Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female. I identified as trans for a period and then desisted; by 2024 I was living as a woman again and describing myself plainly as "a woman open to DM's from another woman/female."
I desisted when my son was 2. In some ways I think his young age made it easier — we just started calling me by a different name and different pronouns and didn't make a big deal about it. He caught on quickly, and we didn't correct him if he used the old name.
On the question of what led me toward transition and then away from it, I don't lay out a full causal story in what I've written, but I do think about the roots of dysphoria. When someone else asked whether they'd ever worked through the source of their dysphoria, I told them to get really introspective about it — asking why and going deeper into why, feeling for answers rather than just thinking about them. I also suggested that anger at trans people might really be anger at oneself, and recommended therapy, noting that being trans didn't create any conflict issues that were already there.
I've thought a lot about the role of ideology and community. I told someone that no one intentionally manipulated them — people have ideologies and share them, sometimes proselytize, and it's normal for teenagers to adopt ideologies they later reject. I said people who were suffering would naturally want to share what they thought was a way out. On my own experience, I said I was more angry at the way I felt silenced by the trans community: that if you don't agree with the philosophy you're labeled transphobic and told to sit down, and that if you talk about your own experience the response is that it's a rare case and that talking about it is telling people it's okay to commit hate crimes. I then reflected that being angry at the trans community for that was also me not owning my feelings — other people's reactions weren't actually silencing me; it was my own shame.
I also shared that being trans was part of why I cut my family off, but that the way they reacted to me being trans was harmful because they are not healthy people — if they were, the relationship could have survived it. I've suggested to others that if their family seemed fine and supportive before turning noxious over a coming-out, that's unlikely, and that conflict problems predated being trans.
I've thought about physical effects of binding: I noted that binding weakens the tissue in your breast and will make them sag more or sooner. I've also commented on voice, telling someone worried about how their voice sounds in a graded oral presentation that "this is just how my voice sounds" is true, that you don't have to justify why your body is the way it is, and that they were probably overthinking it — they're being graded on oral communication skills, not gender conformity, and if they were being graded on that it would be a Title IX violation worth reporting.
I've reflected on body integrity and dysmorphia, remarking that feeling strongly you should have a limb removed is obviously dysmorphia, but feeling strongly you should have your sex organs removed is treated as rational.
Spiritually, I'm critical of New Age. I described it as a Frankenstein of other spiritualities and fabrications created to prop up ego — stuff that sounds and feels good to the practitioner but lacks the depth of the religions it borrows from, usually oriented toward "becoming your Highest Self" and manifesting whatever you want rather than the dissolution of self and attachment. I warned that messing with energetics and spirits without knowing what you're doing can do serious damage, recommended the book "The Siren Song of Hungry Ghosts" as a cautionary tale, and cautioned against hypnosis if you don't know what you're doing since it's often used for bypassing. I suggested Buddhism as a better starting point for understanding masculine and feminine energies, and recommended Angelo DiLullo/Simply Always Awake on YouTube as a teacher who is actually going through awakening. When asked what spiritual tradition has validated being trans, I answered: "Both my observations and the judgements of others that I consider legitimate."
I've been introspective about psychological changes from hormones, asking someone else whether they noticed psychological differences after starting hormones.
More recently I've been looking for professional support in the detransition space. In November 2024 I posted asking if anyone had luck contacting The Detrans Foundation — I'd tried their website but the submit button didn't appear to be working, and I was looking for internships or supervision, or similar organizations. I also noted I'd contacted someone through their website and that my ad blocker might be interfering with site functionality.