Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde, gendernonconformistische vrouw die zich nu stellig als vrouw identificeert, al merk ik op dat mensen me vaak als man lezen of me non-binair proberen te noemen omdat ik androgyn ben, herenkleding draag en geen vrouwelijke stereotypen opvoer. Ik omschrijf dat het niet kunnen relateren aan typische gesprekken van vrouwen me op wat ik nu 'het onzinnige pad van transitioneren' noem heeft gebracht, maar ik geef geen data of medische details over transitie of detransitie. Ik heb pijnlijke, zware menstruaties die in mijn tienerjaren het ergst waren en zijn verbeterd, en ik spreek me uit over het feit dat transvrouwen dat nooit meemaken. Ik ben sterk tegen transvrouwen in ruimtes alleen voor vrouwen en bekritiseer wat ik zie als de banalisering van menstruatie en de uitholling van het woord 'vrouw'. Ik geef geen details over spijt buiten het kaderen van mijn transitie als onzinnig, en er worden geen suïcidale gedachten of zelfbeschadiging beschreven.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female and I've always been visibly androgynous — half the people I meet read me as male, the rest correctly recognize me as female, and some people try to force a nonbinary label on me by using "they" for me. I feel my best in men's clothes, I rarely shave, I never wear makeup, and I don't relate to most women's conversations — I always feel "like such a brute" around them. That sense of not fitting the stereotype of womanhood is exactly what led me down what I now call "the nonsensical path of transitioning in the first place." I don't give a specific age for when I started, but I've since detransitioned and now firmly identify as a female woman, even though a lot of people tell me I'm not one because I don't perform the stereotype. I'm very clear about that identity now: "But I'm a female, a woman, but according to a lot of people I'm not because I'm not a stereotype."
My periods have been a central, deeply personal part of my life. As a teenager my periods were "the worst thing in the world" — cramps, vomiting, bloating, pain shooting into my legs and feet, hot flashes, not having access to tampons or pads at the worst times, constantly bleeding through my clothes, being afraid to stand up in case I'd bled through, and passing huge painful blood clots. They've gotten a lot better since, but I still have plenty of periods and expect plenty more. This experience is why I react strongly to trans women claiming or describing menstruation: I wrote a post titled "You Can't Make This Stuff Up😑" saying I "cannot stand the fact the pain of having a period is so trivialized," and that it's one thing to want to look like something or convince people you're something, but "to sit here and know that you will never, ever experience this and still claim it...how fucking dare you?" I also agreed with another commenter that "the period poops are no joke" and said I "cannot fathom how a period could be a fairytale dream for some people."
When someone pushed back suggesting I thought hot flashes or leg pain were female-only, I clarified that I know many people experience those, including "bio-males taking hormones," and that hormones obviously have effects — but "one of those effects is not suddenly understanding what a period is like." I told that person, "you also don't have to explain a period to me, sir. I've had plenty and I'll have plenty more."
On spaces and identity, I hold firm boundaries: I argued that trans women should not be allowed into female-only spaces, regardless of how they look or whether they bother anyone. "A man is a man. He can look like whatever, he can get all the surgeries he wants, but he is still male and should not be let into female only spaces ever. PERIOD. Performing stereotypes of what a woman is, does not make them women." I also noted the double standard that "the word 'man' doesn't have half the debates surrounding it," which I read as sexism.
I don't describe specific medical interventions, surgeries, hormone durations, or a precise detransition date in what I've written, and I don't discuss therapy, mental health diagnoses, or family dynamics. What comes through clearly is a strong, settled identification as a gender-nonconforming female woman, anger at what I see as the trivialization of female bodily experience, and opposition to trans women being included in female-only spaces.