Alle verhalen

HOCD en de druk om zichzelf homo te noemen

Man · Gedesisteerd395
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een heteroseksuele man die nooit is getransitioneerd, maar ik herken me sterk in deze gemeenschap omdat ik vanaf ongeveer 2014 homoseksuele OCD (HOCD) heb gehad, gedreven door de media-verzadiging van lhbt-onderwerpen, en omdat ik druk kreeg van anderen om me als lhbt te identificeren. Ik heb er nooit therapie voor gezocht, omdat ik dacht dat de meeste therapeuten ten onrechte zouden aannemen dat ik in de kast zat, en uiteindelijk hield ik op aan mezelf te twijfelen. Ik heb jarenlang in deze gemeenschap betoogd dat veel transmensen eigenlijk homo zijn maar moeite hebben dat te accepteren, dat het lhbt-verhaal opzettelijk seksuele geaardheid met genderidentiteit verwart, en dat detrans-mensen het zwijgen wordt opgelegd door juist de organisaties die beweren hen te steunen. Ik ben kritisch over transitie zoals die nu wordt gepromoot, achterdochtig over therapeuten en artsen vanwege slechte ervaringen met medicatie die me werd opgedrongen, en ik geloof dat de activistische omgeving grotendeels verantwoordelijk is voor de identiteitsverwarring en het leed dat mensen hier beschrijven.

Volledig verhaal

I'm a straight man who never transitioned, but I've spent a lot of time in this community because I feel I can relate to a lot of what people here describe. Around 2014, when homosexuality and 'being closeted' were being discussed constantly, especially on places like Reddit, I started having intrusive thoughts like 'what if I was a closeted gay and just didn't know it?' — reasoning that since I also felt like I didn't fit in, maybe that was the explanation, and obviously if I were closeted I wouldn't know. Those thoughts caused me a lot of anxiety. I eventually came across the term 'homosexual OCD' (HOCD) and described it as a moment of epiphany — the common descriptions resonated with me more perfectly than anything else I'd ever heard about in my life. I recognized it as a particular way OCD manifests, and I'd shown signs of OCD as a kid, but the HOCD didn't appear until the media continually talked about homosexuality. I never talked to a therapist about it because I knew, like nearly everyone with HOCD, that most therapists would just incorrectly assume I was 'closeted' or that HOCD is some version of conversion therapy. For some reason I stopped doubting myself, and I count myself fortunate. I never really doubted my sexual orientation on a personal level, in the way a person with OCD doesn't doubt their hands are clean or a light is switched off. I've also faced pressure from others to identify as LGBT even though I'm not, and I've dealt with people making insinuations about my sexuality, which I described as making life a living hell — you can't call people on their insinuations because they can claim plausible deniability and make it about you. I went to a good therapist for something not trans-related who had religiously-motivated beliefs but was reasonable, and I was reluctant to talk to him about certain things because I worried about an unusual reaction. Separately, I've had experience with doctors who tried to force me to take high doses of medications that were making me worse, and no matter how kindly and civilly I communicated, many didn't care and wanted to impose their preconceptions. This makes me very wary of therapists generally and I've warned others here not to be lulled into a false sense of security. I've never transitioned and I'm grateful I didn't go through surgery or hormones; my heart goes out to detrans people, who I believe have been victimized and silenced by organizations that appeared friendly but oppose them where it counts. I've spent a lot of time here arguing that sexual orientation and trans status are genuinely related — that many people who transition would otherwise have identified as gay — and that the mainstream LGBT movement denies this while simultaneously exploiting the confusion. I believe the LGBT narrative constructs a dilemma that isolates detrans people: pro-LGBT therapists will assume they're really trans but closeted, while people on the right don't want to discuss it. I think continually questioning and doubting yourself due to external social pressures only leads you further away from just being you, and that some logical dilemmas effectively never terminate. I've suggested people speak their mind and say to hell with those who call them transphobe or anti-LGBT, and that what you do matters more than what you are — the reason so many transition and regret it is that they've been tricked into asking 'who am I' incessantly, which breeds self-consciousness and self-doubt. I've also discussed medical details here, like gynecomastia being caused by the presence of estrogen rather than the absence of testosterone, and that raising testosterone can worsen it because the body converts it to estrogen; I noted that antipsychotics and some antidepressants affecting prolactin can cause breast development, and that time away from exogenous hormones is what's needed. I've commented on the strong correlation between autism and trans identification, and on brain-difference research suggesting MtF brains most resemble gay male brains, which I take as support for the idea that many trans people are actually gay but struggling to accept it. I've also expressed the view that being a gay woman isn't particularly bad compared to what gay men face socially. I've been critical of the psychiatric establishment's 'chemical imbalance' narrative for antidepressants, while acknowledging the drugs may still help individuals. Overall I'm supportive of detrans people, critical of transition as currently practiced and promoted, and I believe the environment created by activist narratives is substantially responsible for the confusion and distress people here experience.