Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die door online trans-geïdentificeerde vrienden onder druk werd gezet om HRT te nemen terwijl ik psychisch ziek en autistisch was en in een gewelddadige relatie zat, en die op mijn 22e een operatie onderging. Nu heb ik dagelijks intens spijt van die operatie: verlies van alle tast- en erotische gevoeligheid, chronische fascia- en zenuwpijn en onvruchtbaarheid, en later ontmoette ik iemand met wie ik kinderen wilde. Ik zegde mijn baan bij een genderkliniek op voordat ik detransitioneerde, vanwege hoe adolescenten versneld naar hormonen en operaties werden geleid, en later werd bij toeval een stoornis in de seksuele ontwikkeling vastgesteld die veel van mijn geschiedenis verklaarde. Ik heb PTSS, een paniekstoornis en een ernstige eetstoornis, en wat me het meest heeft geholpen is radicale acceptatie, CGT, het verdragen van spanning en weggaan uit online transgemeenschappen. Ik pleit nu sterk tegen medische transitie, vooral voor minderjarigen, terwijl ik het geluk van anderen steun en opmerk dat sommige mensen in deze gemeenschap geen spijt hebben van hun keuzes.
Volledig verhaal
I came to this issue as a young adult who was pressured by trans-identified friends and acquaintances online — mostly on Twitter — into starting HRT, at a time when I was a mentally ill autistic person in an abusive relationship and suffering from severe depression. Those people told me body modification would cure my depression, and they were neither medical professionals nor people who knew me or what was best for my life. I also had a diagnosis of gender dysphoria from medical professionals, and I did what doctors told me would fix me, because we are raised to trust medical authority.
I had surgery at age 22. I have intense, daily surgical regret about it: I lost all tactile and erotic sensation, I have ongoing severe fascia and nerve/myofascial pain from unsightly scarring, and I am now sterile. I later met someone I wanted to have children with and found myself incapable of performing basic functions because of choices I made as a "dumb kid," influenced by internet strangers and supported by quack therapists. I look back and cannot believe I ruined myself at such a young age, before I even knew myself; if I could go back in time I would never do it again. I also have joint pain that is sometimes crippling, and I was on Lupron at some point — I wish I could sue but have no resources. I have had both laser and electrolysis for facial hair.
I reframed detransition as simply discontinuing a medical treatment rather than an identity: "it didn't work out for me." Almost everyone in my actual life — colleagues, friends, family — accepted it immediately and casually; only the "real trans fanatic types" turned hostile, treating me as an apostate. I quit my job at a gender clinic even before I detransitioned, because I was seeing adolescents given hormones after a 30-minute appointment with a provider they had never met, which fast-tracked them to surgery sometimes within 4-6 months of the onset of dysphoria; I knew I could no longer ethically be part of it.
What has helped me is first-line mental health treatment: distress tolerance, cognitive behavioral therapy, radical acceptance — of my natal body and of how transitioning damaged it — plus getting off the internet, getting away from trans hugboxes, and making positive life changes. Radical acceptance is the most potent tool for me: "I had this surgery. This is how my body is now. I can't go backward. All I can do is move forward." I practice looking directly at my body and picking out features I actually like instead of fixating on what I cannot change. I am healthier now than I have ever been in my life and can find acceptance and beauty in parts of myself I never thought I could like, including big scars, though I still cry sometimes and still struggle with guilt.
I experienced what I describe as getting out of a cult and had an extremely typical "got out of a cult" reaction, including tremendous guilt for behaviors I took part in; it took me about two years to fully mentally leave that space. I have looked for a therapist specializing in cult recovery but found little in my area, and I believe no ordinary therapist can help with this guilt because the field is captured by gender ideology. Steven Hassan's comparison of detransitioner treatment to cult apostates resonated with me. My personal hypothesis is that the internet decentralized the cult: instead of one charismatic leader there are many social media influencers functioning as classic cult leaders promising to remove your unhappiness.
I was eventually diagnosed with a disorder of sexual development via an incidental finding on genetic screening for something else. It explained my androgynous appearance, unusual puberty, and chronic medical issues. When I was younger I tried to ask doctors about a possible hormonal disorder and was ignored because "people with those kinds of issues are usually more obvious." I believe many of my issues with gender, body, and mind could have been explained by this, and my physical and psychological issues could probably have been treated with hydrocortisone rather than disfiguring surgeries. I now know, as an adult, that I also have PTSD, anorexia (an eating disorder I still suffer from), and panic disorder; if I had received actual differential diagnosis and treatment instead of affirmation, I would have had these treated competently and conservatively — instead I am sterile.
I have a partner who used to self harm, and we were both trans-identified at the same time; I began detaching from my trans identity and the trans community when discourse demanding that people rewrite their own memories about a trans person's birth sex became mainstream, because it was clear no genuinely marginalized group could achieve that. I also note that dysphoria is closely related to anorexia in that for some it is an illness arising from an urge to maintain control over one's own body, and I was in a slash fanfiction-to-trans-man pipeline as a teenager.
I now advocate strongly against medical transition in almost all circumstances, especially for minors, and I have spent a great deal of time arguing this on Reddit. I describe myself as being as far left as possible except on the gender ideology issue. I do not regret speaking out: I will throw myself out there for anyone trying to stop other people from doing what I did, and I don't feel tired of it yet. I support people being happy and note that this community contains people who don't regret their choices, but I believe the evidence does not support transgender medicine and that I was personally very harmed by it.