Alle verhalen

Op haar 14e wensen intersekse te zijn, op haar 20e voor haar lichaam kiezen

Vrouw · Gedesisteerd1,4K
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een cis vrouw die aan gedetransitioneerd grenst en werkt als geestelijke gezondheidszorgprofessional. Ik ben nooit medisch getransitioneerd, maar worstelde als tiener met mijn vrouwelijke lichaam en wenste intersekse te zijn; rond mijn 20e accepteerde ik mijn vrouwelijkheid. Ik heb persoonlijke ervaring met dwanggedachten (OCD) rond gender en seksualiteit, wat mijn beroepskeuze en mijn scepsis tegenover het affirmatieve therapiemodel heeft gevormd. Ik heb een kind dat zich als trans identificeerde en daardoor rigider en depressiever werd, wat mijn zorgen over het bevestigen van jongeren heeft verdiept. Ik ben kritisch over de huidige genderdiagnoses en transitieprotocollen en pleit voor exploratie, differentiële diagnostiek en transitie als laatste redmiddel, en ik zet me in voor zichtbaarheid van detrans en detrans-vriendelijke therapeuten. Ik blijf een cis vrouw die zich prettig voelt in haar lichaam en actief de detrans-gemeenschap steunt.

Volledig verhaal

I was born female and have identified as a cis woman throughout the time I've been posting in this community, though I went through a period in my youth where I struggled with my female body and wished I were something other than what I was. I have never medically transitioned, which is something I've come to see as a positive in hindsight. As a teen, before 'egg culture' existed online, I knew the term transgender but didn't really understand what it meant. I used to pray I'd wake up one day and magically be intersex, and that the beginnings of puberty had just been a bad dream. I liked a lot of things coded as 'masculine' and hated my body. I was around 20 before I began to accept my femininity and my body. I also had a stubborn streak as a kid: if I heard of anything boys were supposedly better at or that girls were supposed to do, I was going to do it and do it better than the boys (except sports — I'm not athletic). I hung out with my brother's Boy Scout troop and was an honorary member. I hated being female because I hated the double standards and the feeling of being less than. That experience is one of the reasons I'm drawn to and want to help in the detrans community. I eventually went into a helping profession — I refer to myself as a therapist/professional in my comments, and I describe translating 'technical/doctor/government speech to normal human' as part of my day-to-day practice. I have personal experience with OCD: my own struggles with OCD are part of why I chose a helping profession, and having personally experienced gender and sexuality-based intrusive thoughts got me interested in TOCD and gender dysphoria. I don't use the affirmative therapy model in my practice; I'd rather explore identity with clients and help them rationally make choices based on what's actually going on. I've expressed frustration that therapists are told they must affirm anyone who presents as trans or risk being labeled transphobic or accused of conversion therapy, and I've said I'd love to work with detrans people but worry about my career. I got invited to a continuing education class on affirmation and it made me cringe. I've been open about my own life circumstances: I was completing grad school around 2020, dealing with financial uncertainty and the pandemic, and stress eating. I describe myself as not particularly fond of my body at that time but able to reframe — thinking of myself as strong rather than fat, able to replace the water jug on the water cooler without help. I'm childfree and don't want children. I've discussed with my doctor my hatred of periods and desire to never have one: I tried an IUD, which lessened my periods to almost nothing, but went back to continuous birth control because I wanted no period ever. I was advised against uterus and ovary removal due to risk of pelvic floor prolapse, and told uterine ablation should wait until I'm closer to forty in case it initiates early menopause. I also discussed the depo shot and its cautions. I followed my doctor when she switched clinics because I refused to lose her. I have a kiddo who at one point identified as trans — the child was 'the girliest girl,' asked if wanting to wear boy's clothes made them a boy, then cut their long hair short, stopped wearing nail polish, and started identifying as trans, becoming more rigid in gender roles and increasingly depressed, believing testosterone and a double mastectomy would cure their depression and anxiety. I also have a cat (and previously a dog) I jokingly 'diagnosed' with disorders while helping my kiddo through a panic attack. I have a brother. I'm in the US. I've also mentioned family medical history — 'most of the older women in my family have a bit of facial hair, hooray PCOS.' On transition and medicine, I've been consistently critical and cautious. I've argued that the DSM criteria for dysphoria are broad, don't specify when dysphoria should begin, and can be applied to nearly every teenager who dislikes their body. I've said clinicians are not encouraged to rule out normal puberty discomfort, OCD, body dysmorphia, or trauma. I've said I have yet to find good studies showing long-term quality-of-life increases from transition, and that the research on hormones is, in my words, 'shit.' I've cited studies showing no statistically significant change in suicide rates post-transition and QOL studies showing declines in physical health, sexual health, and social support. I've argued transition should be a last resort after rigorous evaluation and less invasive measures, that hormones shouldn't be used for cosmetic purposes, and that the 300%+ increase in natal female referrals is a red flag. I've been clear I do think hormones and surgery can help some people but that their overall impact is limited until better long-term research exists. I've advocated for detrans people's visibility, saying it will take people willing to be called transphobic for existing and telling their stories to change the conversation, and I've wished for a directory of detrans-friendly therapists in the US. I've also engaged with a women's discussion subreddit, upvoting substantive posts when photo posts drowned out discussion, but stopped myself from messaging moderators for fear of backlash. I don't describe a detransition of my own — I never transitioned — but I've worked through accepting my body and femininity, and I've been open about body-image struggles, stress eating, and periods of not liking my body while reframing toward what my body can do.