Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben als vrouw geboren, transitioneerde als jong persoon sociaal zonder hormonen of operaties, en ben nu gedesisteerd en identificeer me als biseksuele vrouw. Ik geloof dat mijn dysforie voortkwam uit een laag zelfbeeld, een androgyn/mannelijk uiterlijk, schizotypische trekken en diepe ongelukkigheid met mezelf, en niet uit trans zijn. Een borstgroeispurt rond mijn 21e maakte me gelukkig in plaats van dysforisch en bevestigde dat ik niet trans was. Ik ben nu kritisch over hoe gemakkelijk transitie wordt aangemoedigd en over trans-/non-binaire identiteiten in bredere zin, terwijl ik nog steeds zeg dat transitie voor sommigen goed kan zijn.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female and grew up in the UK. I was never a tomboy — I've always been quite girly, and even when I identified as a trans guy I sometimes liked to present as a 'trans femboy'. Around my early teens I started identifying as trans and socially transitioned, using he/him and living as a trans guy. I never had hormones or surgery — I only socially transitioned, so I describe myself as desisted rather than detransitioned.
Looking back, I think the gender dysphoria was a result of general unhappiness with my entire self and extremely low self-esteem. I physically looked androgynous/masculine, had a kind of masculine face and acne, and was flat-chested when I started identifying as trans. I subconsciously thought that if I was a trans guy, my discomfort with my whole self would make sense. I also think my schizotypal diagnosis contributed — I was just trying to find a reason why I felt so disconnected from my body. I've also noted that when I identified as trans and socially transitioned I was deeply, deeply unhappy with myself and mentally ill.
About six years after socially transitioning, I felt a lot better about myself generally. I saw pretty girls and thought 'I want to be like that…. Oh wait, I can be!' Then, when I was around 21, I had a hormone surge and my breasts suddenly grew very large. Instead of feeling dysphoric about it, I actually felt very happy — and that's when I realised I'm not trans after all. I now have very large breasts.
I didn't want to admit I'd made a mistake at first — it was the classic sunk cost fallacy. Getting out of that way of thinking wasn't easy but it wasn't impossible. My depression improved over time, my self-esteem improved, and I started to find joy in femininity and being a woman. I now really like dressing femininely and wearing makeup, I like my boobs, and I like that I can express my emotions more freely than I feel I could as a man. I also like the idea of being able to grow a human, that women have fewer health risks and higher life expectancy, and I feel confident in how I was born. I've never been a tomboy and I still wear very feminine clothes and never wear pants or shorts.
I'm autistic and I like labels — I don't mind 'trans' and 'cis' as opposites, though I understand some people hate labels. I'm also disabled, which for a while made me think I couldn't pursue fitness goals, but I found there are always things you can do; fitness has really improved my mood and sense of self. I also recommend having career and fitness goals to work towards.
On sexuality: I'm a bisexual woman, and I'm currently dating a man. Some queer people don't like that — someone once called me 'straight-lite'. I've also been critical of what I see as hostility within LGBT spaces toward straight people and straight men, and I've pushed back when people accuse others of being right-wing for saying so.
I'm now critical of how transition is encouraged in the current climate. I think transitioning could be a good idea for some people, but it's encouraged at the drop of a hat and the vast majority of people shouldn't transition at all. I've said that if you have ANY doubts at all, no matter how small, you should not do anything medical because it's insanely hard to reverse. I've also been critical of trans and non-binary people, saying I think many use the label as a way to gain control over their identities instead of going to therapy, and that I've never met a trans/nb person who is emotionally regulated. I believe the 'transgender urges only came after the self hate' — that was true for me, and I think it's the same for most trans people. I've also been sceptical of some feminist critiques but have come to agree with some of them after seeing the behaviour myself, including women commenting on my breast size and suggesting I get a reduction for a back I never said hurt, and grown women making catty remarks to me as a teenager.