Alle verhalen

Een overlevende die nooit transitioneerde, en toch anderen waarschuwt

Vrouw · Gedesisteerd247
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde... nee — ik ben een vrouw die nooit is getransitioneerd en zich niet als trans identificeert; ik lees en post soms als buitenstaander in detrans- en gender-kritische ruimtes. Ik heb sterk kritische opvattingen over de transgenderbeweging, die volgens mij geworteld is in narcisme, en ik ben tegen puberteitsremmers en medische transitie voor kinderen; in 2022 waarschuwde ik een ouder voor blijvend verlies van seksuele functie. Mijn opvattingen zijn deels gevormd door seksueel misbruik en verkrachting in mijn kindertijd, en ik identificeer me als lesbienne met gender-kritisch feminisme. Ik heb anderen gewaarschuwd voor chirurgen en voor de onomkeerbare effecten van testosteron op vrouwen. Ik heb zelf geen transitiegerelateerde medische ingrepen ondergaan.

Volledig verhaal

I am a woman who has never transitioned and does not identify as trans; I have commented in detrans spaces as an outsider, and I want to lay out my views and what I've said over the years. I hold strong critical views of the transgender movement. As early as February 2019 I wrote that 'Transgender movement is rooted in' narcissism, and by November 2019 I stated plainly that 'Trans people are the narcissists - there's even studies proving it.' I have never been a detransitioner myself — in a November 2019 exchange I explicitly said 'I never comment in this sub as I'm not a detransitioner' and 'I just browse here,' though I acknowledged I had commented there that day. My hostility toward transition is partly rooted in personal trauma. In November 2019 I wrote that a lot of people's 'hatred of men' 'comes from a legitimate place of being abused and raped by them often as young children for a lot of us,' implying I was sexually abused as a child. I also wrote 'Nothing wrong with hating the sex class that is the reason for your oppression,' while clarifying 'I don't personally hate every single man on earth, but I do know men aren't inherently good for women and can't be feminists.' I identify as a lesbian and hold gender-critical (GC) views; in August 2019 I defended lesbians who wouldn't sleep with trans women, saying 'any real lesbian would not' and would make excuses rather than say 'you have a penis and aren't a woman.' I mentioned being banned from a men's rights activist subreddit and suggested my side should ask mods to 'just ban all GC people' if that's what they wanted. I have been active in detrans and critical online spaces, referencing r/NeovaginaDisasters, r/FtM, and r/detrans. In May 2019 I strongly warned someone against surgery with Brassard, saying he is known to 'butcher people' and directing them to reviews and r/NeovaginaDisasters. I have also commented on hormones: in May 2019 I told someone 'Hormones don't make you suicidal, your mental illness is,' and in July 2019 I laid out testosterone's permanent effects on women — 'hairless, permanent clitoral enlargement,' voice changes, and fat redistribution that reverses when you stop — saying 'I hate the effects testosterone has on women' and noting 'Estrogen on men hardly does anything they still look and sound like men.' I referenced Buck Angel's necrotic uterus post and pain reports on r/FtM. I am deeply critical of medicalizing gender-questioning youth. In August 2019 I called a case 'Munchausen's by proxy: gender style' and cautioned that doctors 'aren't infallible.' In July 2019 I reacted to a tragic death with anger 'contributed by the fucking transgender ideology.' In January 2022 I wrote a long warning to a parent of an 11-year-old son, urging them to 'look in to puberty blockers extensively,' citing Jazz Jennings as an example of a child whose 'penis remained child sized,' who 'has never had sexual feelings and will never have an orgasm' because of blockers. I argued it is 'disgusting to take away a child's sexual organ functioning and the ability to orgasm before they even know what one is,' that 'an 11 year old would trade their sexual health for the ability to be a girl,' and that it's the mother's job to decide whether 'essentially castrating your son' is worth it, adding 'Nothing wrong with him going through male puberty first and THEN deciding later if he wants to transition.' I also claimed trans activists 'deliberately ignore/avoid/falsify any scientific data that skews negatively towards transitioning and harass, intimidate and threaten researchers.' I have occasionally been supportive of individuals: in November 2019 I told someone 'You look healthy and I hope you're feeling it too! Lookin' good!' Overall I remain critical of transition, especially for youth, while not opposing adults' choices in every case.