Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die zich als transmasculien/non-binair persoon identificeerde, rond mijn 21e sociaal transitioneerde, een top surgery kreeg (zonder spijt) en na ongeveer 1,5-2 maanden stopte met testosteron toen mijn dysforie verergerde. Ik accepteer mezelf nu als masculiene, vrouwelijke persoon, heb nog steeds dysforie en beheers die met therapie, medicatie tegen angst/depressie, beweging en gemeenschap in plaats van met verdere medische transitie. Ik voel me verraden door het gebrek aan informed consent en open gesprek in de transgemeenschap, en ik pleit voor meer onderzoek, begeleiding en alternatieve benaderingen van dysforie vóór transitie. Ik heb geen spijt van mijn operatie of van het proberen van HRT, maar ben bang dat ik anderen heb beïnvloed en geloof dat sociale besmetting een rol speelt bij de stijgende transitiecijfers.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female and grew up feeling, from a young kid, that I was "more like a boy" — I expressed this before I even knew the word transgender existed. I had dysphoria for most of my life. Growing up I never saw masculine women in media who looked like me; representation was mostly larger butch women or stereotypical masc lesbians, while women on screen were hyper-feminized or sexualized, which made me deeply uncomfortable. Most of my favorite characters, real-life role models, and people in my job/field were male. I internalized the idea that since I was not like those women, I must be male.
I came out as transmasculine (FtM) about five years before March 2022 — around 2017, at age 21 — and socially transitioned, fighting hard to prove myself to family, coworkers, and people at school. I was publicly open about my queerness, had many trans friends, and was a huge advocate for the trans community. I lived most of my life feeling like a guy. I eventually pursued top surgery, which I knew I wanted and which I do not regret at all. I waited until my mid-20s before deciding on hormones, and I was on testosterone for about a month and a half to two months before stopping.
I was given HRT after my first appointment at the clinic, with no real counseling or examination of other mental health issues first. Once on T I started getting permanent changes — facial hair and bottom growth — and realized this wasn't what I wanted for the rest of my life. My dysphoria was getting worse in new areas, like my bone structure and genitals, things I couldn't change. I was constantly scrutinizing myself: whether talking with my hands was too feminine, whether crossing my legs was too feminine, checking my face, voice, and body for not being "cis male" enough, and feeling socially exhausted before I even left the house. I developed imposter syndrome and anxiety in public spaces. I realized my dysphoria was never going to go away and would only get worse the more I fed it.
The turning point came around two months on T, when I decided to quit. Breaking my internet addiction is what gave me the realizations I needed to stop my transition — online was where I felt most comfortable expressing transness, but offline it was hell. I looked into other reasons for my dysphoria, including trauma, and came to see my dysphoria as more like an escapist trauma response and a mental illness that needed to be addressed as such. I also researched the medical side effects of HRT that no one seemed to want to discuss — uterine/vaginal atrophy, heart problems, cartilage and joint breakdown, ovarian cysts, possible hysterectomy — and decided I wasn't willing to commit to hormones for the rest of my life or be a guinea pig.
I still identify as non-binary and still experience dysphoria, but I decided not to continue my transition. I'm coming to accept myself as a masculine, female person. I still have trouble feeling comfortable with female pronouns and words and would feel embarrassed using them after all the time, effort, and money I spent proving my male identity — though truthfully they/them pronouns feel exhausting too. I don't regret my top surgery or trying HRT, because they helped me figure out what I did and didn't need to feel like "me."
I feel betrayed by the trans community. I wish my therapist had encouraged other methods of coping with dysphoria before jumping to transition. I'm scared I've influenced others down the same path, scared of kids and teenagers making uninformed permanent medical decisions, and terrified seeing whole friend groups in my art/cosplay communities all being trans — I believe social contagion is at play. I've been doing my best to manage mental health and trauma first, with hormonal transition as an absolute last resort, and I've been getting on the right medication for anxiety and depression, which made a world of difference. I compiled a comprehensive list of healthy ways to cope with dysphoria without transitioning, and I advocate for more non-politicized discussion, better long-term research, and more counseling before medical intervention. I try to stay compassionate and level-headed, viewing this chapter of my life "like a book on my shelf, not something locked away in the basement."