Alle verhalen

Vijf jaar ouders adviseren vanaf de zijlijn

Vrouw · Gedesisteerd163
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gender-non-conforme lesbische vrouw die minstens sinds medio 2020 actief is in detransitioner-gemeenschappen en steun en advies geef in plaats van een persoonlijke transitie of detransitie te beschrijven. Ik ben kritisch op transitie bij jongeren, ROGD en een cultuur van identiteitslabels, en adviseer minstens tot 25 te wachten vóór onomkeerbare medische beslissingen. Ik heb ouders geadviseerd binders en ‘herbevestigend’ gedrag af te wijzen, maar ook af te raden zwaarhandig verzet te bieden. Ik moedig detransitioners aan hun verhalen te delen ondanks de sociale en politieke moeilijkheden. Op dit moment identificeer ik me als een gender-non-conforme lesbische vrouw en beschrijf ik in dit transcript geen persoonlijke medische transitie.

Volledig verhaal

I am a gay, gender-nonconforming woman who has been active in detransitioner spaces since at least mid-2020, offering advice and support to others. I speak from my own perspective as someone who is same-sex attracted and comfortable as a woman, and I have at times referred to myself as a 'fellow gender-nonconforming gay.' In my interactions, I have consistently counseled young people questioning their gender to hold off on hormones or irreversible medical procedures until they are older — I specifically recommend waiting until at least 25, since I believe the brain is still developing until then. I believe there is nothing shameful about being a straight or cis woman, and I am critical of what I see as an over-identification culture among LGBT youth, where 'every minor aspect of personality, attraction, sex drive, and style' gets labeled with an identity. I have described the narrative that short hair or masculine clothing means you must 'be a man on the inside' as 'a profoundly sexist narrative.' I have advised a parent of a young girl showing signs of what I called 'Rapid Onset Gender Dysphoria' (ROGD), describing it as 'indeed a contagion with teens/pre-teens' and comparing it to eating disorders in the 1990s. I recommended against getting her a binder or using 'reaffirming' behavior like a boy name or he/him pronouns, but also advised not pushing back too hard to avoid feeding a rebellious narrative. I suggested de-genderizing language, calling out sexist statements, bringing up feminist issues, and getting her involved in physical activities. I also warned that binders 'can cause deformities if worn too extensively.' I have supported someone going through a detransition process, including advising that they could quit estrogen 'cold turkey' without adverse effects if their testes are intact, while acknowledging possible mood swings. I have been supportive of people leaving relationships where they felt a partner's love was conditional on them being trans. I have also acknowledged the isolation and 'political' difficulties detransitioners face, and encouraged someone to keep sharing their story honestly. I recommended the YouTube channel 'GNC Central,' an FtMtF detransitioner, to someone questioning. I have also reassured people about body image concerns, saying most people are not 100% happy with their body and that it's fine to consider things like a breast reduction without it meaning they have dysphoria. I have no stated medical procedures of my own, no stated transition history, and no stated mental health diagnoses in this transcript. I have not described any regret about transition personally, since I do not describe having transitioned myself in these comments.