Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een homoseksuele man in de dertig die door mijn familie werd verstoten vanwege mijn homoseksualiteit en als minderjarige seksueel werd misbruikt door een oudere man, en die in de jaren 1990 als kind Ritalin kreeg voorgeschreven. Ik beschrijf niet dat ik zelf ben getransitioneerd, maar ik post vaak in detransitie-ruimtes, waar ik jongeren adviseer trauma op te lossen voordat ze transitie overwegen en waarschuw voor onomkeerbare medische gevolgen. Ik vind dat seksualiteit vast en aangeboren is, dat genderdysforie meestal psychologisch is en niet „geboren in het verkeerde lichaam”, en dat transitiegeneeskunde te snel wordt toegepast. Ik ben kritisch over wat ik zie als pedofilie en politiek extremisme dat de LHBT-gemeenschap infiltreert. Ik meld geen persoonlijke detransitie, huidige identiteit als gedetransitioneerd of suïcidale gedachten.
Volledig verhaal
I am a gay man who has been active in LGBT online spaces since at least late 2019, and I write about transition, dysphoria, sexuality, and trauma from a skeptical, psychologically-oriented perspective. I was in my thirties as of January 2020 (I referenced 'my thirty plus years on earth'), and I have been openly gay since at least the 1990s, when I describe 'the homosexuality we fought for in the 90's.'
I was raised in a family where being gay was not accepted — I wrote that if I had ever been 'presented with the choice' of changing my sexuality, 'my family life would have been fought with far less disownings,' indicating my family disowned me over my homosexuality. I have a long-term boyfriend as of December 2019.
I experienced sexual abuse as a minor: in December 2019 I wrote that 'many gay men's first introduction to sex was with an older man preying upon them. It happened to me, and it happened to my boyfriend.' I consider this a common and under-discussed trauma in the LGBT community, and I believe parents often 'pawn off the job of dating and sex guidance to the lgbt community,' leaving predators positioned to exploit that.
I was prescribed Ritalin as a child in the 1990s — I compared a doctor's three one-hour visits before putting a young person 'on a path' to puberty blockers and breast removal by saying 'It took my childhood doctor longer to decide if I should be on Ritalin, and they passed that out like candy in the nineties.' I have not described a formal ADHD diagnosis, but the Ritalin prescription implies childhood attention or behavioral treatment.
I do not describe having personally transitioned, detransitioned, or experienced gender dysphoria myself. Instead, I offer advice to others questioning transition. In December 2019 I advised someone whose gender identity seemed 'tied up' in past trauma to 'take a few years of therapy for the trauma before you even consider transitioning,' warning that transitioning while dysphoric from trauma 'stands a high chance of enhancing the dysphoria further.' In April 2020 I gave a questioning young person two approaches: a 'soft way' of exploring the root of their body discomfort, noting 'folks of your age group overwhelmingly return to their original gender into adulthood,' and a 'not so soft way' of 'calculated traumatic exposure' — researching irreversible consequences including voice changes, loss of vocal range, permanent effects of early hormone therapy, cancer risks, and the large arm/leg skin graft scar from genital reassignment surgery.
I hold a strongly essentialist view of sexuality: 'Human sexuality isn't fluid; you're either gay, or you never were. You can't traumatize somebody into homosexuality anymore than you can traumatize them out of it.' I reject fluid-orientation models as 'farcical' and argue they echo 'pray the gay away' rhetoric. I believe sexuality is largely genetic plus environmental predisposition, comparing it to handedness. I cite animal homosexuality research (rams at 10%, bonobos at ~60% female-female activity) to argue homosexuality is natural.
On the causes of gender dysphoria, I reject the 'male-brained/female-brained' framework as based on societal stereotypes, and instead theorize dysphoria arises from 'a combination of chemical and psychological events,' possibly hormonal disruption in the womb (I note the fraternal birth order effect and endocrine-disrupting pharmaceuticals in food). I compare dysphoria to other body dysphorias and believe most cases have 'a psychological explanation that can be solved without surgical or pharmaceutical treatments,' with transition appropriate only for 'folks with a very deep seated, chemically induced brain issue.'
I am critical of aspects of the contemporary LGBT and trans communities. I have argued that the community has 'been infiltrated by organized pedophilia,' citing Jessica Yaniv and a registered sex offender reading to children in drag in New York City, and wrote 'If you hang out with wild dogs, don't be surprised when you get fleas.' I also argue that trans identity has become overly entangled with hardcore leftism, making it hard to distinguish trans-hate from leftist-hate. I theorize that trans people's high suicide rates relate partly to an innate human 'disease avoidance instinct' being triggered by physical anomalies from transition, plus trauma-induced PTSD from the dramatic change, rather than purely to 'transphobia.'
I am cautiously optimistic about future transition technology, particularly 3D organ printing using a patient's own stem cells and DNA, which I prefer to surgical alternatives.
I do not describe current mental health diagnoses for myself. I do not describe regret about transition personally, since I do not describe having transitioned. I have not described any advocacy or activism beyond posting advice and commentary online.