Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een man die nooit is getransitioneerd maar autogynefilie (AGP) heeft, wat volgens mij het enige was dat me deed denken dat ik trans was, samen met zelfhaat en suïcidale gedachten. Ik heb nooit hormonen genomen of medische ingrepen gehad, en ik had last van een lage libido door SSRI’s, wat verbeterde nadat ik overstapte op Wellbutrin. Ik ben als commentator actief in detrans- en gendercritische discussies, waarbij ik de realiteit van AGP verdedig en kritiek heb op hoe AGP-mannen worden gedemoniseerd. Ik heb genuanceerde opvattingen over transkwesties, veiligheid en vooroordelen, en ik erken dat ik kritiek soms te persoonlijk heb opgevat. Ik heb geen formeel activisme gedaan en mijn huidige identiteit is die van een niet-getransitioneerde man met AGP.
Volledig verhaal
I was born male. I have never been on hormones and have never socially or medically transitioned, but I do have autogynephilia (AGP) — I've written, "I have AGP. It's literally the only thing about me that made me think I was trans (besides self-hatred, suicidal ideation, etc)." That is the closest I came to identifying as trans; I never came out, never changed my name or presentation, and never pursued any medical steps.
I first encountered the concept of AGP early on and described it plainly: "Autogynophilia. It's when males feel aroused at the thought of being a female." Over time I came to see AGP as a real and important phenomenon, and I pushed back hard against people who deny it exists: "I think the idea that AGP is a myth is incredibly dangerous for people like me." I also argued that the way society talks about AGP pushes men like me toward trans ideology: "If you've got one side saying you're a creepy predatory misogynistic narcissistic fetishist, and you've got the other side saying you're just really a woman born in the wrong body, what do you expect is going to happen?"
I believe my AGP developed in the context of misogynistic attitudes I held: "I'll admit I have (or at least had) some misogynistic views that led to me developing this fetish in the first place, but fetishes aren't really something you can get rid of as far as I know." Alongside the AGP I struggled with self-hatred and suicidal ideation, which I listed as additional factors behind my thinking I was trans.
I have dealt with mental health treatment: I was on SSRIs — citalopram first, then escitalopram — and experienced lowered libido from them. I later switched to Wellbutrin (bupropion), which I said "has pretty much reversed my low libido." I offered this as advice to another poster while acknowledging our situations weren't comparable.
On sexuality and consent, I described an early experience: "as a kid I thought I was literally 'homophobic' because I was deeply uncomfortable with being touched sexually by boys/men. Turns out I just didn't like being touched without consent, go figure!" I don't describe myself as gay or straight anywhere in these posts.
I'm active in detrans and gender-critical spaces as a commentator rather than a detransitioner. I've discussed a sibling's gender identity with some confusion — I asked someone why they kept calling their sibling "brother" when they disagreed with that person's gender identity, and when challenged I said, "It was just confusing to me is all. I wasn't trying to be rude." I also expressed empathy toward someone whose sibling was transitioning, telling them they shouldn't feel guilty: "There are a ton of external and internal pressures for these kind of things and we can't control how other people behave or react. They're just caught up in the same shit that you were."
I'm critical of how the word "transphobic" is used, arguing it's more of an insult than a useful term, and I hold a generally live-and-let-live view: "it's perfectly fine to hold hatred for ideologies, behaviors, etc, but you shouldn't hate entire groups of people based on the way some (or even most) of them act." I'm also skeptical of how men with AGP are treated in these debates, while acknowledging that some AGPs are a genuine problem: "I agree that many AGPs, particularly the ones that vehemently deny that AGP even exists, are a serious problem." I conceded I may have taken criticism too personally: "You're right, I may have taken this a little too personally. And taking it so personally might make me look like a narcissist, lol."
On safety, I accepted that women have good reason to be cautious around male strangers: "Sure, it hurts my feelings to be thought of as a threat, but I recognize that it's not a risk a woman should be willing to take with a male stranger. It's just something men have to accept, and I wish MTFs would accept it too." I also noted I walk on eggshells around women: "I already feel like I walk on eggshells to avoid making women feel uncomfortable."
I have opinions on punk music and politics — I think punk became conformist once it was redefined as simply progressive leftist — and I've made a passing critical remark about Don Cheadle's "Protect Trans Kids" shirt. I also noted I'm the same age as a poster who came out as nonbinary in middle school, saying the concept "was not on the radar of myself or anyone I knew back then," which places my own adolescence before nonbinary identity was widely discussed.
I have not done any formal advocacy or activism. I've never had surgery, never been on hormones, and have no medical complications or fertility concerns to report. I don't describe any current relationship, family, or career impacts. My regret, to the extent I express it, is about the self-hatred and suicidal ideation tied up with the AGP rather than about any lost time in transition, since I never transitioned.