Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerd persoon, man geboren, die in oktober 2018 stopte met oestrogeen zonder testosteronblokkers, na ongeveer 18 maanden aaneengesloten HRT (plus zes maanden af en aan), en terugkeerde naar mijn geboortenaam. Ik zie mijn dysforie als geworteld in autogynefilie, en ik heb een formele diagnose borderline persoonlijkheidsstoornis van een psychiatrisch ziekenhuis, naast depressie en angst. Detransitie is zwaar geweest: in januari 2019 meldde ik dat het ‘niet goed met me gaat omdat ik nog steeds een vrouw wil zijn’, en ik heb een eerder suïcideplan gehad, al maak ik die plannen nu niet meer. Ik heb last gehad van ongewenst terugkerende lichaams- en gezichtsbeharing, gemengde gevoelens over mijn borsten en genitaliën en voortdurend verdriet omdat ik niet meer als vrouw leef. Ik blijf ambivalent: soms mis ik HRT, soms wil ik gewoon detransitioneren. Ik pleit voor voorzichtigheid bij het starten van HRT en trek het gemelde detransitiepercentage van 3% in twijfel.
Volledig verhaal
I was born male and, looking back, I can see now that my dysphoria had a very psycho-sexual root — I identify with the concept of autogynephilia (AGP) and believe it is the source of my dysphoria. I first started identifying as a trans woman and went on testosterone blockers-free hormone therapy — a small shot in the belly once a week, no other medicines — for roughly 18 months continuously plus about six months on and off, using my endocrinologist's prescription. I never took spiro.
I came out and lived as a trans woman for a period. During that time I enjoyed finally going on dates and having my first sexual experiences with men; I no longer felt "invisible" in that way, I started liking dressing like a woman every day, and I had fun with selfies. But not a whole lot got better: I was still in seclusion 90% of the time and very depressed, caught in an existential battle — "is this who I really am? Do I want attention? Is this just a fetish?" I also felt shame about being feminine. Before transition I was super shy and most people thought I was gay; it had been far easier being a "cute shy girl" than a "weird shy loser" when it came to dating.
On 2018-10-25 I posted that I had officially quit HRT, going off cold turkey. Within a couple of weeks I could already feel the effects of testosterone returning in my mood, personality, and skin. My endocrinologist wanted to test my levels after three months. I never changed my birth certificate, but I had legally changed my name, and changing it back a second time within a year became a bureaucratic nightmare — I live far from the state my ID is in, so I had to get a new ID in my current state with the old name before I could change it again.
I describe myself as one of the people who "fell through the cracks." It's very easy to get on HRT in big cities, including through informed consent. I don't blame anyone, because I should have explored my own feelings more first. I believe people should see if presenting a certain way every day — and really trying to pass — is for them before doing anything invasive, and that a lot of people experience dysphoria but transition isn't the best treatment for everyone.
I was formally diagnosed with borderline personality disorder at a mental hospital. I have plenty of cognitive distortions that get in my way, and the borderline diagnosis "shakes things up" in my life. My therapist is pretty affirming — he just wants me to find an identity that's right for me — and when I told him about my AGP he said I should look how I want to. I've also dealt with depression and anxiety; I've recommended pramipexole to others as an antidepressant.
Before, I was a bitter recluse. I became very macabre and started watching The Fly repeatedly — dark times. Nothing was working out: I was working as a dishwasher, which I hated, had no close friends, and no one was looking out for me. I also had a suicide plot in the back of my mind. I no longer plan on suicide, but I said I am "so broken now I don't know what I'm going to do or how I'm going to live my life."
Detransition has been hard. In January 2019 I reported that I was "not doing well because I still want to be a woman." The things that bother me now include beard growth, body hair ("This really sucks and not something I anticipated"), looking "manly" in proportions, my hairline, and mixed feelings about my breasts and genitalia — though I would never have SRS. I get sad about getting older. I also said I still don't want to "grow up."
Socially, I told my employer about my situation and he was OK with it. I went back to using my birth name and applied for a retail job with it. Appearance-wise I kept long hair, shaped brows, and no facial hair, but wore masculine clothes and had a male-sounding voice. On 2018-12-12 I got "the big haircut" — though I have a no-clippers policy and like bangs. I veer more toward masculine clothes now but still don't want to cut my hair short. I was 27 at that time.
I met someone in real life, through a non-transgender-related program, who is also detransitioning — he took hormones for a time and is seeking top surgery. That surprised me because I would never have guessed he was ever gender variant. I think the commonly cited 3% detransition figure is dead wrong: changing everything about yourself is a recipe for disaster, and the regret figure isn't higher because few detransitioners are willing to disclose, and many move on and disown being trans so they wouldn't take a trans-related survey anyway.
Sexually, before transition I had flings with men but always wanted to role play and be the girl — I would paint my toenails, shave my legs — and I still felt dysphoria, feeling like (trans) womanhood was my only path to happiness. I've said "cuddles with men are awesome" and that I'm going to miss being the girl in the relationship. After experiencing dating as a woman, I said I'll probably not want to date as a man, since it's less fun having to do the work of pursuing and being dominant.
I still hold a nuanced view of AGP and transition: I don't think there is anything wrong with transitioning as an AGP person, and I'd argue many trans women have it. On bathrooms I'm iffy — I don't think trans women should use the men's bathroom but I'm not sure about the women's either, out of respect for their own space. I think of some trans women as women and others not so much, depending on commitment, poise, and assimilation; I wouldn't call myself a woman by my own criteria.
I've told others not to take HRT if they have doubts, to investigate whether their dysphoria is sexual, and that it's OK not to be a woman. I've also advised people to get their depression and anxiety in order before doing anything rash, and that sometimes when people are depressed they want to throw away everything they have to reinforce their misery. I posted to detrans because I find it a more helpful forum than MtF or asktransgender, and I insisted I don't post to invalidate others or with an agenda — I'm struggling with my feelings and looking for help.