Alle verhalen

Vijf jaar in activistische kringen, daarna terug naar de kliniek

Vrouw · Gedetransitioneerd246
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw en medisch professional die zich een tijd als trans identificeerde en ongeveer vijf jaar diep verankerd was in transactivistische kringen. Ik ervoer genderdysforie en overwoog te transitioneren, mede door de boodschap in transgemeenschappen dat ik als gendernonconformistisch persoon ‘niet vrouw genoeg’ was. Ik heb een geschiedenis van trauma en heb EMDR-therapie aanbevolen om trauma te verwerken. Ik heb zorgen over het affirmatieve zorgmodel en het ontbreken van onderzoek naar psychiatrische comorbiditeit bij dysfore patiënten. Ik heb me publiekelijk uitgesproken over de schade van puberteitsremmers, het gebrek aan bewijs dat medische transitie werkt, en de oversexualisering van vrouwelijkheid in de transgemeenschap.

Volledig verhaal

I am a detransitioned woman and a medical professional. I was born female. I identified as trans for a period and was deeply embedded in trans activist circles for about five years. I experienced gender dysphoria and considered transitioning in part because of the messaging I received in trans communities that I was 'not enough of a woman' as a gender non-conforming person. I also experienced internalized misogyny, describing myself as 'old'/unwanted/unattractive at 28. I have a history of trauma and have recommended EMDR therapy for trauma processing. I have concerns about the affirmative model of care and the lack of exploration of psychiatric comorbidities in dysphoric patients. I have spoken out publicly about the harms of puberty blockers, the lack of evidence for medical transition's effectiveness, and the oversexualization of femininity in the trans community. I have also expressed concern about the medical establishment's ties to puberty blocker manufacturers and the lack of evidence-based treatments in trans medicine. I have a colleague who is a surgeon and has shared with me that vocal surgery has one of the highest regret rates and lowest success rates among surgeries. I have recommended voice training and voice therapy as alternatives to vocal surgery for detransitioned women. I have also recommended distress tolerance therapy, radical acceptance, and checking for OCD for individuals struggling with gender dysphoria. I have recommended detaching from online trans communities and trans-focused media as part of the process of feeling better in one's own body. I have also expressed concern about the use of experimental medicine on dysphoric people and the potential harms of puberty blockers, including the risk of not having sufficient genital tissue for reassignment surgery. I have also expressed concern about the lack of evidence for the 'wrong brain' theory of dysphoria and the importance of focusing on which interventions, if any, are appropriate to help cope with distress rather than ruminating on quasi-religious questions. I have also expressed concern about the medical establishment's willingness to perform mastectomies as early as 14 years of age and to initiate hormones on any new patient's first visit with a clinician as long as they were 17 years of age or older, without a wait, therapy referral, comorbidity evaluation, or even bloodwork. I have also expressed concern about the lack of quality evidence that medical transition decreases suicidality or suicide attempts in the long term, or improves mental health or quality of life in the long term. I have also expressed concern about the trans spaces I spent five years in, where immediate medicalization is the goal and people unironically advocate for insane things such as making hormones available over the counter and giving puberty blockers to every single minor.