12 months and shoulder length in about 16 months. After detransition I slimmed down in my face, straightened my teeth with braces, and grew older, so my self-confidence is higher now. I also learned about birth control pills for the first time when I was almost 17, about half a year after desisting, when I had to actively seek out the school doctor for mental problems. Sex ed where I grew up was extremely poor for a wealthy Western country. I thought condoms only prevented STDs, that only trans people were allowed sterilization, and that pregnancy was inevitable if you had sex.
The main reasons I wanted to transition were hating my periods, not wanting the ability to become pregnant because I am staunchly childfree, and not fitting into female beauty standards. Losing my fertility was my number one reason and losing my period was my number two. I now know that birth control pills can reduce or eliminate periods and that sterilization exists for cis people. I have been trying different birth control pills to treat my ongoing discomfort. My periods are almost gone on the pills and the likelihood of pregnancy is much lower. I would like to have my uterus removed, but I know no doctor would do that without a medical condition. When I turn 25, I may get sterilized where I can get my tubes cut and tied, since the age limit for sterilization in my country is 25.
I still experience something similar to gender dysphoria. I still hate my periods, still don't want boobs, and still don't want biological children. But the two main differences now are that I don't feel as sad as often and that I know the cause. I know it doesn't mean I'm trans. I would describe my earlier mindset as thinking the grass was greener on the other side; now I know both sexes have pros and cons and that if you get rid of some problems you just get new ones. I used to say I was a "trans man," then "non-binary," then "cis woman." Now I identify as a cis woman, a socially desister FtMtF, and a queer woman. I am now 23 years old.
On sexuality: before and during the time I thought I was trans, I was only attracted to men and was considered straight by many. I enjoyed reading both yaoi and yuri stories because the couples couldn't have accidental pregnancies and there were fewer gender roles. I romanticized gay relationships because I thought it would be convenient to never worry about pregnancy. After detransition I gradually started becoming attracted to women. I didn't notice I was bi until I was almost 18. Now I identify as a biromantic homosexual cis woman, meaning I can be romantically attracted to both genders but am only physically and sexually attracted to women. I have tried to be attracted to conventionally attractive men and even exposed myself to the smell of testosterone for four years, but it didn't work. I am a femme who prefers other femmes. I dated someone who later came out as MTF, but I wasn't attracted and we ended it after about a month.
I have no regrets about buying the masculine clothes or shaving off my hair, although I no longer find the aesthetics appealing. But there are tons of things I do regret: considering changing my sex, coming out, thinking life must be better as a male, and believing it would solve beauty standard pressure. I wish I had never gotten into the trans stuff and never come out. I also wish I had known earlier that birth control pills existed, that it's normal for cis women to hate their periods, and that both genders have difficulties. My regret is not improving or worsening dramatically; it's more of a settled, matter-of-fact acknowledgment that it was a mistake.
Mental health: I was diagnosed with ASD at 12. When I was 14 I had a failed suicide attempt because of hormonal mood changes. I was suicidal monthly because of my periods and assumed it was normal to be suicidal and just part of life. I went to the school doctor for mental problems when I was almost 17. Since detransition and starting birth control, I don't feel as sad as often. I don't blame anyone but nature; I think nature is cruel and a joke.
Currently I am doing well and am happy. I am single, on birth control which means no pregnancy risk and almost no periods, and I have no permanent changes to my body. My friends and family have helped me through difficult times. I live in a liberal city in Norway and I have been celebrating Pride for the last couple of years. I know about 10+ people who identify as trans or non-binary and have met up to 100. I have never met an open desister or detrans person in real life.
I still support trans rights for consenting adults, but I hold many critical views. I think medical transition should be illegal for children under 18, that there should be an age limit of 18 on HRT and surgeries, and that doctors should be allowed to refuse patients they think will regret it. I think non-binary is a cultural identity rather than a biological sex, that there are two biological sexes, and that genital preferences in dating are valid and not transphobic. I believe gender dysphoria is a real mental health condition and that "true trans" people - transsexuals who medically transition without regret - exist but are very rare. I have been banned from an LGBT subreddit for expressing my opinions about "non-men" events, and I find much of the non-binary and "genital preference is bad" concepts confusing. I attend Pride but not trans-only events, and I have shared posts on my social media announcing that I am not trans.