Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een afgestudeerde socioloog met stellig genderkritische opvattingen die pleit tegen transitie als behandeling van dysforie, tegen zelfverklaringsdefinities van geslacht en gender, en tegen non-binaire identiteit als effectieve politieke strategie. Ik geloof dat trans zijn vaak een symptoom is van diepere problemen zoals seksueel misbruik in de kindertijd, en dat transitie het oppervlak behandelt en niet de oorzaak. Ik noemde mezelf vroeger links maar doe dat niet meer, en ik merk nu dat ik niet vrij kan spreken in links georiënteerde politieke ruimtes. Ik heb in dit materiaal geen persoonlijke ervaring met transitie of detransitie beschreven. Mijn huidige identiteit is die van een genderkritische, niet-trans persoon die advies en argumenten geeft in plaats van een persoonlijk detransitieverhaal.
Volledig verhaal
I have a sociology degree, and my teachers there distinguished organized cults from a decentralized form they called "cultist behavior" — a framework I still use when I look at social movements. I used to consider myself a leftist and enjoyed talking politics with leftist friends, but repeated experiences have made me ashamed of the term; for example, about an hour before writing one comment I left a debate with a leftist friend who insisted biological sex doesn't exist and wanted me to prove him wrong — I found the whole situation absurd and walked away. I can't speak my mind in those debates anymore.
I have come to hold strongly gender-critical views. I argue that disagreeing with an ideology does not mean denying that the people exist: "I disagree with the logic and the analysis I'm not denying your existence." I think self-declaration definitions of "woman" are circular and unworkable at scale, and that sex-based protections — changing rooms, bathrooms, sex-segregated sports — are necessary because men assault women far more often than the reverse. I believe gender is not an identity but a sociological set of expectations and behaviors: "Gender is sociological, it's not about identity and never has been." My advice to people with dysphoria is to work on the dysphoria before permanently altering the body: "Dysphoria is temporary while transition is (for some parts) permanent." I think transitioning carries health risks and does not guarantee dysphoria will go away, and that psychotherapy can address dysphoria more efficiently and permanently. I have said gender dysphoria can resolve naturally with time or through self-work.
I view being trans as in many cases a symptom of something deeper, such as surviving sexual abuse as a child or young teen — I noted that every non-binary and trans classmate I had at university had been sexually assaulted. I see transition as a way to run away from problems, treating the surface instead of underlying issues, which can then cause greater damage if left unattended. I also believe suicide figures around trans issues are exaggerated to push political ideas aggressively, as a form of emotional blackmail. I welcomed news coverage of the link between autism and transgender identity, saying it "definitely needs to be more studied," and I described a case of a child being pushed toward transition as "textbook child abuse."
I am critical of non-binary identity specifically. I distinguish three concepts: non-binary as a feeling or identity with no science behind it and essentially limited to Western cultures; gender non-conforming as simply going against your gender's typical behavior or looks; and androgynous as a physical trait of being hard to sex on sight. I argue that claiming a new label like non-binary is a "selfish waste of time" that won't change society, whereas true feminism changes society rather than one's own personal life: "This is the difference between trans ideology and radical feminism." I have described identity-focused gender discourse as a first-world luxury — "You have ran out of problems to worry about so you close in on your 'identity'" — and said, "Go out in the forest for a few days see if your gender matters there. Y'all are losing grasp on reality." I also wrote, "gender only exists if you believe in it" and then, "Oops I stopped believing."
I have been blunt and combative in these exchanges, telling one interlocutor they sounded like they were 16 and lived in an alternate reality, and expressing disgust at specific comics I associate with child sexual abuse material. I also noted that intersex conditions are birth malformations occurring across species, not a third sex, and that most trans and non-binary people are not intersex. I have not described any personal experience of dysphoria, transition, or detransition in this transcript — my contributions have been argumentative and advisory rather than autobiographical.