Alle verhalen

Van defecte implantaten in 1992 tot voorzitter van een detransitiegroep

Man · Gedesisteerd87
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een voorvechter van detransitie en voorzitter van CAUSE in Australië, en werk tegen wetgeving over 'conversietherapie' waarvan ik geloof dat die steun voor detransitie en voor kinderen die zich aan hun geboortegeslacht aanpassen zou strafbaar stellen. Ik ben christen, maar zie dit als een psychologische en fysiologische kwestie, niet als een religieuze. Ik heb zelf nooit LHBTIQ-aantrekkingen gehad en kwam hier als buitenstaander mee in aanraking, al heb ik begin jaren negentig transseksuelen geholpen met defecte borstimplantaten. Ik geloof dat de meeste kinderen met genderdysforie desisteren met de juiste steun en dat medische transitie ernstige onomkeerbare risico's met zich meebrengt die duidelijk moeten worden besproken. Ik bouw internationale netwerken op om het recht op detransitie te beschermen en te voorkomen dat steungemeenschappen zoals r/detrans worden gesloten.

Volledig verhaal

I am the Chair of CAUSE, an Australian organisation, and I have been working on a project to gather stories from ex-gays and ex-transgender people to push back against proposed 'conversion therapy' legislation in Victoria and Queensland. I am Christian, but I have always been clear that this issue of gender dysphoria and transgenderism is fundamentally one of psychology and physiology, not religion — Christianity doesn't come into it for non-Christians. My concern is that the legislation, backed by politicians like Dan Andrews and Annastacia Palaszczuk, would criminalise with fines up to $30,000 and 18 months jail any counselling, prayer, or even parental support aimed at helping a child align with their natal sex rather than affirming gender dysphoria. I believe this legislation is based on poorly written academic work citing a small number of self-reported cases of harm, and that it wrongly conflates historical aversion therapies used on homosexuals in psychiatric clinics with modern supportive counselling for gender dysphoric children. I have never had any LGBTIQ attractions myself — I am learning as an onlooker from the outside. I got into this work partly because I saw how few detransitioners who are not religious are willing to publicly tell their stories, and I wanted to help change that. In the early 1990s, my wife and I assisted transsexuals with faulty Dow Corning breast implants in Prahran, Victoria, which gave me some direct experience of the medical side of these issues. I have been vocal about the statistics: I believe 80-95% of gender dysphoric children will grow out of it if given support, whereas 100% will transgender if put on puberty blockers and affirmed. I have cited Prof John Whitehall's work on childhood gender dysphoria, Kenneth Zucker's watchful waiting approach at his gender clinic (and his eventual vindication in court after being fired), the 35 doctors who resigned from the Tavistock clinic in the UK, and the long-term Swedish study which I believe showed SRS contributing to suicide rates around 10 years post-surgery. I am deeply concerned about the irreversible consequences of medical transition — sterility, urological problems, sexual dysfunction, lifelong hormone dependence — and I believe these should be made very clear to anyone considering that path, though I accept that if someone understands the risks, going ahead is their right. I have been a strong supporter of Walt Heyer, who lived as a woman for 10 years before detransitioning and now runs a support website for detransitioners. I have also promoted the stories of Billy Burleigh and Erin Brewer. I estimate, following Walt Heyer's figures, that around 20% of transitioners regret, and I have criticised clinics for not following up with people who drop out of studies — the very people most likely to be experiencing regret and depression. My core position is one of freedom of choice: anyone should have the right to be trans if they want, and anyone should have the right to detransition if they want. What I oppose is governments legislating to take away the right to leave trans or LGBT lifestyles, and I am building networks around the globe to fight what I see as the extremes. I have warned that if these laws pass, communities like r/detrans could themselves be labelled hate groups and shut down. I have offered my personal email ([email protected]) to help connect people in Canada and elsewhere who are seeking support to detransition. I see this work as a duty — Christians like me are bound to put the welfare of others before ourselves — and I have challenged anyone to find evidence that my motives are anything other than care for people seeking help.