Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die nooit een sterke genderidentiteit had en, na worstelen toen ik jonger was, besefte dat mijn ongemak ging over het niet passen in vrouwelijke stereotypen en niet over man zijn. Ik zat in de online transgemeenschap voordat het een trend werd, maar trok me terug nadat ik zag dat vragen werden gesmoord en ideologie boven wetenschap werd gezet, vooral het gebrek aan onderzoek naar vrouwelijke transitioneerders. Ik geloof dat echte genderdysforie bestaat maar zeldzamer is dan recente cijfers doen vermoeden, en ik denk dat het percentage spijt veel hoger is dan de vaak aangehaalde 1%. Ik ben kritisch over het geven van hormonen aan jongeren, waaronder beginnen met testosteron op 15, terwijl ik me nog steeds pro-transrechten noem. Ik ben actief in deze detransitiegemeenschap, waar ik anderen probeer te steunen bij hun eigen twijfels.
Volledig verhaal
I never had a strong sense of gender identity, and for a long time I thought something must be wrong with me because of it. Looking back, I think I mistook not fitting the feminine stereotype for gender dysphoria. I struggled with the same thing when I was younger, and over some years I came to realize it was not actually a gender thing — it was that I had not found myself yet. I now accept myself as a woman who is not especially feminine, and I genuinely do not know anyone who walks around constantly feeling like a man or a woman; I barely feel like my gender two seconds of the year, and I think that is fine.
I was in the online trans community for a long time — long enough that I was there before it became a trend — and I was in a Discord channel where people were thrown out for asking a single question. That experience of being frozen out, along with seeing how ideology seemed to be put above science, is what made me step away from the online community. I am pro trans rights, but I do not think it is healthy that you are not allowed to ask even one question, and I have read about doctors who are pushed by ideology. The people who suffer from that are the ones who should have been informed before making a choice. I am not American; I live in a European country that is far more left than the American left, and I think the American black-and-white politics is a big part of the problem. I consider myself a proud Democrat and believe in open debate.
I care a lot about the lack of medical research on female transitioners. Almost all research is done on biological men, and the changes to organs in female-to-male transition are barely talked about. I was aware organs grew bigger, but not the full extent of what people have described to me, and I am grateful when people bring it to light. I think it is insane that people get banned for discussing this. I also think it is sad that young people are not told it is okay to be a masculine girl, and I have a lot of respect for those who dare to challenge the mindset of giving hormones and surgeries to children. When I hear about someone starting testosterone at 15, I find it shocking and believe the ideology behind it should be held responsible for young people being put on life-changing medication.
I do believe genuine gender dysphoria exists, but I think it is much rarer than the numbers of recent years suggest, and I do not believe only 1% regret transitioning — I think the real numbers are much higher and that one day the truth will come out. I think a lot of people who went through with transition will realize it was not right, but may stay silent. I also think more people than we think have been misdiagnosed. I put very little into the idea of 'feeling like' a gender, though I do think people can feel that a body part does not belong to them.
I have been on both sides of this and try to be supportive: I have told a young person considering breast reduction to wait until their early 20s, reassured a detransitioning person that their voice sounded female, and asked how someone's voice has recovered after stopping testosterone. I also noted that I have heard of more people's bodies returning closer to their original shape after a couple of years off testosterone, though it is individual. I try to encourage people not to compare themselves to idealized versions of gender on social media while in a vulnerable place. Overall, I stepped away from the online community but remain active in this detransition community, where I feel people are open and can debate respectfully.