Alle verhalen

Diagnose na één psychiatriesessie — en de eetstoornis eronder

Vrouw · Gedesisteerd1,1K
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw van 21 die sociaal als transman leefde maar nooit medisch is getransitioneerd. Ik identificeer me nu als trotse, feminiene vrouw in een heteroseksuele relatie, en ik ben biseksueel. Mijn 'dysforie' bleek voort te komen uit een eetbuistoornis (sinds mijn 9e), ernstig pesten in mijn kindertijd om mijn gewicht en lichaamsbeharing, misogynie en onrealistische schoonheidsidealen. Een psychiater zei dat ik na slechts één sessie met transitie moest beginnen; in plaats daarvan zocht ik therapie voor de eetstoornis en trauma en herstelde ik mijn verbinding met mijn vrouwelijkheid. Ik ben nu kritisch over transitiegeneeskunde en pleit voor therapie en onderzoek naar de grondoorzaak vóór hormonen of operaties.

Volledig verhaal

I was born female and had what I describe as a normal, girly childhood — I was the girliest girl as a child and grew into a feminine woman. I am 21 years old now (as of early 2024), middle eastern, and I have always been hairy; I was bullied severely as a child for being a hairy girl, and my mom forced me to wax my body hair starting when I was 9. That same year, at 9, I also developed binge eating disorder, and I was always a chubby girl — now I describe myself as an overweight woman with a very feminine, hourglass figure, big breasts and a big booty. Growing up, misogyny bothered me a lot. I started to feel how disgusting it is to be a woman — I hated periods, hated how estrogen supposedly makes women more emotional, hated the pressure to be a size 0 and wear makeup every day. I felt I had to fit the feminine woman stereotype because I wanted to be loved. When I got tired of everything I had to do to be accepted as a woman, I started thinking I'd be so happy if I were a man. Those thoughts kept coming; I tried to distract myself but couldn't. Eventually I told myself, 'okay that's it, maybe I am a trans man,' and started to accept that as my 'reality.' Thankfully I never medically transitioned — no hormones, no surgeries — but I did socially transition and lived as a trans man for a period. There were people fueling it, saying things like 'you are really a man, you are not emotional like other women,' which I didn't recognize as sexist at the time. I was too busy feeling happy that misogynistic men were accepting me into their male friend groups. I later came to see that the so-called 'trans joy' was basically male privilege, and that feeling 'free' was really just relief from misogynistic standards that harm women. What ultimately moved me toward detransition was a combination of critical thinking and therapy for the actual underlying problems. I looked up what I call 'transphobic hate group' detrans subs, gender critical people, professors and scientists, and realized there is no such thing as feeling like a gender. I also had a psychiatrist appointment: when I told her I felt like a man, she said it was not an illness, that I shouldn't go to therapy for it, and that I should start transition — after only one single session with me. I did not listen to her. Instead I researched what I could do other than transition and questioned everything about myself. I realized my 'dysphoria' was actually caused by my eating disorder and the trauma of being heavily bullied for my weight as a child, which had left me disconnected from my body, my soul, and my gender. I started going to therapy for the eating disorder and the bullying trauma instead of seeking a gender change, and after that I feel better, secure, totally okay in my body, and connected with my womanhood. I also came to believe that gender roles, not dysphoria, were driving a lot of what I felt. I questioned whether what I called dysphoria was really just trying to meet the standards of what a man 'should' be. I now think gender or sex is just what you're born with, and that defining genders by stereotypes is wrong and offensive — there are masculine women and feminine men. I also came to believe that misogyny is a main cause for many trans men: the media we consume overwhelmingly features male protagonists, and I noticed that when I asked myself what gender I wanted to be, the answer was 'a man' because I wanted to be the main character, not the boring village girl the main character marries. I see that pattern in myself. I also posted about an eating disorder and body image: after trying to lose weight unhealthily and failing, I disconnected from my body and felt like a gross human being who didn't deserve love, even with my hourglass figure. I felt inferior to people who are fit, and feeling not feminine enough to be a woman traumatized me so badly that I coped by thinking I was a man. Consequences of bullying, unrealistic beauty standards, misogyny, lookism, and body shame all fed into it. On March 6, 2024, I posted that I miss being a woman — I miss being his girl, his soon-to-be wife, I want to carry our child and get pregnant, I miss girlhood, sisterhood, and sapphic spaces (I am bisexual). I am now in a heterosexual relationship with a man. I wrote that sometimes I still feel 'deceiving thoughts' but that I am a woman, that my body, my vagina, and my breasts don't deserve to be removed, that my body needs love and doesn't need to be fixed — I just need to learn how to love it. I also asked for help learning to love being a woman, noting that the fetishization of yaoi and yuri manga/anime at a young age can mess up someone's mind, and that being a guy had seemed 'freeing, happier, something desirable, no more heavy breasts, no more periods, muscles.' I want to romanticize and see the beauty of being a woman again, and I want to be a mom. I have also become quite vocal about the ethics of transition medicine. I posted asking whether it is even ethical to perform trans surgeries, especially bottom surgeries, arguing that people who want top and bottom surgeries should be sent to a psychiatrist to find the real reason behind the desire — personality disorders, autism spectrum, body image issues, derealization, dissociation, traumas, sexual assault, misogyny, patriarchy, bullying. I noted that I've seen detrans people say doctors approve hormones after one single session, which mirrors my own experience with my psychiatrist. I believe nobody should be given hormones and surgeries when there are other issues going on, and I said (perhaps intemperately) that I've never seen a trans person without mental issues, adding that I myself have an eating disorder that was the cause of my dysphoria. I also said I am not going to vote for it but don't think it is ethical to perform surgeries on people who are clearly not mentally well and need therapy instead. I believe bottom surgeries are riskier than top surgeries, cannot be reversed, and can never be functional like natural genitalia. I have engaged with the community actively: I warned others about a creepy guy DMing people in the detrans subreddit asking sexual/BDSM/feminization questions (he reached me from a different account after I blocked him, and I contacted the mods); I mistakenly accused another commenter of being that person and apologized publicly; I started a thread asking for opinions on retransitioners; and I've discussed regret rates, noting I didn't know transgender women's regret percentage was that high compared to transgender men's. Current status: I identify as a woman again — a detransitioned/desisted woman, proud of my female body, in a heterosexual relationship, bisexual, wanting to become a mother. My eating disorder is something I am still working on (I asked for tips to get rid of it). My regret is not about medical changes since I never medically transitioned, but about the time and identity spent socially transitioned and the near-miss with a psychiatrist who almost pushed me into medical transition after one session. I feel relieved and grateful I didn't. I am critical of transition for others, especially when underlying trauma, eating disorders, body dysmorphia, or mental illness are untreated, and I advocate for therapy before any medical intervention.