Alle verhalen

Dysforie zonder transitie — en ervoor kiezen vrouw te blijven

Vrouw · Gedesisteerd184
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde... nee — ik ben een tienermeisje dat nooit is getransitioneerd maar dysforie als vrouw ervaart, en ik werk eraan mezelf te accepteren als masculiene, genderdoorbrekende lesbienne. Ik schrijf mijn ellende toe aan geïnternaliseerde vrouwenhaat en de druk van performatieve vrouwelijkheid in plaats van geboren zijn in het verkeerde lichaam, en ik ben kritisch over hoe makkelijk transitie wordt aangeboden aan mensen zoals ik. Ik heb littekens van zelfbeschadiging waar ik spijt van heb en heb gewezen op de mogelijkheid dat het „erger kon, ik had dood kunnen zijn”, maar ik heb sindsdien geen poging beschreven. Ik identificeer me momenteel als vrouw en ben tegen transitie voor mezelf, terwijl ik sympathiek blijf voor degenen die detransitioneren.

Volledig verhaal

I was born female and I'm 17 years old as of July 2019 (I say 'I'm an 18 year old female' in one June comment and 'I'm 17' in several July comments, so my age is a little inconsistent across posts, but I'm a teenager either way). I've never transitioned — I want to be clear about that, because when someone told me their heart broke for me I said plainly, 'I can't relate to your issues as I've never transitioned.' What I do have is dysphoria as a female, and I'm actively trying to accept myself. I started hating being female sometime in my teen years. I've come to understand it as internalized misogyny and the pressure of performative femininity. I don't conform to gender roles. Society would call my behaviour and clothing choices masculine — I dress like a '12 year old boy,' I don't like makeup or fashion, and I don't shave my legs (though I do shave sometimes purely out of pressure, and I usually only wear shorts because of it). Presenting femininely is foreign to me: I tried for a couple of months last year but it just felt fake. I cringe when my mother calls me a young lady — I can picture a young lady and I don't feel like I fit that image. I feel like a bit of an outsider and I don't measure up to what society wants from me. I'm a lesbian, which adds to the not fitting in part. I don't want male attraction. I'm disgusted by being perceived as female in the sense of how society treats women — I wrote that I hate how society makes women into 'sexual ornaments for mens eyes' and that it's 'all such bullshit.' I also said, as a female woman, 'I don't want to be desirable or attractive. It creeps me out, it feels like something I'm forced to want.' I find Instagram culture really creepy and objectifying, and I think it's made things worse because all the girls get into it. I look at my friends changing during the teen years into makeup and fashion loving girly girls and I feel like it's a joke I can't understand — 'Where are all the normal, natural, free, real women?? Where have my friends gone?' I like my female body but at the same time I resent it because of society — it's a double edged sword. I don't think passing as a male would solve those problems for me; I can't imagine how looking like my brother and calling myself a man would feel better. I just want to be who I am and stop feeling like I need to feminize myself to be acceptable. If I saw more girls like me who didn't conform to gender roles, I don't think I would have these problems. I'm going to keep being who I am and work on my self esteem and not give a fuck what society says a woman should be. I have self harm scars on my arm that I regret, but I've accepted that they're a part of me — it shows how strong I am, how I can make it through things. I said 'It could be worse, I could be dead instead,' which suggests things got dark at some point, though I haven't described a specific attempt. I don't have a formal mental health diagnosis in what I've written, but I did tell someone else that their fear of becoming trans sounded like OCD and paranoia and suggested they find a psychologist for intrusive thoughts and try mindfulness. I have a cousin who is an autistic female who transitioned FTM, and I've heard that's a common thing for autistic females. I'm critical of transition as an option for people like me. I've written that trans groups are 'such an echo chamber of mental illness' — that they validate each other's transitioning, don't question anything, shut down outside opinions as TERF, and are 'hurting themselves in the end.' I think there will be a lot of regret in the next 10 years given how popular transitioning has become. I told someone considering top surgery at 17 to stop and think about it longer: 'I wouldn't want to make any life long decisions about my body and not be 100% on it.' I also told someone else, 'I think a lot of gnc people think transition will save them from these issues but then they live to regret it.' I don't believe nobody is 'born in the wrong body' — I wrote that these ideas come from the sexist society we're born into, and that transition reinforces gender roles by equating masculinity with man and femininity with woman. I also pushed back on the idea of 'feeling like a woman': 'I don't feel like one, I just am one. Assigning biology feelings is just destructive and wrong.' I think talking about gender as a feeling has dissociated more people from their own sex and gender. The hardest part is that I admitted wanting to be a man: 'For me I want to be a man but I also don't. I just want to feel good enough, comfortable, I want to fit in. I hate how I see being trans as an escape or the forbidden fruit. It's so tempting, but it truly isn't what I want.' I try to imagine a world where gender roles didn't exist and the world accepted me as a 'masculine' woman, and if that world existed I don't think I would have dysphoria. That's what keeps me going. I'm supportive of people who detransition — I told one person 'I think detransitioning is like the opposite of failing. You're so strong to overcome your problems in this way' — and I've been encouraging others to slow down and not rush into transition. I haven't done any formal advocacy or activism beyond posting in these communities.