Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die dysforie had voordat ik wist wat trans zijn was, en die de gender-kritische gemeenschap werkelijk nuttig vond om te leren leven met mijn vrouwelijke lichaam. Ik ben de wens om te ontsnappen naar het andere geslacht gaan zien als een veelvoorkomende reactie op seksisme in plaats van een reden om te transitioneren, en ik betoog nu dat gender een sociale constructie is zonder mannelijk of vrouwelijk brein. Ik sta scherp kritisch tegenover transitie voor anderen, vooral voor van nature vrouwelijke mensen, en ik zie het medische transitiesysteem als winstgedreven. Ik raadde anderen om gezondheidsredenen testosteron af en moedigde aan geïnternaliseerde homofobie te onderzoeken. Ik heb zelf geen psychische diagnoses, zelfbeschadiging of suïcidale gedachten gemeld.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female, and I came to identify as a detransitioned person by the time I was posting in early 2019. I had dysphoria before I ever knew what being trans was — that much I stated plainly when someone suggested otherwise — but I ended up detransitioning and found the gender-critical community to be a real source of help for me.
My dysphoria, as I came to understand it, was bound up with living in what I called a sexist world. I came to see the desire to escape into the opposite sex as a real feeling, but one that is common among women rather than a signal that transition is the answer. "If you're a woman, this is normal for obvious reasons of living in a sexist world," I wrote. I came to believe the solution was not to transition but to come to terms with my biology, fight sexist gendered stereotypes, and learn to be happy with who I naturally am. I also told another person considering testosterone that it was normal for women in this society to feel uncomfortable in their bodies and wish they were the opposite sex because of prevalent sexism.
I do not have any record of specific medical interventions in this transcript — no dates for hormones, surgeries, or blockers appear — so I will not claim any. What I did say about medicine was skeptical: when I commented that "More medical procedures = more money," I was expressing a view that the transition medical system is financially motivated. I also advised against taking testosterone because of the health problems it can cause, telling someone there is nothing wrong with how their body naturally is and that being hairy doesn't make them any less of a woman.
A lot of my thinking was shaped by gender-critical feminism. "As a detrans person, GC really helped me," I wrote, and I pushed back hard against anyone who tried to steer people away from it. I rejected the idea of male and female brains as sexist, argued that gender is a social construct, and said that no clothing style or mannerism can make someone female. I was blunt and combative in debate, telling one interlocutor they sounded like they were in a cult for accepting what I called biased studies, and accusing trans women of appropriating women's experience and oppression. I did not feel sympathy for trans women in those exchanges, saying I didn't tend to feel sorry for men who gaslight and appropriate women's experience, and I described one person's claim to womanhood as fetishizing women. I also said there is no such thing as a "female essence."
I was direct with people who seemed to be struggling: I told one person that if they felt better off testosterone and not performing as a man, they should detransition, and I encouraged them to examine internalized homophobia and why it made them wish they were a man — "It's not your fault, it's society's." I told another person there's no shame in admitting you tried something and realized it's not for you, and that there's no script you have to follow. I also said there's nothing wrong with being gay or gender non-conforming.
On the whole, I was critical of transition for other people, particularly for natal females, and I saw the medical side as profit-driven. I did not do any formal advocacy or activism in this transcript beyond participating in these discussions. The subreddit itself I described as "so incredibly helpful" to me. I did not report any mental health diagnoses, self-harm, or suicidal ideation of my own; I only told someone else that if they felt like killing themselves because people disagreed with their worldview, they should seek help for a mental illness. My current identity, as of these posts, was a detransitioned woman with gender-critical views.