Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerd persoon, man geboren, die ongeveer twee tot vier jaar geleden transitioneerde en inmiddels met testosteron is gestopt. Ik heb vooral spijt van mijn transitie omdat die mijn mogelijkheden beperkte om een gezin te stichten en een conventionele partner te vinden, en omdat ik nooit sperma heb ingevroren, al heb ik geen spijt van de meeste lichamelijke effecten behalve de ongewenste borstgroei, die ik haat. Stoppen met hormonen gaf me ongeveer twee maanden ernstig libidoverlies en een maand klachten als in de menopauze, en weer testosteron nemen veroorzaakte vier maanden dagelijkse instortingen, ondanks normale bloedwaarden voor mannen. Detransitioneren was extreem zwaar — de problemen die transitie veroorzaakte gingen niet weg en oude problemen kwamen terug — en ik raad mijn pad niet aan. Ik blijf genuanceerd over transitie in het algemeen: ik denk dat identiteit vloeibaar is en dat de meeste trans mensen die ik in het echte leven ken gelukkig zijn, terwijl ik kritisch ben over de online transitiecultuur en anderen waarschuw om offline te gaan.
Volledig verhaal
I transitioned somewhere around two to four years ago — I've said that detransitioning is 'basically what we did 2-4 years ago' in reference to people now starting transition — and I've been off testosterone for a while now. I never froze sperm, which I called myself an idiot for, and that decision, along with the physical changes I got, is central to how I think about my situation now.
I regret transitioning, but not for the reasons people usually assume. My regret is that it imposed a drastic limitation on ever starting a family or finding a 'normal' partner — by which I mean not polyamorous, hypersexual, or using 'cringe babyspeak asexual' language. I also regret the fetishization that came with being visibly trans; I said it 'sucks and is almost inescapable at a certain point' and that it's 'a big part of why I wish I never transitioned.' I do not regret the physical effects of transition overall, except for breast growth — my breasts 'have gotten too big and it's annoying,' and elsewhere I confirmed 'I definitely hate my breasts.' I also don't think I live 'delusionally.'
Coming off testosterone was rough. I said getting off HRT killed my sex drive far more for about two months than it ever was while on it, and that things should eventually go back to normal. I also warned someone else, speaking from experience, that they'd have 'about a month of full on menopause' and that 'it really does kind of suck.' More strikingly, going back on testosterone 'broke my brain worse than HRT ever did somehow' — I spent four months melting down every single day over nothing, hoping it was a hormone imbalance, but my blood tests came back in normal male ranges, leading me to conclude 'something in my brain just doesn't work correctly with my body's normal chemistry.'
On the substance of transition itself, I've taken a nuanced position. I think looking to online communities like Reddit for this kind of guidance is fundamentally a mistake. I've found that most trans people I've met in real life don't ascribe to 'born this way' narratives or 'ensouled genders' — they agree identities are fluid and change throughout life, and how one's sense of physical being maps onto the societal concept of gender can shift over time. I said most trans people view transition primarily as a way to feel comfortable with your physical body, with acknowledgment that feelings may change down the line, and that every trans person I've met in the real world is a pretty happy and normal person, with one exception. I also pushed back hard on claims that people transition to escape sexualization (for women) or to escape being seen as a 'violent loser' (for men), and rejected the idea that the US is anti-male — I said the US is clearly anti-female and that sexualization of and violence against women is far worse than 'manspreading' trending. I do accept that 'culture is to blame' in the sense that gender is a fake cultural construct based around sex, and said that's analysis most people who transition have already done.
I've been candid that detransitioning was extremely hard. I told someone 'it was just way too much work detransitioning. The actual problems the transition caused didn't go away, and all the old problems also came back, which led to way too much for me to handle.' I also noted I don't really recommend my own path. On practical matters I've advised people to get offline, stop taking advice from fetish ERP Discord servers, and not worry about Reddit's opinion of their relationship. I warned that legal documents are urgent because executive branch policy changes won't distinguish between trans and detrans gender marker changes, pointing to problems Texas detrans people have had reverting markers. I estimated detransition rates at roughly 5% to maybe 10%, acknowledging that's a notoriously hard thing to study. I've also been self-aware about the community's hypocrisy, noting it 'feels weird to be so insanely aggressive about people who are basically doing what we did 2-4 years ago' and calling out 'glass houses.'
I don't appear to have had surgery — my complaints are about unwanted breast growth and I've discussed facial hair removal options like electrolysis and laser in general terms. I don't discuss family, career, or a current relationship status in this transcript, and I don't describe any formal therapy.