Alle verhalen

Communistisch organiseren vervangen door identiteitspolitiek in Portland

Man · Gedesisteerd159
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een homoseksuele man die me eerder non-binair identificeerde en sindsdien gedesisteerd is; nu zie ik sekse als een objectieve biologische categorie. Ik verliet marxistische en linkse politieke organisatie omdat die werd gedomineerd door liberale identiteitspolitiek en queertheorie in plaats van klassenanalyse, en ik ben nog steeds communist, maar inactief. Nu ben ik kritisch over performatieve trans-, gehandicapte en neurodivergente identiteiten, vooral in de scene van Portland. Ik waarschuw anderen om geen blijvende medische veranderingen door te voeren omwille van een partner. Ik heb in mijn berichten geen specifieke medische details, tijdlijnen of geschiedenis van mentale gezondheid gedeeld.

Volledig verhaal

I've lived in Portland for about 11 years now, and I've built a good group of friends I can be open with. In a metropolitan region with several million people you can always find your niche, though Portland and Seattle do have a lot of what I'd call insufferable ultraleft gender cultists — you just have to avoid those types where you can. I'm a gay man who identified as nonbinary for a while. I've since stopped identifying that way, and I now think of sex as an objective biological category — being a man or a woman is like being a redhead or short or having green eyes: traits that exist independently of our feelings about them. Having a body adapted to produce the larger gamete is what makes someone a woman, and that isn't something you can choose or will into existence with surgeries and drugs. I've told people directly that liking dolls or being into pop divas doesn't make you a woman, and that being male or female is a biological fact that doesn't determine your likes, personality, or aesthetic. My detransition or desistance from a nonbinary identification is tied up with politics. I used to be very active on the left — I was in a Marxist party and interacted with other parties and groups on the broader left. I gave a lot of time, labor, and money to causes I eventually came to really disagree with. What I found was that actual Marxism, with a class-based material analysis, had very little role in the 'Marxist' party I was in — it was maybe 10% Marxism and 90% liberal identity politics, postmodernism, and anarchism. The trans and queer issues were a big part of why I stepped back. I had to leave, and I don't regret it. I'm still a communist, though I'm not active in any political movement like I was before. If a Marxist party formed that rejected queer theory and supported things like homosexuality and gay marriage being legal, and had a good line on a few other issues, I'd likely join and get active again. I've also become quite critical of what I see as performative identity claims more broadly. In Portland, the disabled/trans/neurodivergent/DID systems are a dime a dozen, and they all seem to be feeding off each other's performances — people using walkers and canes who don't actually have mobility issues. My read is that the disabled/trans/neurodivergent kids are almost all white, and I think it's a way for them to construct an oppressed identity in order to lessen the 'harm' they cause by being white. I'm skeptical of people who medically transition for a partner's sake. I once advised someone directly that their partner sounded like a chaser and that they shouldn't make any permanent changes to themselves for him, because it's the person themselves who will have to deal with the consequences, not the partner. If the partner can't accept them as they are, that's the partner's issue to work through, not theirs. I don't go into detail about specific medical interventions, timelines, or surgeries in what I've shared publicly — my account here is more about identity, politics, and how I came to the views I hold now.