Alle verhalen

Ruzie met de detrans-gemeenschap over haar eigen dogma

Vrouw · Gedetransitioneerd91
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerd persoon die eind december 2023 lid werd van de detrans-gemeenschap en vroeg naar detransitiecijfers voor FTM versus MTF, en kritisch meedeed aan discussies over spijt, vatbaarheid en de online push richting transitie. Ik ben kritisch geweest over hoe transitie online wordt gepromoot, en waarschuwde dat het vatbare mensen kan overtuigen en tot een dag kan leiden waarop je vol spijt wakker wordt, terwijl ik ook weerwoord gaf aan detransitioners die trans mensen de schuld geven van hun eigen keuzes. Ik heb publiekelijk geen gedetailleerde medische specifieke zaken gedeeld, maar heb verwezen naar kennis van welke hormoneffecten blijven bestaan na het stoppen. Ik botste met moderators over wat ik zag als te zwart-wit denken. Mijn huidige identiteit is gedetransitioneerd, en ik blijf betrokken bij de gemeenschap als kritische stem.

Volledig verhaal

I started this account in late December 2023 by asking a straightforward question on the detrans board: are there more female-to-male detransitioners than male-to-female ones? I didn't know the answer and was genuinely curious about the numbers, and when someone replied with information I said I'd look it up. That curiosity about the broader picture has been a running theme for me — I keep circling back to how people end up transitioning in the first place. I've been on the other side of these conversations too. When someone described taking random online drugs for the sake of gains, I told them bluntly that it was "very male brained" — taking unregulated substances without thinking it through. I've argued that calling something out is always better than ignoring it, and that sometimes knowing less is better, which is a strange thing to say about someone researching hormone effects, but I meant it in the sense that some knowledge invites trouble. What I keep coming back to is the question of why people take the leap at all. I asked someone point-blank whether there was anything they liked about being on hormones, and then pushed further: there must have been some pros, otherwise why take that leap of faith unless you're a susceptible person. That word — susceptible — matters to me. I think a lot of people, myself included, went in looking for something we thought we'd get, and the appeal was real enough to override caution. I'm critical of how transition gets presented online. I wrote that it's a great way to convince susceptible people that they're trans too, and that the harmful effects are things most people already know about — "what can be more scary than waking up one day full of regret." That fear of regret is something I take seriously. I've also asked other detransitioners directly why they chose to detransition, and what went wrong, because I want to understand the mechanics of it — what pushes someone back. I've clashed with people on the board. When someone said they detransitioned just to have a boyfriend, I told them that was on them, not on trans people — and I repeated it, because I don't think detransition should be weaponized against trans people generally. I got downvoted for it, twice, and I told the mods they were being black-and-white about something that isn't black and white. I don't think every detransition story is a cautionary tale about the ideology of transition; sometimes people make choices for complicated personal reasons and then look for someone to blame. I don't talk much about my own medical details publicly. I've been asked how long I was on hormones and I've noted that someone kept most of the good effects, which suggests I have some frame of reference for what persists and what doesn't after stopping. But I've kept the specifics close. What I will say is that I think about this stuff constantly — the demographics, the regret, the susceptibility, the way the online discourse flattens everything into team sports. I'd rather people slow down and think than rush in and find out the hard way.