Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die uit de transitie kwam en besefte dat de mensen die het meest om me gaven degenen waren die ik had genegeerd terwijl ik geobsedeerd was door transitie. Ik nam testosteron en kreeg onomkeerbare lichamelijke veranderingen, en ik waarschuw anderen nu tegen medische transitie, voorspel rechtszaken en bekritiseer wat ik zie als winstgedreven medische wanpraktijken. Ik pleit actief tegen transitie voor jongeren, deel kritisch onderzoek en bronnen, en moedig mensen aan op hun gevoel te vertrouwen en zich publiekelijk uit te spreken. Ik heb vijandigheid en uitsluiting van de transgemeenschap ervaren nadat ik vertrok, maar vond steun elders. Ik geloof dat er iets bevredigenders uit de pijn kan komen en gebruik mijn verhaal om anderen te helpen.
Volledig verhaal
I came to transition as a young person who was, in my own words, "obsessed with transitioning" — so consumed by it that I couldn't see that the people around me were the ones who cared for me the most. I don't lay out every step of my medical timeline in what I've written, but I did go on testosterone at some point: I've told others researching hormones that "Being on T has a load of side effects, please be sure to research them fully for answers," which tells you I have direct experience of being on it. I also speak from the other side of surgery and irreversible bodily change, warning people that "Irreversible bodily decisions don't need to come into play to be yourself" and that life's issues "cannot be resolved with simply taking a pill or cutting off things that grow on us."
What moved me toward detransition was a combination of realizing who actually loved me, and becoming deeply skeptical of the ecosystem I had been part of. I described the trans community as promising friendship and love when you become trans, but casting you out when you leave: "Unlike the trans community of which will cast you out even tho they promised friendship and love when you became trans, leaving the trans community is a whole different story." I've said that how many people remain friends with anyone from the trans community without being judged is a real question, and that support and love do exist — "sometimes it may take some searching to find it."
I also came to see the online environment I'd been in as molding me: "It's literally what you surround yourself with (online counts) that effects you and molds you." I described a kind of enforced cheerfulness in those spaces as "toxic positivity," saying that if something presents itself as only happiness, love, and unity, it's never actually that. I've called the whole thing "a big malicious lie" and said I don't know how it started but that it's "very deep and dark."
On the medical side, I've become openly critical. I said I think transition medicine has become "a money making scheme for these 'medical' quackery companies to exploit young people into their malpractices and human experiments," and that I hope lawsuits start to pop up because too many lives are being wrecked. I said the only reason I can see for doctors not seeking mental/psychology help first "before deconstructing a body and doing irreversible damage" is money. I predicted lawsuits: "Detransitioning you're already seeing - but absolutely in a couple of years give or take there will be lawsuits to follow, those are also already happening." I've also cited desistance research — that back in 2013, 80 out of 127 adolescents had desisted by ages 15 and 16, and that I've heard the number today is 60-90%, a figure I attribute to Dr. Deborah Soh.
I've recommended Dr. Deborah Soh's work and book (The End of Gender) as "incredibly eye opening," and defended it vigorously against people calling it transphobic, arguing that using biological science is not a phobia and that the label is a tactic to shut down conversation. I've shared resources including a YouTube video, an Ovarit link about Janice Turner and Keira Bell, a Medium piece called "The Elephant in the Room," and pointed people to LGBdroptheT on Saidit.net. I've quoted IGLYO's 2019 document, specifically page 17's line about "no need to obtain a professional or medical diagnosis to change legal gender," calling it "incredibly devious."
I've been vocal about speaking out, telling others to stop remaining silent and to tell people about this "not just here in this subreddit," even if hated: "standing up for what is right, you'll have more self respect and feel better about yourself." I've encouraged people to trust their gut when they have doubts about transitioning — "If you have doubts, I'd always say go with your gut and don't proceed" — and to do real scientific research rather than YouTube influencers' research. I've warned about predatory dynamics, describing an approach as "very predatory" and comparing a shaming tactic to "i heard shelly won't suck your dick" — a ploy to get people to do things they'd never otherwise do, tied to fetishization of transitioned people. I've also said that it's okay not to look like what society says is masculine or feminine and still be your biological sex.
I've been supportive of other detransitioners publicly — congratulating them, telling one "you look AMAZING," and sharing an interview titled "Growing Out of GroupThink | with Helena" that I called "such an amazing detrans interview." I've also said that females are being "taken away from being a proud female" and that you can wear whatever you want without changing yourself medically. I've expressed concern about Reddit itself, saying it's "not a safe place" and that it's controlled by "the overlords of the trans big pharmaceutical companies, NGO's & big tech."
I've dealt with hostility: I've been called names and told I'm quoting fascist playbooks, and I've responded that nothing I said was hateful and asked people not to distort reality. I've told people not to give hateful critics any light unless they're mentally and factually prepared, and to educate themselves rather than stoop to name-calling. I've said I won't be offended by terms I know don't define me: "I know who I am. No words can puncture through to who I know I am."
I've also reflected on my own behavior and admitted I've been the jerk at times, calling that realization "massive internal (and to me, spiritual) growth." I've told others that patience and self-forgiveness matter, and that there's hope. I've prayed for someone else to find peace, and I've been open about the pain of the whole experience while believing something more fulfilling can come out of it.