Alle verhalen

Jaren als trans man, en dan rouwen om de man die ze nooit zou worden

Vrouw · Gedesisteerd542
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedesisteerde, gedetransitioneerde vrouw, als vrouw geboren, hetero en gender-non-conform, en ik heb nooit HRT genomen, ondanks meerdere jaren waarin ik me actief als trans identificeerde. Ik schrijf mijn dysforie — aanwezig zolang ik me kan herinneren — grotendeels toe aan autoandrofilie, autisme en trauma, en ik werd in feite naar een trans identiteit geduwd omdat ik als heteroseksuele, masculien overkomende vrouw geen ander kader zag voor wat ik meemaakte. Detransitie betekende rouwen om de fantasie een ‘normale’ man te worden, schaamte over GNC-zijn en dissociatie over de jaren die ik leefde als iemand die ik niet ben. Nu ben ik kritisch op genderideologie en medische transitie, die ik zie als een oplichterij die geen sekse verandert en gezondheidskosten met zich meebrengt, terwijl ik nog steeds compassie voel voor dysfore mensen. Ik pleit voor ruimte en gemeenschap voor heteroseksuele, masculiene vrouwen en voor een bredere groep die gender-non-conform mag zijn.

Volledig verhaal

I was born female and I have wanted to be male for as long as I can remember — the desire to be the opposite sex goes back to my earliest memories, and I've been dysphoric for as long as I can recall. I never went on HRT, but for several years I was actively identifying as trans, living as someone I am not, and that period now feels like a missing chunk of my life — like waking up from a coma and finding someone else had control of my body while I was blacked out. I have described that time as dissociative: "Who was I before I did this, who am I now, and what the hell happened in between??" I now identify as a desisted, detransitioned woman. I am gender nonconforming and straight — I am not attracted to women — and that combination has been central to my confusion. I was basically a butch lesbian in presentation but wasn't attracted to women, and I didn't know how else to make sense of that, so I almost felt pushed into identifying as trans. I think many straight, naturally GNC women get pushed toward transition because the only examples we see are "gay trans men" or butch lesbians, so of course we end up thinking we must be one or the other. A key framework for me has been autoandrophilia (AAP). Learning about where my gender issues might come from — in my case AAP — helped me frame them as something "real," which in turn helped me feel more real, more like a person. I've described myself elsewhere as a "schizoid AAP" and said that sometimes it feels confusing and impossible to know how to exist in the world. I've said I can't wrap my head around "normal" heterosexuality: "How could you not want to also be like the thing you find most compelling??" I've suggested others look up autoandrophilia as a possible label, and I've said that as more people come to understand themselves this way instead of as "trans," maybe we'll find new ways of helping ourselves. I also think there's a massive overlap with autism/autistic traits, reflecting a lack of normal socialization with your same sex. I have trauma and autism-related issues, and I suspect my fear of rejection for being GNC is more about my own issues with trauma/autism than about actual rejection. I live in northern New England. I've experienced a lot of shame and self-disgust about being nonconforming, and one of the hardest parts of desisting has been grieving the imaginary future where I got to be a "normal" man and wouldn't have to deal with the pain of being rejected for being GNC. Transition represented freedom to blend in, but I've come to believe transition would only make that problem worse, which left me crushed. I've said that being straight and GNC past a certain point is extremely isolating and confusing, and that a lot of straight transitioners had no other way of making sense of what was going on. I never took testosterone, but I've commented that it's "fundamentally unhealthy to have that much testosterone in your body as female," and that medical transition doesn't actually change your sex and comes with many health costs — I've called medical transition "kind of a scam." I've said I'm no longer making any effort to disguise my sex: I'm literally just a woman with short hair, never been on HRT, yet 90% of strangers mistakenly read me as male, and that social dissonance is what drove me to want to transition in the first place. I've noted it's a strange experience not feeling "woman enough" having never even been on HRT, though it seems to settle out over time. On the process of desisting, I've found it helpful to think about my relationship with myself — the little girl I used to be, the woman I am now underneath the male identity — and to open myself to connection with others and show myself real love and compassion. I've said dysphoria might never completely go away but you can do a lot to heal the split in your personality. I've also said embracing being female feels like the only way forward but is a massive task, and that it's genuinely devastating that it's impossible to become male. I've expressed hope that we'll develop better ways of understanding people like me, because the "trans" label seems to be doing a lot of harm. I've dealt with OCD-like loops around gender: I called perpetual "questioning your gender" OCD nightmare fuel, criticizing the no-win logic where HRT helping or worsening dysphoria both supposedly confirm transition was right. I've been critical of gender ideology broadly — I've said "trans" is just gender nonconformity dressed up in wishful thinking, that gender and sex cannot actually be pulled apart, and that unlearning gender ideology made me reconsider reducing people to labels and privilege hierarchies. I generally use others' requested pronouns to be respectful but find it feels dishonest and like perpetuating a harmful ideology; I've said I don't care about hurting feelings but the issue is when it feels dishonest. I'm skeptical that transition brings true, deep, healthy contentment, comparing it to organized religion — maybe not "true" but something some people need. I've also said diagnosis and medication are handed out as quick fixes too often, and that gender medicine is a particularly egregious example of that. I have compassion for others still identifying as trans, hoping eventually to heal enough not to have to avoid them. I've advocated for expanding who's "allowed" to be GNC, noting there's no community for masculine women attracted to men, and I've encouraged other detransitioned women to explore femininity without worrying about labels.